Wine Trail Properties

132 Main Street Penn Yan, NY 14527
  •   5   (9 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Wine Trail Properties has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

8
Reviews
45
Properties for sale
135
Sold properties
$381k
Average sale price
$51.5m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) as lead and supporting agent and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 9 agents at Wine Trail Properties.

Austin Lapp
Austin Lapp

Owner / REALTOR®

  5   (7 reviews)
About Austin
How many young people at 22 years of age buy their first home? Well, meet Austin Lapp! He purchased his first home in 2010 in his hometown of Penn Yan, NY. This experience inspired him to start watching the real estate market in the surrounding area with an interested eye. A year later, Austin was approached by a friend who needed help managing his rental properties. Austin accepted the job and started managing properties. He really caught onto it quickly and acquired his real estate license in 2013 to further his experience and education in the wonderful world of real estate. Austin worked hard at gaining the trust of his clients and grew in every way. During his management tenure he oversaw vacation rentals, residential apartments & houses, and listed & sold millions of dollars of real estate year after year. Now, Austin is solely dedicated to real estate sales and is grateful for all the wonderful experiences he has had in every part of the business. He is one of the most successful brokers in the area! In his 10+ years of experience he has gained the trust of hundreds of clients including investors, first time home buyers, sellers interested in upgrading to larger homes, retirees, waterfront buyers & sellers, and more! Check out his client testimonials below. Growing up in this beautiful part of New York State has made Austin realize that this region truly has something special that few other areas in the world can offer. But more than just recreation and tourism, Austin understands the important role of local agriculture and his background in management has taught him how to be an effective communicator, advocate for his clients, and do what's best for them....even if it means telling someone that they need to wait to buy or sell. Austin has a very broad understanding of how he intends to help real estate buyers and sellers! Austin’s goal as a real estate broker is to keep the entire process simple & honest. Whether you’re a buyer or a seller, it is Austin’s goal that you be a satisfied client that is very pleased to refer family, friends, and neighbors because of a positive experience working with him. Other than real estate, Austin enjoys outdoor activities such has hiking, running, crossfit, a little bit of fishing, beekeeping and of course water sports on Keuka Lake. Austin is also an active musician and leads worship at a local church, WellSpring Fellowship.
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadgeaotybadge
Joseph Hy
Joseph Hy

REALTOR® / Licensed Real Estate Agent

  5   (1 review)
About Joseph
Born and raised in the Southern Tier, Joe came to the world of real estate after being a full-time photographer for several years. He has a unique perspective of the Finger Lakes area, having traveled all throughout it for his work. As he explored the region, he found more and more that he was captivated by the real estate market in the area. After buying a house of his own, and later an additional piece of land for recreational use, the desire to be in the real estate market grew. Finally, the pull was too strong and Joe happily acquired his real estate license and joined the team at Wine Trail Properties. Eager and motivated, Joe brings both his eye for beauty and his keen mind for numbers to the table. He helps his clients see the value in their property and conveys that value to the region. For people searching for a home, Joe is constantly researching and calculating what properties are available and how to maximize an investment in a new house. He is passionate about sharing the value of home ownership and real estate investments with everyone who will listen. Joe has been described as a “to-the-point” kind of guy, bringing a key strength of clear communication. He serves his clients with efficiency, dedication, and zeal. Joe also enjoys hiking, camping, visiting national and state parks, seeking new landscapes to photograph, and building out his family’s off-grid getaway property.
View Profile
Kyle Spinks
Kyle Spinks

REALTOR®

  5   (1 review)
About Kyle
Kyle caught the real estate bug when he and his wife Sami bought their first home when he was 26 years young. Through that experience he became obsessed with learning all he could about real estate and real estate investing. Less than a year later they purchased a second property; an investment property on Main Street in Penn Yan. It was at that time that Austin saw potential in Kyle and convinced him to get licensed and join the Wine Trail Properties team. Kyle approaches all real estate transactions with energy, enthusiasm and integrity. His goal is to make the home buying and selling experience easy, exciting, and enjoyable. His process is very meticulous with clear lines of communication to keep all parties on the same page so there are no surprises. Kyle loves to learn and grow with every interaction and enjoys sharing his knowledge and experience with his clients. He enjoys preparing first time buyers and sellers for what to expect throughout every step of the process. He works hard to be the agent you prefer to use and refer to your friends & family. Kyle was born and raised in the Finger Lakes and is always looking for new ways to experience all the amazing things this beautiful area has to offer. He enjoys boating, kayaking, hiking, skiing, golfing and hunting. You can frequently find Kyle with his wife and dogs driving around the lakes finding all the best scenery, waterfalls and breweries.
View Profile
Brianne Kirk
Brianne Kirk

