Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 100 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Andy's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, friendly, well-prepared, dedicated, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Would have gotten 5 stars except...
over 1 year ago
Would have gotten 5 stars except...

Great service! Returned calls promptly, arrived at appointments on time or early and was a pleasure to do business with. The only reason he didn't get 5 stars was one mistake. He said the gas bill was paid by the utility and it is actually my responsibility. This was no big deal really. Just a disappointment.

Seller review
Home sold quickly
over 1 year ago
Home sold quickly

We’ve bought and sold numerous properties in our lifetime. Andy is definitely one of the best realtors we’ve had the pleasure of working with, from beginning to end. There wasn’t but a few days when we didn’t hear from one or both Andy and Michelle. Yes, in our case we had two agents, both worked together to get our house ready and sold. His attention to detail was obvious, From having excellent photos taken to an outstanding listing on mls. To top it off A full price offer says it all!

Seller review
A breath of fresh air
over 1 year ago
A breath of fresh air

He will do what he says in a timely manner. He is never pushy, in fact he looks for things to improve and is always helpful. He knows the market well. He and Michelle put together a great sales plan. So good, the house sold before it actually listed. I would use Andy again if a need arises.

Seller review
Excellent Agent
over 1 year ago
Excellent Agent

Andy Anderson is an excellent agent and would highly recommend him. Very professional agent.

Buyer review
ROCKSTAR REALTOR!
over 1 year ago
ROCKSTAR REALTOR!

Andy has become our go-to for all things real estate! We met him as the listing agent on a property we wanted to purchase and quickly found him to be very thorough, professional, and knowledgeable—a great experience. Fast forward a few months, a property we really wanted and have kept an eye on unexpectedly came on the market. I knew we needed Andy on this one. We called him after the business hour on a Friday night, and he answered. In true Andy Anderson style, by the following morning, we were informed the listing agent had already received a tentative, informal (verbal) offer, but Andy's quick action and professional savvy put us in position to submit a competitive bid, and our offer accepted! Andy goes above and beyond with the utmost integrity and professionalism. He is tenacious and genuinely looks out for everyone's best interests. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND Andy Anderson.

Buyer review
Andy is a terrific person!
almost 2 years ago
Andy is a terrific person!

Andy is very knowledgeable about the area as well as the different aspects of houses. He tuned in to what we were looking for very quickly and made it a mission to find us the perfect house!! And we had so much fun 😁 while looking!! We highly recommend using Andy for a fun and successful house search!

Buyer review
2nd Home Purchase
almost 2 years ago
2nd Home Purchase

I reached out to the realty company and Andy was assigned to me and my brother. We had very specific criteria and budget for it home and I provided 2 extensive lists of properties for us to look at. Because both of us live out of town we felt most comfortable looking at property before making an offer. We purchased the house we made our second offer on. Andy did his best to accommodate our travel times and facilitated an easy closing. We look forward to our 2nd home.

Buyer review
Andy Exceeded our expectations in every way possible.
about 2 years ago
Andy Exceeded our expectations in every way possible.

Andy is very knowledgeable in the market we looked for and communicated to us often in each matter. His professionalism pleasantly became apparent to us upon our first meeting.

Seller review
Team Andy Anderson & Michelle Metcalf
about 2 years ago
Team Andy Anderson & Michelle Metcalf

Andy Anderson & Michelle Metcalf are a formidable Team. This is a full-time career for both of them and the RESULTS are positive. Their unique skills are Integrity, Professionalism, Encouragement, Experience, Strategies, Marketing, and a tireless Work Ethic. They are available to communicate, communicate, and communicate by text, email, or phone. They exceeded our expectations and I highly recommend them for all your Real Estate needs.

Buyer review
Above-and-Beyond
about 2 years ago
Above-and-Beyond

We contacted Andy to inquire on one of his listings. We quickly found Andy to be very thorough with details about the property, and he offered to do additional research on anything we had a question about that he couldn’t answer immediately (which was very little), and offered more detail we had not considered. We decided to have Andy represent us as buyers, as well, based on our initial experience. Andy was easy to get a hold of anytime, throughout our property purchase. He was quick to offer to do additional footwork or research, and followed up with an email and phone call to make sure we were as informed as possible. He accompanied us to see other properties we were considering, as well. He made this entire transaction so easy and pleasant! Andy is easygoing, honest and professional—he absolutely goes above-and beyond, even when he doesn’t have to (when you are not his client). We have worked with several really good realtors in the past and plan on making additional real estate purchases in the coming months. Based on this experience and getting to know him through it, Andy would be our first choice to work with and represent us for any future transactions!

Seller review
Professional, thorough, knowledgeable & responsive
about 2 years ago
Professional, thorough, knowledgeable & responsive

We contacted Andy after our prior realtor was not as responsive as we needed him to be. Andy basically made the deal happen; he made several trips to the site, researched information pertinent to our land that really made the sale happen, and negotiated the issues that convinced the buyer to go through with the purchase. Andy was very communicative during the process and always answered his phone within a timely manner. He’s very friendly and personable as well. Would give him 10 stars if possible!

73 - 84 of 100
© 2026 RateMyAgent