Barbara's profile

Barbara's reviews

  5  
Barbara has 35 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Barbara's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, great negotiation, friendly, empathetic, supportive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Barbara truly cares about her client
over 3 years ago
Barbara truly cares about her client

Barbara truly cares about her client. My husband and I were on a home hunting journey for half a year. She helped us along the way. Every time when we went house viewing, she pointed out all the potential downside of the property. She is the type of broker that cares a lot. Thank you Barbara for your assistant. We are now happy in our new home:)

Seller review
Where do we begin? The short version is we met Barb trying to buy our first house
over 3 years ago
Where do we begin? The short version is we met Barb trying to buy our first house

Where do we begin? The short version is we met Barb trying to buy our first house. Our experience was so incredible as first time home buyers that 10 years later we immediately called Barb when it was time be first time home sellers! That speaks volumes of the level of trust, accountability, and service we found in Barb that 10 years later we still wanted her services. Barb stays connected with all her clients through social media, email, social event invitations, and more. She always remembers you - and she always remembers your family story. We always received the best care from Barb and her team (Thanks, Nathalie!) but also the additional contacts/service vendors she recommended. We had NO IDEA what we were doing either as buyers or sellers - but we learned so much through Barb and her partners. Barb is incredibly communicative, timely, and honest. We were sad to leave the area because that means we have to find someone else to entrust our future home buying/selling experiences. Thanks, Barb, for everything. - Rachel & Scott

Seller review
Barb proved to be incredibly supportive, caring, persistent, and knowledgeable in helping us find an
over 3 years ago
Barb proved to be incredibly supportive, caring, persistent, and knowledgeable in helping us find an

Barb proved to be incredibly supportive, caring, persistent, and knowledgeable in helping us find and purchase our new home. She was with us every step of the way, gently but effectively guiding us through the complexities of the home-buying process. She was always available to hear our concerns, answer our questions, and provide solid, practical advice without ever being pushy or impatient. Barb was a pleasure to work with and consistently impressed us with her competence and professionalism. Five stars are hardly enough to express our satisfaction!

Buyer review
Barbara is the absolute best! Not only did she help me and my fiancé find our dream home, but she is
over 3 years ago
Barbara is the absolute best! Not only did she help me and my fiancé find our dream home, but she is

Barbara is the absolute best! Not only did she help me and my fiancé find our dream home, but she is the most personable, funny, cheerful person in the business. It is very obvious that Barbara loves what she does, and she is great at it, too! She and her assistant, Nathalie, are always extremely responsive and communicate very effectively at every step along the way. Barbara is the most skilled real estate broker I have had the privilege to work with, and she cares so deeply about each of her clients, which is obvious in the work she puts into everything she does. Barbara is 5/5 stars – we highly recommend her!

Seller review
Barbara is amazing, very knowledgable and dedicated
almost 4 years ago
Barbara is amazing, very knowledgable and dedicated

Barbara is amazing, very knowledgable and dedicated. Attention to all detail and proactive on her client's behalf. Selling a co-op is complicated, so having someone who knows the market inside out, and is familiar with all the players is just what i needed, and Barb is best at this game! Highly recommended. Barb, thanks for being there every step of the way with me, and giving 100%! You're the best!

Buyer review
We used Barbara for the purchase of a condo in Peekskill, NY
almost 4 years ago
We used Barbara for the purchase of a condo in Peekskill, NY

We used Barbara for the purchase of a condo in Peekskill, NY. Such a smooth deal. From being organized and thorough with walk through’s, being a great Shepard for the negotiations, to getting us to the closing- she was the best real estate agent we have ever used. Thank you so much Barbara for everything. I highly recommend Barbara Bodner for your real estate needs.

Seller review
Barb is a true gem…knowledgeable, efficient, and personable
about 4 years ago
Barb is a true gem…knowledgeable, efficient, and personable

Barb is a true gem…knowledgeable, efficient, and personable. She handled every detail of our home sale process with skill. We received multiple offers on our house and she guided us through the process of selecting the best offer. And, she’s fun to work with, too!

Buyer review
5 stars don’t do justice to the magnificent job Barbara and her team has done for us
over 5 years ago
5 stars don’t do justice to the magnificent job Barbara and her team has done for us

5 stars don’t do justice to the magnificent job Barbara and her team has done for us. Always so professional and well informed about the whole selling/buying of a home takes. She walked us through every step as first time homebuyers and we couldn’t ask for more. Her kindness and professionalism made us feel comfortable and confident when we had a very long road to go. She just doesn’t sell houses she helps to make dreams come true. Forever grateful with her and her team for making possible for us to live in our dream home.

Seller review
My real estate transaction experience with Barbara Bodnar and Caldwell Banker was very good
about 6 years ago
My real estate transaction experience with Barbara Bodnar and Caldwell Banker was very good

My real estate transaction experience with Barbara Bodnar and Caldwell Banker was very good. The entire process including setting a selling price, the house photographes, the marketing and showing of the property were all done very professionally. The results of the process were excellent. The house was sold within 2 weeks and over the asking price. We received a number of valid offers and were able to ask for highest and best offer. If I were in the market of selling another house in the area, I would definitely use Barbara Bodnar as my realtor.

Seller review
I have worked with Barb three times now
over 6 years ago
I have worked with Barb three times now

I have worked with Barb three times now. She helped me purchase my first home, and then when it was time, sell that home and purchase my second home. Barb is incredibly knowledgeable and was always willing to spend time to talk out any questions I had. Barb always responds quickly and just generally makes the process go smoothly. I would definitely work with her again and have recommended her to several friends!

25 - 35 of 35
© 2026 RateMyAgent