Amy's profile

Amy's reviews

  5  
Amy has 74 reviewsacross 28 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Amy's qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, friendly, detail-oriented, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
The GOAT of Realtors
4 months ago
The GOAT of Realtors

Amy was absolutely incredible to work with and helped my family find our dream home. Our search was long, but Amy was always in constant communication, keeping us informed of new houses on the market. She came to each showing prepared and was extremely knowledgeable about every home we looked at—and if she didn’t have an answer right away, she made sure to get back to us quickly. Once we went under contract, we faced several complications that prolonged our closing date, all of which were completely outside of our control. Throughout it all, Amy continued to check in regularly, maintain clear communication between all parties, and advocate for our needs. She never let us feel forgotten or discouraged. Amy is professional, respectful, kind, and most of all, truly invested in her clients. We felt supported from start to finish and could not have asked for a better agent. I highly recommend Amy to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Seller review
Best Agent Ever
4 months ago
Best Agent Ever

Amy was very helpful in explaining the market conditions, comps, and timeline for the sale of my home. She was able to get the property under contract in less than a week. She worked with a professional photographer to get great pictures for our listing and was thorough in researching with the town, putting together the contract, and followed up quickly with the multiple offers we received. She was also our agent in the purchase of our new property and was very patient as we seemingly viewed endless properties to find our new forever home. She gave us great information on how to position our offers in this challenging market and did an amazing job of putting together full profiles on the properties we wanted to view (including town registration info, permit details, comps, and details gleaned from discussions with the seller's agent). It really helped us to position ourselves well when we made our offers. While we did lose out on a few great properties due to the insanity of the market (houses going 60-100k over ask), we ultimately found and won the best property in the best location for our family. Our 5 year old also adores her, so that puts her over the top.

Seller review
Outstanding Again
4 months ago
Outstanding Again

Amy took charge from the start walking us through the process smoothly. A very knowledgeable and's professional person with numerous contacts available for all the services we required. She was always available when needed,

Seller review
Real Estate Agent of Your Dreams!
4 months ago
Real Estate Agent of Your Dreams!

Working with Amy (twice) was an absolute game-changer. From start to finish, the process was seamless, professional, and genuinely enjoyable. Her knowledge of the market, attention to detail, and constant communication made me feel confident every step of the way. She went above and beyond—anticipating needs I didn’t even know I had—and always advocated for my best interests. If you’re looking for someone who is trustworthy, responsive, and truly exceptional at what they do, look no further. Amy is the kind of agent everyone hopes to find and the one who makes buying and selling an stress-free, enjoyable experience! I will be using only Amy for all of my future real estate purchases!

Buyer review
Trustworthy and Dependable, Simply the Best!
4 months ago
Trustworthy and Dependable, Simply the Best!

Amy is truly the best of the best. I have worked with her for years, and her knowledge and level of expertise are unmatched. Last month, Amy helped me purchase my third home. Throughout the process, she consistently demonstrated exceptional dedication and professionalism-keeping me informed and easing any concerns along the way. The information and advice she provides are very useful, and she always goes above and beyond. Apart from her professionalism, Amy creates an atmosphere that is comfortable and personable, making the entire experience genuinely enjoyable. I deeply appreciate her commitment not only to excellence in her field but also to building a genuine connection. I highly recommend Amy to anyone seeking a committed and highly effective real estate agent. Thanks again Amy, it was a joy working with you!

Seller review
Highly Recommend!!!
4 months ago
Highly Recommend!!!

We worked with Amy over a period of 6 months to both buy and sell. She was extremely communicative, down to earth, flexible, patient, and knowledgeable. Would definitely recommend!

Buyer review
Wonderful Agent
4 months ago
Wonderful Agent

Amy was wonderful to work with and helped us find our forever home in a challenging market. She offered wonderful insights and advice and really took the time to understand what we were looking for in a new home. I would recommend her to anyone

Buyer review
Outstanding Experience
4 months ago
Outstanding Experience

Amy was not only knowledgeable about the real estate market, she was kind, caring and always looking out for my best interests.

Seller review
Exceptional Team
4 months ago
Exceptional Team

We had a fantastic experience working with Amy and Craig during the purchase of our home. They were incredibly responsive and communicative throughout the entire process, which made everything feel smooth and stress-free. They allowed us to be hands-off when we needed to be, while still ensuring every detail was handled expertly. Their knowledge of what makes a competitive offer in a fast-moving market was invaluable, and we always felt confident knowing they were advocating for our best interests. We’re so grateful for their professionalism, expertise, and support, and we highly recommend Amy and Craig to anyone looking to buy a home.

Seller review
Amy is the best!
4 months ago
Amy is the best!

Amy is wonderful! She is honest, knowledgeable, communicative, and kind. Amy goes above and beyond for her clients to ease the stress of selling/buying process. You will be well taken care of! You will not regret working with Amy!

Seller review
Supportive throughout the entire process
4 months ago
Supportive throughout the entire process

Amy is the ultimate professional, with a wealth of knowledge about the market, it's changing and what the changes mean! She communicates clearly and effectively and demonstrates great empathy. She has great contacts and resources available to help with all the things that popped up during the sale of an estate property. I highly recommend Amy Balko

Buyer review
Knowledgeable and kind
4 months ago
Knowledgeable and kind

From the beginning, Amy set the stage for our home search. We lived out of state, so she set up a zoom call to discuss neighborhoods that fit what we were looking for. She gave us such great insight into each one, and we felt secure with the search in her hands. She even took us on Zoom home tours before we arrived for our official house hunting trip. Amy gave unbiased comments about each home, so we could make the decisions without feeling pressure. It was clear she knew her stuff, and we appreciated that very much. She was always quick to get back to us via text or email, and if we wanted to see a house, she got us in quickly. When it came time to make an offer, her suggestions are the reason we are now in the perfect home for us. She told us what we needed to offer…and it worked!! Throughout the experience, Amy felt like a friend, and it made a process that could have been very stressful actually fun!

1 - 12 of 74
© 2026 RateMyAgent