Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
25 reviewsacross 19 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, detail-oriented, reliable, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Caroline goes above and beyond
about 1 year ago
Caroline goes above and beyond

I can't recommend Caroline highly enough. I worked with her six years ago when I was looking for a rental. She found the perfect spot for me. I went on to buy that place and then she helped me when the time came to sell it. Caroline is professional, diligent, and stops at nothing to provide excellent service. Finally, I'll say that she's just a kind human being. I appreciate all she did to help me find the right buyer.

Caroline Mescia
Buyer review
She won't give up until you get what you want!!
about 1 year ago
She won't give up until you get what you want!!

I have nothing but positives things to say about Caroline work ethic, her tenacity, and her will to get you want!!! Very dedicated she would go on beyond the call of duty to get results for you, I won't recommend any one but her!

Caroline Mescia
Buyer review
No better team than the Bolcar team!
over 1 year ago
No better team than the Bolcar team!

Exceptional. Where to even begin... we heard of Sandra & Bob when another family member of ours worked with them a couple years prior. When it came time for our own house-hunt and given the time when we were looking and the anxiety that came with it, we reached out to the Bolcars' nearly immediately. The wealth of knowledge that both Sandra and Bob have is incomparable; they complement one another so well. Information, problem-solving and resourcefulness are naturally embedded in them which continually educated and steered us in the right home for us. They listened, accommodated and listened to our needs and desires, ultimately landing the home that was just right. The Bolcars and their team were dependable, professional and always approachable. They were always present in every step of our home-hunt and we would choose them over and over again.

Sandra Bolcar
Buyer review
The BEST realtors we could ask for - recommend 10000%!
over 1 year ago
The BEST realtors we could ask for - recommend 10000%!

As first-time homebuyers, my partner and I were nervous about the entire process, but we could not have asked for better realtors to guide us. From the very beginning, they took the time to educate us about what to expect, advised on key factors to consider, and listened carefully to our needs and preferences every step of the way. With Sandra’s years of experience in real estate, and Bob’s insight as a former builder, their combined knowledge was invaluable in helping us make informed decisions. Their expertise gave us the confidence we needed to navigate the complexities of buying a home. They connected us with great trusted professionals for our inspections, mortgage lender, and more which was a huge help! We felt supported and well-informed at every stage and we are so grateful for their hard work in helping us find our home. If you’re looking for realtors with extensive experience who genuinely care about their clients, we highly recommend them!

Sandra Bolcar
Seller review
Trustworthy and knowledgeable
over 1 year ago
Trustworthy and knowledgeable

Caroline was excellent to work with. Her communication was clear, well organized, and strategically on point. She has a firm understanding of market conditions and works to mitigate unseen detriments. She is an excellent realtor to work with.

Caroline Mescia
Seller review
Great experience
over 1 year ago
Great experience

Caroline was professional, efficient, and very responsive. I would highly recommend Caroline.

Caroline Mescia
Buyer review
A long journey finally to a close
over 1 year ago
A long journey finally to a close

Although these were twists and turns along the way (due diligence on sellers should be an important part of real estate agency), Caroline has been a steady hand in guiding the deal towards final closing. And I appreciate that.

Caroline Mescia
Seller review
Bolcar Team won’t disappoint!
over 1 year ago
Bolcar Team won’t disappoint!

We are repeat customers of Caroline Mescia and the Bolcar team. Whether you are buying or selling you will not be disappointed in the expertise, professionalism and commitment that they provide.

Caroline Mescia
Seller review
A pleasure working with Sandy
over 1 year ago
A pleasure working with Sandy

Sandy and Bob made the stressful process of listing and selling our house with a 3 month old baby as painless as possible. They were responsive and accommodating of our crazy schedules and we ended up accepting an offer over ask. An easy experience and we made some dear friends in the process.

Sandra Bolcar
Buyer review
We had the pleasure of working with Caroline for almost a year while searching for our first home, a
over 1 year ago
We had the pleasure of working with Caroline for almost a year while searching for our first home, a

We had the pleasure of working with Caroline for almost a year while searching for our first home, and we couldn’t be more grateful for her dedication, patience, and expertise throughout the process. Caroline was always available to answer our questions, provide valuable advice, and guide us through every step of the home-buying journey. Her knowledge of the market and attention to detail made us feel confident that we were in great hands. She never gave up on finding us the perfect home. We highly recommend Caroline to anyone looking for a reliable and genuinely caring realtor. Thank you, Caroline, for making our home-buying experience so positive and successful!

Caroline Mescia
Buyer review
Sandra is a gem of a realtor
almost 2 years ago
Sandra is a gem of a realtor

Sandra was very helpful and guided us in the whole process. She is very experienced and has a huge knowledge of the industry.

Sandra Bolcar
Seller review
Always got us a good deal
about 2 years ago
Always got us a good deal

Sandy helped us find a great house in Montclair about a decade ago. During the first Covid summer she negotiated a great deal selling it on the first day of the open house, and closed the deal even though a tree took out the front steps two weeks before closing. She found us a last minute town house, again a great buyers deal, and then three years later sold that on the first day of the open house. Her analysis and advice, both in how to stage the house and how to list it were spot on. Whether buying or selling she is committed to her clients. Period. We've moved out of New Jersey, but continue to recommend her to friends who are moving in, renting or looking to move out.

Sandra Bolcar
1 - 12 of 25
© 2026 RateMyAgent