Aaron's profile

Aaron's reviews

  5  
Aaron has 59 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Aaron's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, well-prepared, friendly, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Dependable and Truly Exceptional
5 days ago
Dependable and Truly Exceptional

My sisters and I cannot recommend Aaron Jay highly enough. After our parents passed away unexpectedly in an accident, we were faced with the difficult task of selling their home while all living out of town. From the very beginning, Aaron went above and beyond to help us navigate an emotional and challenging process. Because we lived out of town, there were many things we couldn't do ourselves, and Aaron was always willing to step in and help. He was quick to respond to calls and texts, keeping us informed and giving us confidence that everything was being handled properly. Aaron is friendly, sincere, trustworthy, and hard working. His strong network of local contacts was invaluable. No matter what challenge came up, Aaron either had a solution or knew the right person to call. Most importantly, he treated our family with kindness, compassion, and respect during a very difficult time. We are incredibly grateful for his guidance, support, and dedication, and we would wholeheartedly recommend him to anyone looking for a realtor they can trust.

Buyer review
Very knowledgeable and helpful throughout the home buying process!!
5 days ago
Very knowledgeable and helpful throughout the home buying process!!

Aaron was a joy to work with, very knowledgeable on the market and helped make the home buying process very easy and smooth. He came highly recommended from a co-worked and we would also highly recommend Aaron. If you’re in the market then make it easy on yourself and go with Aaron!

Buyer review
Friendly, Professional & Responsive
2 months ago
Friendly, Professional & Responsive

Aaron is knowledgeable about real estate transactions, communicates clearly and promptly, and is a very friendly person to work with. Overall our experience was fairly easy going when considering how many processes and procedures go into a property deal. He made every effort to ensure we were taken care of and he looked out for our best interests. Thanks Aaron!

Seller review
Greatly appreciative of Aaron Jay's knowledge of real estate.
4 months ago
Greatly appreciative of Aaron Jay's knowledge of real estate.

Aaron Jay's experience in real estate was very helpful. From marketing, constant communications, recommending persons for cleaning, repairs, maintenance, and staging. There were immediate offers on the property after the first open house and a quick closing of escrow. Aaron was pleasant and patient to work with. I highly recommend Aaron.

Seller review
Selling My Magalia Home
7 months ago
Selling My Magalia Home

Aaron is a great agent and really goes above and beyond. He came recommended to me and now I have the pleasure of continuing to recommend him to others. Straightforward, honest and hard working. Really so so appreciate of Aaron and everything he did for me.

Buyer review
Great to work with
8 months ago
Great to work with

Aaron was always very through, helpful and prompt with everything. He found mistakes the other agent made. This is my second house from Aaron and everything always has been great!

Seller review
Arron Jay is a trusted Realtor
8 months ago
Arron Jay is a trusted Realtor

As an absentee homeowner and one that lived out of state, Aaron expertly guided me through the sale of my home. Through a difficult market and obstacles, Aaron enabled the sale. Aaron had knowledge of resources available to optimize my home in a buyer's market. I highly recommend Aaron Jay and his realty company .

Buyer review
Professional and easy to work with
8 months ago
Professional and easy to work with

Aaron was wonderful helping us navigate home buying as first timers. He was very responsive, answered questions and gave us great ideas on what to look for when touring homes. We’d absolutely recommend him and work with him again in the future.

Buyer review
Knowledgeable, excellent communication
11 months ago
Knowledgeable, excellent communication

Aaron was great to work with. He consistently provided timely and accurate communication on the transaction requirements and status. A pleasure to work with!

Seller review
Another house sale with Aaron
about 1 year ago
Another house sale with Aaron

This is our second time selling a home with Aaron and he continued to be helpful, responsive, easy to work with, and flexible. He did a great job guiding us through the process and was receptive to our input and ideas. Also, his photographer took great photos of the home - they came out multiple time to take pictures throughout the day. The sale went quickly and smoothly and we continue to appreciate Aaron's support through what can be a stressful process.

Buyer review
Chico's BEST agent - we've bought 3 homes with Aaron as our agent!
about 1 year ago
Chico's BEST agent - we've bought 3 homes with Aaron as our agent!

Aaron truly is the best, and we recommend him constantly to all our friends and family. Aaron genuinely cares for his clients, he's very knowledgeable about the market and process of home buying, and he's hilarious! We have bought three properties with Aaron over the last couple years and he made the process seamless, while answering all of our questions promptly.

Seller review
Aaron Jay - Outstanding Realtor
about 1 year ago
Aaron Jay - Outstanding Realtor

I feel so fortunate to have worked with Aaron Jay of City of Trees Realty in the sale of my brother's home in Chico. He was patiently and actively involved in coordinating every step of the process to prepare the house for sale with his expertise and his network of local contacts. Without him, the process would have been daunting to say the least. He shared his knowledge of the market to determine an appropriate price. His communication skills are top notch. In spite of rainy weather, the home was only on the market for two weeks before it was in escrow. If I were to buy or sell another home in Chico, my first call would be to Aaron Jay.

1 - 12 of 59
© 2026 RateMyAgent