Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 66 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
almost 5 years ago
Very proactive and highly engaged

Amy was a fantastic agent. She gave us a good summary of the market and helped us price out house appropriately. We had an offer within two days!

almost 5 years ago
Amy is the best!!!

In this crazy market you would think anyone could sell your house and get you over asking. But after jumping into the process of selling our home, I quickly realized that we need a professional who knew their stuff. Amy was exactly that agent! She walked us through our double digit offer list, broke down the pros and cons of all the offers, and helped us land the best offer for us! Not only did we get a great offer, but she made it super easy for us to walk through this process. If you are in the greater Winter Haven area, I highly recommend you contact Amy!

about 5 years ago
Amy Reynolds

Overall Amy was there to help me whenever needed; as first time home buyer it was a new experience but she was able to answer my questions and help me through this process.

about 5 years ago
Exceptional Customer Service and Knowledge!

Amy has served as our realtor three times over the past 10 years- helping us buy and sell homes! She is incredibly knowledgeable and provides exceptional customer service! We were on a very tight timeline with our last move, and Amy worked diligently to ensure everything was on schedule and efficient. Amy thoughtfully guides her clients through the entire home buying process. She is highly skilled and passionate about her job! We recommend Amy to anyone buying or selling a home in Polk County!

about 5 years ago
Excellent agent

Amy is very easy to work with and is always kind and professional. She goes the extra mile for her clients and we highly recommend her!

about 5 years ago
Amazing Experience Buying Our New Home

Amy Reynolds was wonderful to work with when looking for our new home. We were looking for over 7 months, she was always patient and never made us feel rushed. When we finally found the home we were in love with she guided us on aspects that we were unfamiliar with at the time. Especially with the insane real estate market we have found ourselves in. She was always quick and responsive to everything that we came across. We highly recommend working her!

over 5 years ago
4 offers in 1 day!

Amy Reynolds helped us to sell our home for more than asking price. She is market knowledgeable, priced our house well and was flexible on the price. I was particularly appreciative of her rapid response to many questions I had about the process and steps. She was professional and scheduled many showings the first night and next day after listing our home. She sent us the 4 offers and explained each so we could get the best deal. Amy Reynolds was an awesome realtor.

over 5 years ago
Best realtor!

Working with Amy was the best experience! We will continue to use her expertise!

over 5 years ago
could not have been any better

Amy is very professional and knows her stuff, yet she is very friendly and genuinely nice. I really enjoyed working with her, and she knows how to make you feel at ease. She is honest and up-front. I like that.

over 5 years ago
Knowledgeable

Amy was wonderful to work with, very knowledgeable and kept us up to date on the entire process.

37 - 48 of 66
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent