Deborah's profile

Deborah's reviews

  5  
Deborah has 160 reviewsacross 46 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Deborah's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, honest, friendly, clear communication, supportive, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
LOOK NO FURTHER!
over 2 years ago
LOOK NO FURTHER!

This was our second time looking for a house with the Deborah, so we already knew we were in great hands. We were a little nervous with this purchase as the home was a bit neglected as the homeowner was sick but we loved the space and saw much potential. It was definitely an almost flip and so much more to do but we got it for a steal in a great area and town.

Buyer review
Fantastic experience with Deborah!
over 2 years ago
Fantastic experience with Deborah!

My husband and I had an enjoyable and effortless experience working with Deborah. She was referred by friends who had just worked with her to purchase their dream house, so we knew we were in good hands, but Deborah still exceeded our expectations. Her knowledge of the bigger real estate landscape coupled with her specific local intel makes her an essential partner for anyone buying a house in the NJ areas she services. What really sets her apart is her wealth of knowledge on houses and property - she sees things that other agents (or even inspectors!) might miss, and this allows her to give a highly informed opinion. We trusted her guidance at every turn, and she took the time to understand what was most important to us and find us the perfect home. We couldn't recommend her more highly!

Seller review
Home Sold Fast
over 2 years ago
Home Sold Fast

Home sold right away over ask and was very responsive through process.

Seller review
Simply the Best!
over 2 years ago
Simply the Best!

Deborah Citerella has been fantastic throughout the selling and buying process. Knowledgeable, professional and tenacious to get you your deal. We were able to reach her at anytime. Deborah had made herself available to show us houses. We would use Deborah again if we needed her. We would highly recommend this agent.

Buyer review
Deborah was excellent to work with
over 2 years ago
Deborah was excellent to work with

Deborah was excellent to work with. She made sure that we were taken care of. She is very knowledgeable on homes and especially the inner workings of homes which is tremendously helpful for new home owners.

Seller review
Deborah was exceptional!
over 2 years ago
Deborah was exceptional!

Deborah was exceptional in her assistance to us in our selling our home from the beginning to end - from her knowledge of the market, appropriate asking price point, negotiations, suggestions for repairs in the home to make, references for subbing out jobs, and help to us in preparing the house itself, and closing. She was involved and she was always available and responsive to our inquiries. Deborah Citarella has our HIGHEST recommendation!

Seller review
Deborah was exceptional in her assistance to us in our selling our home from the beginning to end -
over 2 years ago
Deborah was exceptional in her assistance to us in our selling our home from the beginning to end -

Deborah was exceptional in her assistance to us in our selling our home from the beginning to end - from her knowledge of the market, appropriate asking price point, negotiations, suggestions for repairs in the home to make, references for subbing out jobs, and help to us in preparing the house itself, and closing. She was involved and she was always available and responsive to our inquiries. Deborah Citarella has our HIGHEST recommendation!

Buyer review
Amazing experience and I am lucky that I found Deborah
over 2 years ago
Amazing experience and I am lucky that I found Deborah

Amazing experience and I am lucky that I found Deborah. Knows the neighborhood and the market. Very realistic with her advice and totally accurate, incredibly efficient with my time. She really understood what my needs were with the budget and the kind of property, and tailored things for me in a practical and useful way. She also advocated through a very difficult set of seller-counterparts and continued to help after the closing with recommendations on contractors, local services, and even taking on some handiwork projects herself in order to make the transaction easier for me. Would definitely recommend.

Buyer review
Deborah was amazing to work with when buying my condo
over 2 years ago
Deborah was amazing to work with when buying my condo

Deborah was amazing to work with when buying my condo. I was coming into the area from out of state and she was able to help me narrow my search. When a suitable condo became available, she picked me up at the airport, drove me to see it, and then drove me back to the airport. I bought during a hot market so her ability to act quickly and recommend an appropriate bid ultimately got me the property. Since I was unfamiliar with the area, Deborah also used her contacts to help me secure financing, an inspector, and some renovation contacts post-purchase. I can highly recommend Deborah if you're looking to buy in New Jersey.

Buyer review
We felt very well taken care of by Deborah
almost 3 years ago
We felt very well taken care of by Deborah

We felt very well taken care of by Deborah. Her negotiation skills were top-notch and she was able to secure our dream home for a fantastic price. She was always available and went the extra mile to make sure we were comfortable throughout the process. I highly recommend her to anyone who is trying to buy their dream home!

25 - 36 of 160
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent