Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 29 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Andy's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Best Realtor in the Carolinas
about 1 month ago
Best Realtor in the Carolinas

Words cannot express the gratitude I have for Mr. Andy. I have known Andy for years through my parents and have been working with him for the past 8 months to find my first home. If I had/have a question, he’s there for me every time. If I contacted him about a potential option, he immediately jumped on it, no questions asked. His customer service is outstanding but so is his knowledge. Being a first time buyer, he educated me through the whole process and answered questions I didn’t even know to ask. His negotiations were amazing, if he thought he could get a better deal, he’d go to work and push as hard as he could. Before this process Andy was another cool guy I knew but now, he has became a great friend. Took the time to be personal with me and be a great person. I’m sure everyone that Andy works with get this same exact experience because of how natural and easy he is about his processes. Last but not least, who else in the real estate industry is a badass that races boats at 214mph? Only Andy

Buyer review
Patient, knowledgeable, and encouraging we would find our perfect home.
about 1 month ago
Patient, knowledgeable, and encouraging we would find our perfect home.

Andy was incredibly patient and supportive throughout our entire home-buying journey. We searched for nearly a year, and he guided us every step of the way with professionalism, knowledge, and genuine care. Andy was extremely insightful when it came to identifying potential concerns in homes, considering future resale value, and ensuring overall safety and quality. What stood out most was the confidence and peace of mind he gave us throughout the process. It was reassuring to know he would never recommend a home he wouldn’t feel comfortable placing his own family in. Andy consistently checked in, kept us informed, and made sure everything moved as smoothly as possible from start to finish. We are truly grateful to have chosen Andy as our realtor and cannot thank him enough for his patience, encouragement, and unwavering support throughout this experience.

Seller review
Working with Andy as our seller’s agent was a great experience!
about 1 month ago
Working with Andy as our seller’s agent was a great experience!

Working with Andy as our seller’s agent was a great experience! He was very realistic about the price point he suggested for our home and didn’t try to inflate the listing price just to “win” our business like some other agents did. We appreciated his honesty and transparency from day one. Andy was always checking in, responsive, and incredibly helpful throughout the process. He even helped with handyman-related issues and was always there whenever we had questions. His knowledge of the area is unmatched, and it really showed. Thank you, Andy!

Seller review
excellent job marketing my home!
about 1 month ago
excellent job marketing my home!

Very responsive. A pleasure to work with. Strong knowledge in lakefront property

Seller review
Experienced Sale made easy!!
about 2 months ago
Experienced Sale made easy!!

It was wonderful working with Andy as he is very familiar an d experienced with the area and the market. He provided key information that led to the timely sale of our home. His market knowledge was vital to the pricing and marketing he provided. Andy is great at communicating everything going on with your transaction. He contacted people who were able to help and provide info for home inspection questions. He is very good at getting back to you quickly with anything you may throw his way. Would highly recommend Andy for your real estate needs. He makes the process so easy and less stressful than it has to be.

Buyer review
Exceptional Experience from Start to Finish
3 months ago
Exceptional Experience from Start to Finish

We had an outstanding experience working with Andy Reynolds. From the very beginning, Andy was incredibly patient, kind, and fully committed to helping us find the perfect home. He took the time to understand exactly what we were looking for and never made us feel rushed or pressured. His knowledge of the area and expertise in the market were invaluable, giving us confidence in every decision we made. Andy was always responsive, professional, and willing to go above and beyond to ensure we felt informed and comfortable throughout the entire process. Thanks to Andy, we found our dream home, and we couldn’t be more grateful. Having him by our side from the first showing to the final steps made all the difference. We highly recommend Andy to anyone looking for a dedicated, knowledgeable, and trustworthy real estate agent.

Buyer review
Impressive knowledge and a pleasure to work with
4 months ago
Impressive knowledge and a pleasure to work with

We had an outstanding experience working with our realtor, Andy Reynolds, while searching for a home or lot to build our home in the Lake Wylie area. From the beginning, he was extremely professional and took the time to truly understand what we wanted. His knowledge of the Lake Wylie market was impressive, and he helped us identify a property that was exactly right for our needs. Communication throughout the entire process was excellent. He is always responsive, quick to answer questions, and kept us informed every step of the way. Andy’s insight made a huge difference and gave us confidence in our decision. Overall, Andy is incredibly easy to work with—knowledgeable, attentive, and dedicated to helping us find the right property. We would highly recommend him!

Seller review
On Top Of It!
7 months ago
On Top Of It!

Working with Andy was an exceptional experience. Andy communicated clearly and consistently throughout the entire process, making sure I understood each step and always feeling supported. His market expertise and attention to detail made everything run smoothly, and his friendly, patient approach made what could have been a stressful experience truly enjoyable. Whether it was answering questions, handling paperwork, or navigating negotiations, Andy went above and beyond. I’m extremely happy with the outcome and would highly recommend Andy to anyone looking for a reliable, experienced, and dedicated real estate agent.

Seller review
Andy Reynolds - THE Lake Wylie Expert
9 months ago
Andy Reynolds - THE Lake Wylie Expert

Andy exceeded my expectations as a listing agent. From the very beginning, he provided a clear strategy for pricing, marketing, and presenting my home in the best possible way. His knowledge of the local market and attention to detail ensured that my property stood out, and he was always available to answer questions and provide honest, thoughtful advice. Andy’s professionalism, strong communication skills, and commitment to my best interests gave me complete confidence throughout the process. Thanks to his guidance, the sale was smooth, efficient, and successful. I would highly recommend Andy to anyone looking for a reliable and dedicated real estate professional to sell their home.

Buyer review
House purchase
11 months ago
House purchase

Andy was so helpful with the process of purchasing the house. He guidedus through everything we needed to do . I highly recommend Andy to anyone looking for a home.

Seller review
A trusted real estate partner over the years
12 months ago
A trusted real estate partner over the years

Andy was both our buy side agent when we bought our house 9 years ago and sell side when we moved on this past summer. Andy was a great partner both times. We ended up getting multiple offers, including above ask, on our house sale and also helped us manage through the contract period to closing. Appreciated working with Andy over the years. Although we have moved out of the CLT area, we would gladly work with him again if we ever came back.

Buyer review
Sold, bought and moved with Andy’s help!
12 months ago
Sold, bought and moved with Andy’s help!

Andy was great to work with. He helped me sell my home. Keep me up to date on comparisons in may neighborhood. Had 2 people interested and went to contract and closed 18 days later on my new home. He helped me with many phones calls whenever I called! Thanks Andy!

1 - 12 of 29
© 2026 RateMyAgent