Barbara's profile

Barbara's reviews

  5  
Barbara has 35 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Barbara's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, great negotiation, friendly, empathetic, supportive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
An excellent experience
almost 2 years ago
An excellent experience

Barbara is a magnificent realtor knowing everything that she should know and beyond. She did a professional, efficient job on the viewing to potential buyers and the selling of my mother’s condo. This all happened in a matter of weeks. I would highly recommend her.

Seller review
Great agent
almost 2 years ago
Great agent

Barb is a great agent who helped us everystep slong the way. Not only did she work with us on various options, helped us find a contractor, and keep us informed at every step, but also got us above asking price! She has high ethics and knows just about everybody! Highly recommend.

Seller review
Barbara made the selling process easy!
about 2 years ago
Barbara made the selling process easy!

I am so happy with my experience using Barbara as my agent. She made the process very easy and my apartment sold quickly for the price I was hoping for.

Buyer review
Professional and Caring
about 2 years ago
Professional and Caring

Barbara is super knowledgeable, truly an expert real estate agent! But more importantly, she is personable. She worked very hard to understand our wants and needs as clients, and was tenacious about getting us into the right house. She succeeded! We couldn't be happier. Thanks Barbara.

Seller review
Best agent
over 2 years ago
Best agent

Once again Barbara Bodnar has represented me, this time for the sale of my home. And, like my previous experience with Barbara, when my husband and I worked with her as buyers, she has consistently proved to be the best. Barbara is professional and experienced. And her assistant Nathalie is terrific. She knows how to make things happen while being delightful to work with!

Buyer review
Fabulous Broker!
over 2 years ago
Fabulous Broker!

In the spring of 2022, my husband and I decided that we wanted to buy a home in the Hudson Valley.Having family in Dutchess County, we spent time in the area and discovered its wonderful cultural and natural qualities.A broker we knew in NYC had worked on a sale with Barbara Bodnar at Coldwell Banker in the Yorktown office, and highly recommended her to us. Buying a house is not easy.It takes perseverance.You need a broker who is not just experienced, but also one who is professional and patient.You need a broker who communicates well, who has integrity and truly cares about your interests. It doesn’t hurt if you really like them and enjoy spending time with them. This is an important relationship. I’m describing Barbara, and our relationship with her. Along the way, Barbara cautioned us when necessary, negotiated when needed and understood when we were discouraged. We learned that she had a previous career as a social worker, and rapidly understood how she used those skills in the entire process. After a long and difficult search, and after submitting bids on multiple properties that didn’t pan out, we found just the right property. Finding a house you like enough to submit an offer and getting an offer accepted is only the first step. You want to know that you are making the right decision. Barbara connected us to a trusted network of professionals that included her indispensable assistant Nathalie, a home inspector, a general contractor, an electrician, a radon remediator, a security company, an appraiser and a company for window treatments – all expert and terrific to work with. It is easy to feel overwhelmed by the “to do” list around buying a home, let alone find expert and reliable professionals. Barbara and her network gave us confidence that we chose the right home pre-sale and could help us make the property the home we wanted post-sale. We finally closed on our house in April of this year. We could not have done it without Barbara. She is a gem.

Buyer review
Barb Bodnar is the best!
over 2 years ago
Barb Bodnar is the best!

Barb proved to be incredibly supportive, caring, persistent, and knowledgeable in helping us find and purchase our new home. She was with us every step of the way, gently but effectively guiding us through the complexities of the home-buying process. She was always available to hear our concerns, answer our questions, and provide solid, practical advice without ever being pushy or impatient. Barb was a pleasure to work with and consistently impressed us with her competence and professionalism. Five stars are hardly enough to express our satisfaction!

Seller review
A true professional
over 2 years ago
A true professional

Barbara deserves more than a 5 star rating. She went above and beyond with helping to sell our previous house and with the purchase of our new home. Barbara is extremely knowledgeable with all the details involved with buying and selling and always looks out for her clients best interest.

Seller review
Professional with team approach
over 2 years ago
Professional with team approach

Barbara is a knowledgeable real estate pro who worked with me through every step of the selling process. If you are looking for someone to be on top of everything and then some, I suggest you give Barbara Bodnar a call.

Seller review
Sales agent
almost 3 years ago
Sales agent

Barbara is a very knowledgeable agent from start to finish We were kept updated throughout the whole sales process. Our best interest was always kept in mind

Seller review
Professional service beyond my expectations.
almost 3 years ago
Professional service beyond my expectations.

Barbara evaluated and listed our condo and within one day we had substantial activity. Barbara’s knowledge of the business, the community and geographic area made the process carefree.

Buyer review
Great Experience
over 3 years ago
Great Experience

Barbara has been our agent for almost three years but it feels like we have known her a lifetime. Barb’s extensive knowledge experience and professionalism has landed us two great homes that we love! She has patience and great communication skills. She made us feel as if we were her only clients and like family. If we could give six stars we would!

13 - 24 of 35
© 2026 RateMyAgent