REALTOR® / Licensed Real Estate Agent

About Brianne
Brianne was born and raised in Penn Yan and grew up on Keuka Lake. After attending college, she returned to the beautiful Finger Lakes area where she worked with her husband, as owners of a Keuka Lake restaurant for many years. Brianne immediately made her mark in Keuka Lake real estate after joining the Wine Trail Properties team in late 2015. Specializing in waterfront sales on multiple lakes, Brianne is hardworking and energetic. Her clients describe her as hands-on, knowledgable, and trustworthy. They benefit from from Brianne’s local network and her tenacity to maneuver the through the buying and selling process. Named on the Buffalo, Rochester Syracuse Top 100 Realtors in 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022 Brianne has the experience and expertise to help both buyers and seller's succeed in the Finger Lakes Real Estate market. Brianne has preformed in the top #25 for waterfront sales in 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022 for all of the Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse agents. Brianne has a business degree in management from Saint Leo University. She volunteers her time with the Yates County Youth Soccer Board. She loves to spend time on Keuka Lake with her family. Brianne and her husband, Art, live in the Penn Yan area with their young family.
View Profile
Jeremiah Horning
Jeremiah Horning

REALTOR® / Licensed Real Estate Agent

About Jeremiah
Jere Horning has lived in the Finger Lakes region for 40 years and wants to help others that are looking to buy or sell their home. In 1999 Jere started an excavating business. This gave him tremendous experience with drainage, septic systems, site work, and all other aspects of construction. He successfully ran that business until he sold it in 2011 when another business opportunity arose. In 2012 Jere and his wife Danette bought the family business; Horning's Greenhouse & Garden Center just north of Penn Yan. After joining the Benton Volunteer Fire Department in 1993 Jere has held many officer positions and has been an active member ever since. He serves on the board of directors for the Cornell Cooperative Extension of Yates County, Christian Aid Ministries rapid response team & Mennonite Gospel Missions. Jere has been involved in auctions and started auctioneering part-time for other auction companies in 2008. After getting requests to hold auctions for other people Horning Auction Company was formed in 2015 with his brother Ivan as a partner. They hold auctions for estates, business liquidations, and personal property. After graduating from Missouri Auction School Jere was inspired to acquire his real estate license, and now is here to help you sell your property by auction or with traditional listing.
View Profile
Jesse Lapp
Jesse Lapp

REALTOR® / Licensed Real Estate Agent

About Jesse
Meet Jesse, associate broker at Wine Trail Properties! Born and raised near Keuka Lake, he proudly calls the area home, and claims a diverse range of experiences. He has been actively working with clients on a broad spectrum of properties since 2015, including commercial, waterfront, and (his favorite) land parcels. Before joining Wine Trail Properties, Jesse began his career in the construction industry, working several years for a local builder. He then moved on to landscape construction, spending much of his time along the Finger Lakes building sea walls, steps, and patios. Jesse has a knack for seeing and creating organizations/businesses within the community, causing him to start his own business (a sporting goods store), along with creating and running other area businesses and organizations, including several sports leagues. Joining Wine Trail Properties was a natural extension of Jesse's involvement and knowledge of the area and construction experience. He knows the current area market very well, and offers a simple, clear approach to buying or selling real estate. Promising consistent communication and experienced negotiating. Outside of real estate, you can probably find Jesse doing something active (running, camping, hunting, or sports), or working with the youth at his local church, WellSpring Fellowship. Jesse and his beautiful wife, Keren, live in the village of Penn Yan.
View Profile

