Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 66 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Outstanding Realtor

Amy has assisted my family with approx 11 homes being sold and bought, we do not trust anyone else with our properties.

over 3 years ago
Rare realator, driven by complete client satisfaction not $$$$

Amy treated us like family. She kept our expressed home and neighborhood necessities on the forefront to align with our desired budget range. Her ability to respond and execute action with limited time was impeccable. We had worked with two realtors prior to Amy who were not able to sympathize with our situation in order for us to move swiftly. We called upon other members of our family (who live in Florida) to do in person, home walk-through and overall assessments since we reside several states away. Amy was completely accommodating to work with us in that capacity to ensure we did not miss out on housing opportunities due to our adverse distance logistics. Our only regret is that we did not work with Amy from the very beginning of our journey.

over 3 years ago
Excellent Realtor

Amy did a great job selling our home. We were out of state when our home was sold and it couldn't have been handled any more professional then what it was. When we purchase a home in the area in the future we will definitely consider Amy as our realtor. It was a pleasure having her sell our home that we were in more then thirty years. Thanks again Amy!

over 3 years ago
I had an amazing experience, I didn't know anything but she made sure I understood everything.

What a joy and blessings working with Mrs Amy, the knowledge of understanding the value of other properties in the surrounding area. Assisting you with what types of inspection maybe needed for your protection. Very beautiful, warm and caring spirit. She communicated with me though out the entire process and very professional. An amazing journey and I'm so grateful to have shared it with you and I'm going that say it was part of the Master's plan. May you continue to be blessed for being a blessing to me and my home buying experience. Gail

about 4 years ago
Very patient and helpful 💛

Amy was always available to assist when we wanted to see a home. She is very professional, thoughtful snd patient.

over 4 years ago
Winterhaven sale

Amy knows the local market and rental market very well. She shows up and does the hard work other do not. I have worked with many agents and she is the best in her area. Thanks Amy for your hard work

over 4 years ago
Winterhaven Landlord

Amy supported us as manager for our property in Auburndale for nine years, she was very attentive and available to help us as landlords and our tenants as well. Organizing repairs, keeping on tops of the multiple issues and the occasional 'challenging' situations that we all face in renting real estate. We have sold our units and the tenants were saddened to learn that she would no longer be managing the properties. We would recommend Amy to anyone looking for a property manager.

over 4 years ago
Excellent and experienced realtor

Amy was very efficient and was always available to speak whatever the time. Good at updates and firstly very knowledgeable.

over 4 years ago
Amy is the best!

The process of purchasing your first home can be stressful and overwhelming. But, we were so lucky to have miss Amy! Amy took so much of the stress off of our shoulders. She was incredibly organized and punctual, every time we sent her a new house we were able to view it that day. Every time we went to look at a new house she was prepared with good insight into each house and answered every question we had. She treated us like family and helped us get into our first home!

almost 5 years ago
Excellent Experience!

I had an excellent experience with Amy for my recent home purchase. She is very friendly, professional, and knowledgeable about our area and the process. Everything was easy and went smoothly and quickly. Anytime I had questions or concerns she answered them promptly and made sure I was kept up to date with each step of the process. I highly recommend Amy for buying or selling a home!

almost 5 years ago
FIVE STAR +++++

I WOULD BE HAPPY TO REFER HER AS A REPUTABLE AND RELIABLE REALTOR

almost 5 years ago
Don't go anywhere else!

Amy is a resourceful, hard working, and professional full time realtor who gets results. Amy is knowledgeable of the local market and its trends. If you are buying or selling in Winter Haven, don't go anywhere else - just go to Amy Reynolds.

25 - 36 of 66
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent