Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
77 reviewsacross 31 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, patient, detail-oriented, great negotiation, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Best you could ask for!
about 3 years ago
Best you could ask for!

Extremely professional, educational, and kind every step of the process. We were first time home buyers and buying a house was made easy with Roger. Highly recommend.

Roger Kelley
Seller review
Fantastic team!
about 3 years ago
Fantastic team!

Roger and Susan were such a pleasure to work with. I really appreciated their professionalism, the extent of their knowledge, resources, and practical advice. They were in communication with us every step of the way and made the process very smooth. I would highly recommend their team to anyone looking for a realtor!

Roger Kelley
Seller review
Roger and Susan: True Pros
about 3 years ago
Roger and Susan: True Pros

We are very glad that we chose to list our home with Roger and Susan. Our property was tricky because it was likely to set a record for our neighborhood if it was handled properly. From the marketing, listing strategy, to the negotiations, both Roger and Susan get top marks for their level headed approach and expert guidance. And extra kudos go to Neuhouse Realty for running such a quality operation from top to bottom. We are grateful for the help of all those involved, and will definitely have them at the top of our list if and when we need help again in Northern Colorado.

Roger Kelley
Buyer review
Made our first time home buying experience a breeze
about 3 years ago
Made our first time home buying experience a breeze

As a first time homebuyer, my husband and I couldn't have asked for a better realtor. Roger and his wife, Susan, went above and beyond in our house buying process. Roger is professional yet extremely down to earth. He is very knowledgeable and answered all of our questions through the process. He gave us pros and cons to the houses we were looking at, and didn't pressure us at all through the process. Can't recommend these two enough!

Roger Kelley
Buyer review
Outstanding Service
over 3 years ago
Outstanding Service

Coming from the east coast, with no experience with Colorado real estate , we were very fortunate to engage Roger and Susan Kelley as our buying agents. Roger has enormous experience and knowledge of the local front range market, as well as very up to date knowledge of current market conditions. In addition Roger is an excellent communicator who understood our questions and concerns, and gave us very clear answers to all of our questions. And, when we did find the house that best met all of our needs, Roger skillfully negotiated a very good discount on the sellers asking price for us. Beyond the closing of the sale, both Roger and Susan continue to be available and a great resource for local knowledge as we continue to settle in to our new home.

Roger Kelley
Buyer review
Top tier experience
over 3 years ago
Top tier experience

Cheryl was wonderful to work with. She and her husband Roger worked seamlessly together through the 6 month process of finding our new home. She tirelessly guided us through many houses in 3 different towns, arranged showings quickly, and understood our needs and desires. We changed our minds a number of times as to location, price, and desired amenities, but this was never a problem for her. When we found the perfect house, the deal was done with lightening speed and sealed at an excellent price. We would work with her and Roger again in a heartbeat.

Susan Kelley
Buyer review
went the extra mile
over 3 years ago
went the extra mile

Cheryl and her team really went the extra mile for my unicorn. i couldn't have done it without them!

Susan Kelley
Seller review
The service we received from Mr. Kelley, his wife Susan and son Sam was nothing short of phenomenal!
almost 4 years ago
The service we received from Mr. Kelley, his wife Susan and son Sam was nothing short of phenomenal!

I would highly recommend using Mr. Kelley for any real estate needs you may have! His knowledge, guidance, understanding and willingness to help us was above and beyond any expectations we ever had! We will forever be grateful not only to him but also to his wife, Susan, his son Sam and daughter in law Morgan. The whole family was absolutely phenomenal!

Roger Kelley
Buyer review
Great Realtor
almost 4 years ago
Great Realtor

Cheryl was great to work with. She was very patient in helping us find what we wanted. Never tried pushing anything on us. Would highly recommend her.

Susan Kelley
Seller review
Fantastic Stress Free Experience Selling My Home
almost 4 years ago
Fantastic Stress Free Experience Selling My Home

Roger and Susan provided me with a most wonderful experience in selling my home. I had lived there for over 22 years and a sudden life event changed my path and I had to sell this amazing home and I was fraught with emotion. Roger and Susan went to work and were so responsive for both providing me with the knowledge I needed and tremendous emotional support. Their wonderful caring and giving manner made the process stress and pain free. The home sold on the first day and Roger and Susan saw to it that I received the price I asked for and helped me so much with the remaining preparation of the house for sale. They are amazing, kind, knowledgeable, and caring. I am so fortunate and grateful that these two came into my life to help me with such a difficult decision and I have made two new friends for life. I highly recommend Roger and Susan for any of your real estate needs. They are remarkable!

Roger Kelley
Buyer review
Roger and Susan are amazing!
almost 4 years ago
Roger and Susan are amazing!

Roger and Susan were amazing. They arranged 8 showings in one day on very short notice for us when I had a brief window to fly in. They helped us get our dream home under asking and we’re very patient with our endless questions. They made what could have been a very difficult move cross country much easier. They even stopped by with a housewarming gift for our kids and called a few times to check in on us. Really nice people and amazing agents!!

Roger Kelley
25 - 36 of 77
© 2026 RateMyAgent