Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 25 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Andy's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Top notch experience
about 1 year ago
Top notch experience

Andy was great, from the initial meeting, listing, time in between and at the closing. Always there to answer questions/calls.

Seller review
Excellent agent to work with!
about 1 year ago
Excellent agent to work with!

Andy was always helpful. He was kind and generous with his time and knowledge. Always offering to help in any way. I felt really blessed to have him as my agent. The experience was as good as it could be.

Seller review
Suprtb in all three areas
over 1 year ago
Suprtb in all three areas

Andy was a wonderful realtor. He was thoughtful, friendly and always supportive in matters. He went that second mile.

Seller review
Andy is the BEST!
over 1 year ago
Andy is the BEST!

In a tough housing market, Andy got the job done! He simply is the best. He was honest with what was needed, he worked hard, and got the results we needed. Andy was ALWAYS on it and he was in constant contact with us! He was always patient and answered all of our questions. He is always prepared. We can't say enough great things about Andy. We highly, HIGHLY recommend Andy Reynolds and we are so thankful for him. If you need a real estate agent - look no further and hire Andy Reynolds!

Seller review
Outstanding !
over 1 year ago
Outstanding !

So glad I chose Andy as my Agent. Andy’s knowledge of the lake and his years of experience selling homes helped to expedited the sale of my home. Andy kept me informed and encouraged me the whole time. Thank you Andy Reynolds !

Buyer review
Andy has always been professional!
over 1 year ago
Andy has always been professional!

Andy was very pleasant to deal with. He understood my needs for a rental property and helped with all the questions we had! thank you Andy!

Seller review
Problem-solving expertise with genuine care and support
over 1 year ago
Problem-solving expertise with genuine care and support

Andy Reynolds demonstrated excellent problem-solving skills when issues arose regarding repairs. He quickly sought a solution to the issues and brought about a resolve without a delay to the closing. Andy provided support and relentless communication throughout the process.

Buyer review
He is there for you
over 1 year ago
He is there for you

Andy is very easy to work with

Buyer review
WHEN ONLY THE BEST WILL DO
over 1 year ago
WHEN ONLY THE BEST WILL DO

ANDY REYNOLDS IS AN UNIQUE, PROFESSIONAL THAT REALLY CARES ABOUT HIS CLIENTS AND WE HAVE BOUGHT AND SOLD SEVERAL HOMES IN THE LAKE WYLIE AREA THROUGH ANDY AND ALL WITHOUT A SINGLE ISSUE. BEFORE I RETIRED, I WAS THE PRESIDENT OF ONE OF FLORIDA'S LARGEST REAL ESTATE FIRMS, SO I KNOW A GREAT REALTOR WHEN I SEE ONE AND ANDY IS TRULY ONE OF THE BEST AND IS WHO WE CALL UPON TO ASSIST US IN BUYING OR SELLING A LAKE WYLIE HOME. WE LIVE IN FLORIDA AND ARE MOVING BACK TO LAKE WYLIE AND JUST BOUGHT A BEAUTIFUL LAKE WYLIE LAKE FRONT HOME AND GUESS WHO WE CALLED TO ASSIST US ?? YES, YOU GUESSED CORRECTLY, WE CALLED ANDY AND RUDDER, LAKE WYLIE'S PREMIRE REAL ESTATE TEAM AND WE HIGHLY RECOMMEND THEM !!

Seller review
Excellent Realtor
over 1 year ago
Excellent Realtor

My husband and I recently hired Andy to sell our house. Based on comparable properties and general knowledge of the market and the area, Andy helped us set the asking price. Soon after hiring Andy, he quickly uploaded the listing along with a video and pictures to MLS. The first weekend after the listing was posted, Andy held an open house. This made us extremely happy. We were not living in the house and did not live close by. Therefore, every time there was a showing, Andy would go by our house and turn on the lights, check the thermostat, check the pool for leaves, etc. After a showing, Andy would go back to the house and turn off the lights, etc. Andy also kept us informed on comments after showings. When we received an offer, Andy gave us excellent advice on how we should respond. His negotiating skills with the buyer's agent resulted in a contract that made us extremely happy. Andy helped make selling our house very easy. Andy was easy to work with, professional, responsive, knowledgeable and helpful. He also worked well with the buyer's agent. We highly recommend Andy Reynolds.

Seller review
Knows his stuff.
over 1 year ago
Knows his stuff.

Andy helped us sell our house. He is a knowledgeable, no-nonsense professional. His negotiation skills and experience were very evident. An overall hassle-free experience.

13 - 24 of 25
© 2026 RateMyAgent