About us

Wine Trail Properties is a full-service real estate brokerage company that specializes in buying and selling Finger Lakes properties. From resorts to lakefront cottages, seasonal cabins, recreational land, and affordable historic homes, we make your Finger Lakes real estate dreams come true! Aside from helping people discover their dream home, we also offer a powerful advantage for sellers. We have the buyers! We are positioned to provide unmatched exposure to Finger Lakes properties through dozens of internet portals, including our own website, and a targeted marketing technique. Area visitors are introduced to Wine Trail Properties and are directed to our website to view area attractions, wineries, lakes, and information centers. The Finger Lakes Region is recognized as world class wine country. This scenic area is a popular destination for tens of thousands of people who flock to the area each year for a one-of-a-kind experience. Through these visits, many fall in love with the region’s beauty and unique characteristics. This is where we come into play- at Wine Trail Properties, our professional realtors help vacationers become residents and turn first-time guests into recurring visitors. Enjoy the region! We hope that you will find our website rich with helpful information about our beloved area. Review the many links to villages, attractions, and more. Come back often to check for new listings with our Real Estate Property Search option and to see new attractions, local information, and more.

Our reviews

  5  
9 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 6.
Seller review
Dedicated, courteous, and results-driven
3 months ago
Dedicated, courteous, and results-driven

Joe was outstanding to work with from start to finish. His communication was excellent. He kept me informed every step of the way and was always quick to respond to questions. He stayed on top of every detail throughout the selling process, which made everything feel smooth and manageable. His knowledge of the market and professionalism gave me a lot of confidence. On top of that, he was consistently courteous and easy to work with. I highly recommend Joe to anyone looking to sell their home.

Joseph Hy

Joseph Hy

  5   (1 review)
Seller review
Incredibly helpful, trustworthy and knowledgeable!
4 months ago
Incredibly helpful, trustworthy and knowledgeable!

Austin made selling our family home, which was a very emotional decision, as easy as he possibly could have. He gave us advice along the way with our best interest in mind, not just dollar signs, but what was actually best for us and what he would do if he were in our shoes. It was like working with a friend who wanted the best for you! There is no one better to have worked with on this sale, and we are truly grateful for all of the time, knowledge, and care that Austin contributed to this sale. Would absolutely work with him again in the future!

Austin Lapp

Austin Lapp

  5   (7 reviews)
Seller review
Austin is a thoughtful and trustworthy realtor.
4 months ago
Austin is a thoughtful and trustworthy realtor.

If you want honesty and someone thoughtful when purchasing a home, Austin is the person! He is kind, tells you like it is, and helps you in every way possible to either buy or sell or house. Austin helped us find our vacation home and we went back to him when we sold it. He is fantastic!

Austin Lapp

Austin Lapp

  5   (7 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent!!
5 months ago
Excellent!!

Very knowledgeable and professional

Austin Lapp

Austin Lapp

  5   (7 reviews)
Seller review
10/10 Recommend Kyle Spinks for buying or selling real estate
6 months ago
10/10 Recommend Kyle Spinks for buying or selling real estate

Kyle Spinks made the process of selling a home as smooth and stress-free as possible. He approached the situation with professionalism, honesty, patience, and sensitivity, keeping communication clear and consistent every step of the way. Kyle was knowledgeable about the market, provided honest guidance, and handled negotiations with care and integrity. I would highly recommend Kyle Spinks to anyone seeking a skilled and compassionate real estate agent and I look forward to working with him again in the future!

Kyle Spinks

Kyle Spinks

  5   (1 review)
Buyer review
Very happy buyer
7 months ago
Very happy buyer

Austin is so awesome to work with. Always understanding and patient! Highly recommend

Austin Lapp

Austin Lapp

  5   (7 reviews)
Show all 9 reviews
map

Our properties

Wine Trail Properties has 45 properties for sale and sold 135 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$249,900
3882 CR-24
Schuyler County NY 14840
Land
Listing courtesy of Wine Trail Properties
SoldMay 8, 2026
$175,000
109 South Avenue
Penn Yan NY 14527
4
2
1
Multi-Family
Listing courtesy of Hunt Real Estate ERA/Columbus and Wine Trail Properties
SoldMay 6, 2026
$250,000
780 Nine Foot Road
Seneca County NY 14433
4
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Century 21 Steve Davoli RE and Wine Trail Properties
SoldMay 4, 2026
$705,000
4187 East Waneta Lake Road
Dundee NY 14837
3
3
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Wine Trail Properties and Century 21 Steve Davoli RE
Show all 180 properties
© 2026 RateMyAgent