Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
95 reviewsacross 9 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: pleasant, supportive, detail-oriented, friendly, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Two thumbs up experience!
almost 5 years ago
Two thumbs up experience!

Working with Jenna was a very pleasant experience! We looked at several properties with her and finally found a perfect place for us. The closing was pretty streamlined. Jenna hooked us up with everyone needed and made us very happy. We can’t wait to build our new home and start a new chapter in our lives.

Jenna Galegher

Jenna Galegher

  5   (81 reviews)
Buyer review
Smooth land purchase
almost 5 years ago
Smooth land purchase

We had the opportunity to work with Jenna on a few properties over the years but none came to our liking. She continued to assist us and finally we were able to make a fair deal with a seller on a property we really wanted. The whole transaction was smoother then expected as we are long distance from the property. Directions and the hoops to jump through were thoroughly explained to us so it was seamless for the whole process. You will be in good hands and told the truth if you decide to work with Jenna and her colleagues for any real estate need.

Jenna Galegher

Jenna Galegher

  5   (81 reviews)
Buyer review
House Matchmaker
almost 5 years ago
House Matchmaker

Jenna was working with me over 5 months or so to find our place. I saw her present places and watch my response. When the right house showed up, she KNEW it was it!

Jenna Galegher

Jenna Galegher

  5   (81 reviews)
Seller review
Town of Bayfield was very pleased with our experience
almost 5 years ago
Town of Bayfield was very pleased with our experience

I have known Jenna for several years and find her to be very dedicated to her work and her community. Two years ago, the Town of Bayfield was going to sell a 40 acre parcel that we owned. At that time, we asked for proposals from two realty companies in our community. The Town Board chose Windseeker Realty and Jenna Gallagher to handle the transaction for the Town. We couldn't have been more pleased with the experience of working with Jenna, selling the property and closing for us. I personally was very satisfied working with her. If I were to sell any of my own property, I would be very comfortable to have Jenna Gallagher work for me.

Jenna Galegher

Jenna Galegher

  5   (81 reviews)
Buyer review
Smooth Transaction
almost 5 years ago
Smooth Transaction

This was, by far, our smoothest locating and buying experience ever. We will be sure to recommend you and your team to anyone who asks us!

Jenna Galegher

Jenna Galegher

  5   (81 reviews)
Seller review
Katie was awesome!
almost 5 years ago
Katie was awesome!

I couldn't have asked for a more caring person to handle the sale of my dad's cabin. It was an emotional time selling my dad's cabin. I spent most of my summer's up there as a child. I now live in Florida, so it was important that I could be kept updated on how things were going. Katie went above and beyond. She consistently checked on the property, moved some remaining items left in the cabin, volunteered to have a rummage sale, bought some baking soda to get rid of the closed-up cabin smell, and had pictures done to show its charm and potential. I highly recommend her!

Katie Barningham

Katie Barningham

  4.9   (10 reviews)
Buyer review
Knowledgeable, Professional, and Very Friendly
almost 5 years ago
Knowledgeable, Professional, and Very Friendly

Katie was very helpful and accommodating during the process. Her knowledge and research into the home she was selling, relieved my apprehensions about buying this home as it sat. Her response to all communication was quick and thoroughly answered any questions I had.

Katie Barningham

Katie Barningham

  4.9   (10 reviews)
Seller review
Bright future ahead
almost 5 years ago
Bright future ahead

Couldn't have asked for more in an agent. Having only been in the business for such a short time, I was very impressed with the entire experience. Courteous, timely in her responding back to me with any questions or request and overall very professional.

Katie Barningham

Katie Barningham

  4.9   (10 reviews)
Seller review
Katie is GREAT!
almost 5 years ago
Katie is GREAT!

Katie is great to work with and I would highly recommend her! Her friendly personality sets people at ease. She is enthusiastic in her job and goes out of her way to assist her customers while buying and selling property!

Katie Barningham

Katie Barningham

  4.9   (10 reviews)
Seller review
Jenna advised us, and then sold our home.
almost 5 years ago
Jenna advised us, and then sold our home.

We had a great experience working with Jenna on the sale of our home. Jenna carefully evaluated the comparables on the market and put our home on the market for a price we thought was well researched. The market moved quickly, and Jenna proved to have crisp communication as she scheduled showings, and juggled our schedule. As we quickly moved to accepting an offer, the process moved along without a hitch. I'd recommend Jenna, and her Windseeker team, to anyone looking for realty help in the area.

Jenna Galegher

Jenna Galegher

  5   (81 reviews)
Buyer review
Bought land/lot
about 5 years ago
Bought land/lot

We really enjoyed working with Jenna. She's friendly, courteous and professional. She helped us obtain the land we wanted. Very trusting and a great resource.

Jenna Galegher

Jenna Galegher

  5   (81 reviews)
Buyer review
Perfection found
over 5 years ago
Perfection found

We have been working with Jenna at Windseeker for a while, to find the *perfect* Bayfield / Lake Superior getaway. She really got to know us, what we really wanted and found it for us. A listing came up, she contacted us, and because we couldn't get away from work, did a "virtual" walk through, showing us the place with her phone as she walked through it! We had an accepted offer before we set foot on the property! Jenna really nailed it, and we LOVE our cottage on the big lake.

Jenna Galegher

Jenna Galegher

  5   (81 reviews)
37 - 48 of 95
© 2026 RateMyAgent