Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 42 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, patient, friendly, empathetic, supportive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Amy - My real estate SUPERWOMAN!!
over 4 years ago
Amy - My real estate SUPERWOMAN!!

When I contacted Amy to sell my home (via referral of my neighbors who also had a great experience with her), she took time to understand my goals and timeline surrounding a possible move. She set very real expectations for the sale and price - except she exceeded them all! She sold our home barely 4 hours on the market, but negotiated appropriate terms so we had time to find a new one. Keeping in touch with me, she learned about the troubles I was having finding a new place out of state and naturally I trusted her suggestions for a possible move staying in NC. Sure enough, she found us THE PERFECT PROPERTY - and even made sure we didn’t pay more for it than we needed to! Not only did both closings happen exactly as planned, we made more money on the sale and spent less than we expected on our dream home! Needless to say, AMY IS MY HERO! She is trustworthy, professional, super easy to work with and has my highest recommendations!

Buyer review
Amazing Co-Pilot on your journey to find your home!
over 4 years ago
Amazing Co-Pilot on your journey to find your home!

Amy was an absolute pleasure from the first time we met. She was transparent, laid out her process, and was consistent in her execution. Whether it was listening, ensuring I was mindful of certain aspects, or providing a best-in-class market analysis in today's grossly competitive market, I felt at ease and prepared every step of the way. Amy's expertise is only dwarfed by the quality human she is. Over the course of my home journey, I learned a ton about her life story and she truly cared about the difficult nature of why I was searching for my second home even giving me life advice. I started this journey as someone feeling down, nervous, and uncertain which has never been the kind of person I was ...But I finished my journey with an amazing house and a new dear friend in Amy.

Seller review
Peace of mind in a time of stress
about 5 years ago
Peace of mind in a time of stress

Amy has been the rock I needed to sell my townhome while helping a loved one through heart surgery and recovery at the same time. She was there every step of the way to be sure that the process went smoothly, I felt comfortable, and make sure every “i” was dotted and every “t” was crossed. She even went out of her way to meet with a plumber to resolve a quick issue when I couldn’t be there myself! Truly above and beyond while maintaining the highest level of professionalism and compassion. I am thrilled to be working with her on the purchase of our next home and would highly recommend her to everyone!

Buyer review
Extremely helpful, reliable, and trustworthy for First Time Homebuyers
about 5 years ago
Extremely helpful, reliable, and trustworthy for First Time Homebuyers

Amy was phenomenal! We were first time homebuyers and didn't always know what questions to ask. She was always two steps ahead of us guiding us throughout the entire process. She gave suggestions were needed and always made sure we were in agreement and understood things before making any decision. She was always quick to answer our calls, texts, and emails - communication is so important during such a huge process and Amy is and was a 10! I know we would not have been able to close on our dream home without Amy's help. She was truly a blessing for us and our family. We are very grateful for her services and for her friendship. I would highly recommend Amy Donahoo to anyone looking to purchase a home.

Buyer review
THE Agent (Amy Donahoo)
over 5 years ago
THE Agent (Amy Donahoo)

I’ll tell you this, Amy is a different type of agent. Someone that I honestly felt was looking out for us like a family member. We were so lucky to be assigned to her because she was a leader, mother, coach, etc through this whole process. The number 1 thing we valued was her honesty and not being afraid to speak up. There is nothing at all that makes me feel as though she didn’t have our best interest at heart because I was just blown away by how she conducts business. Being a Real Estate Agent to me needs to be more of a human that does Real Estate and that’s who Amy is. We are thankful for Amy and truly know there couldn’t be another agent to provide the service Amy did. Honestly, we didn’t have the words to describe this experience but we hope you see the value of Amy Donahoo.

Buyer review
Very informative, friendly, & patient. She knew exactly what I wanted...
over 5 years ago
Very informative, friendly, & patient. She knew exactly what I wanted...

Amy was match made in heaven! She came to be my realtor via a program with my lender and I couldn't have asked for a better person. She was patient with me & my questions. I'm a research type of person but Amy took the time to educate me on things to look for & take into consideration that I didn't even think of and found me the perfect place. She is a wonderful listener, letting you think out your thoughts and providing unbias perspective made me feel completely comfortable & confident in her abilities. She will not disappoint!

Buyer review
Relocated with ease
over 5 years ago
Relocated with ease

Amy did a great job in navigating our first home purchase in a new state and new town. We were able to house hunt just in one weekend and Amy made sure we could see every home we wanted and suggested a few that fit our vibe. She was helpful in pointing out aspects of each home that we didn't consider and helped us realize what would work best for our lifestyle. Amy was professional, friendly, and made the process relatively stress free. She was readily available to answer any questions we had and did a great job of keeping us in the loop of what was going on throughout the purchase process. The communication was AWESOME and much appreciated since we were buying from out of state. And of course Amy is just a very kind person and you can tell she loves what she does and is a pleasure to be around. 10/10 recommend!

Buyer review
Great Experience
over 5 years ago
Great Experience

What a great time we had finding the perfect fixer upper! The only bad part about buying my house is that I didn't get to hang out with Amy any more!

Buyer review
The finest service a realtor can give!
over 5 years ago
The finest service a realtor can give!

Amy was great in listening to our many needs, wants and dreams. She was able to help us in obtaining our home and working out the nuisances that came along the way! Amy and Phillip were recommended from a family friend and I can see why! I would recommend Amy to anyone in need of a realtor!

Buyer review
Amy found us our perfect home!
over 5 years ago
Amy found us our perfect home!

We were relocating to the Raleigh area from out of state. We had done a bit of research ahead of time to see what was on the market, but Amy was able to show us properties that we didn’t even know were available. We ended up buying a new construction home that Amy showed us, but didn’t come up in any of the online searching that my wife and I did on our own. And we love it! Amy was happy to talk on the phone with us anytime we called her. We had so many questions as first time home buyers and Amy’s knowledge and experience helped us navigate the whole process with ease. She was always happy to answer our questions and always did so quickly. The private home inspector she recommended is top-knotch. Amy advocated for us throughout the whole process and was constantly asking smart questions to our builder that we would have never thought to ask on our own. We highly recommend hiring Amy as your real estate agent. She helped us out a ton and we would not have been able to navigate the real estate market without her!

Buyer review
Knowledgeable and Creditable
almost 6 years ago
Knowledgeable and Creditable

Any and her team treated us with A+ service. Her experience in all aspects of Real Estate shows, because no question went unanswered. Communication is clear and concise. Amy goes above and beyond any expectations of an agent. Thank you!!!

Seller review
Phil and Amy are marvelous to put it lightly.
almost 6 years ago
Phil and Amy are marvelous to put it lightly.

Phil and Amy are marvelous to put it lightly. They feel like family within 10 seconds of meeting them. Their caring for you is felt instantly. They really are concerned that you find what you need, that you receive what you need, and that you move into what you need. If you're selling, they look after you equally so. I have been in over 20 homes in these last 60 years and believe me I really wish all the realtors I've met in my life were like Phil and Amy Donahoo

25 - 36 of 42
© 2026 RateMyAgent