Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 42 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, patient, friendly, empathetic, supportive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
She’s the Best!
almost 2 years ago
She’s the Best!

I could not recommend Amy more to others, especially first time home buyers! Amy came so prepared to every meeting - she knew all the right questions to ask us, as well as the selling agents. She is responsive, observant, knowledgeable, adaptable, and professional, but most of all she is a pleasure to be around. As first time homebuyers, we felt pretty clueless, but she was happy to stop to answer questions or even ask the questions she knew we had. Amy is kind, enthusiastic, and patient. We could not have had a more positive, stress-free (as it can be) experience buying a home & we owe that to Amy!

Seller review
Dynamic Duo
over 2 years ago
Dynamic Duo

We first received such great care from Amy in finding our new little farm. We drove 3 counties in one day! Her project management skills were phenomenal and keep everyone on track to closing. Philip handled the sale our our home we were moving from and it sold in a manner of days thanks to his great marketing skills. Thank you both for making our dreams come true!

Seller review
At our side throughout
over 2 years ago
At our side throughout

We partnered with the Red Wagon team of Philip and Amy to lead us through a successful sale. We are big on constant communication through the process and we got the best. At every point Philip and Amy kept us informed, guided us on our showings, held multiple open houses and helped bring us to the finish line. We were under contract in 8 days all while getting our net asking price. Their analytical tools provided by the Compass Group are second to none. You’ve got to know who your target audience is and reach them with your marketing message. It worked wonderfully. If you are in the market to sell or want to purchase a home - you’ll find no team better that will work for you.

Seller review
Excellent knowledge
over 2 years ago
Excellent knowledge

The Red Wagon Team was very knowledgeable about the market and how much our house would sell for. They communicated often and clearly about each step. They were always professional yet personal. I believe they had my best interest at heart.

Buyer review
Amazing experience
over 2 years ago
Amazing experience

My husband and my experience with Amy was nothing short of phenomenal. She was always there to communicate with us, walk us through a process, and answer any questions we had. We always felt like we had her full attention and she kept our best interests in mind. We’re referring Amy and Phillip to everyone we know in the market or thinking about buying or selling.

Seller review
Wonderful!
about 3 years ago
Wonderful!

Amy was wonderful to work with. Listened and sold my home quickly.

Buyer review
So lucky to have her.
over 4 years ago
So lucky to have her.

Hard to describe our experience with Amy. We were in the process of purchasing our first home. She was straight forward, knowledgeable, and kind. She helped us navigate through processes we didn't understand and never made us feel as if we weren't worthy of her time. Best of all, we felt like she had our back through the entire process (which was not easy for us). We can't say enough positive things about her - anyone would be lucky to have Amy by their side.

Buyer review
Best Realtor Ever
over 4 years ago
Best Realtor Ever

Amy is awesome. She was patient, caring, kind, and knowledgeable. As a 1st time home buyer she definitely helped me make informed decisions and helped me calm during anxious times of the home buying process. I would recommend her to anyone looking to work with someone who has integrity, who is genuine and who will go just as hard for you as you would for yourself. No one better than Mrs. Amy Donahoo #BestRealtorEver

Buyer review
Amy helped me close on my first home in a VERY competitive market
over 4 years ago
Amy helped me close on my first home in a VERY competitive market

Amys knowledge and expertise in the Real Estate Game is unparalleled. . Amy helped me close on a home after weeks of competing against all cash offers and she also helped me find a mortgage broker once mine backed out last minute. I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy in the Triangle Area and I will continue to work with her for years to come.

Buyer review
Best Agent on the Triangle
over 4 years ago
Best Agent on the Triangle

Working with Amy was a pleasant experience. My first house buying. But she helped me and my family accommodations and going the extra mile for us. Always willing and able to help us. She was more than a agent. She is a friend to us.

Buyer review
Key Structural Insights & Much More
over 4 years ago
Key Structural Insights & Much More

Amy's professionalism and warmth made it pretty easy to work with her. Where she really shines is during walk-throughs. I was often impressed with her keen understanding of construction, architecture, and maintenance costs when describing everything from roofs to butcher block countertops. I would definitely recommend her!

Buyer review
Land searching with Amy
over 4 years ago
Land searching with Amy

Amy is probably the only realtor I know who would go tramping through woods in spite of spider webs and 90+ degree heat to look at properties with us! Her dedication (and patience) to helping us find just the right spot to build our home was amazing! I look forward to working with her again when we go to sell our current house.

13 - 24 of 42
© 2026 RateMyAgent