Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
570 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, detail-oriented, friendly, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
This was our second transaction with Elise Fay, both experiences were excellent
over 8 years ago
This was our second transaction with Elise Fay, both experiences were excellent

This was our second transaction with Elise Fay, both experiences were excellent. She is fair minded and friendly, but direct enough to surface issues early and keep the deal moving. Please make an appointment with her and drive through a neighborhood. You will find she had exhaustive knowledge of recent sales and great insight into wellness and lifestyle issues associated with the location. The more time I spent with her the more impressed I was.

Elise Fay
Seller review
I would recommend Elise Fay to anyone who is looking to buy or sell a home in the Phoenix area!  She
over 8 years ago
I would recommend Elise Fay to anyone who is looking to buy or sell a home in the Phoenix area! She

I would recommend Elise Fay to anyone who is looking to buy or sell a home in the Phoenix area! She is an excellent realtor, and will make every effort to get you the best price on your home if you are selling, or get you the best deal if you are buying. She is easy to work with, and is always available to her customers. Don't hesitate to use this wonderful realtor!

Elise Fay
Seller review
Elise was very personable and professional every step of the way in our selling experience
over 8 years ago
Elise was very personable and professional every step of the way in our selling experience

Elise was very personable and professional every step of the way in our selling experience. She also assisted in the buying process on the other side of the process. In both cases she stepped up and made sure our best interests were always number one. She took the time to explain all the details and make sure we were well educated on our specific needs. I would highly recommend Elise for your listing or buying transaction. She is insightful, knowledgeable and puts the client first. Choose her when making your Real Estate transaction. Anthony

Elise Fay
Buyer review
Elise has been great to work with, my previous experience with a Realtor was terrible and Elise demo
over 8 years ago
Elise has been great to work with, my previous experience with a Realtor was terrible and Elise demo

Elise has been great to work with, my previous experience with a Realtor was terrible and Elise demonstrated how things are supposed to be handled. She's very responsive, knowledgeable and is a GREAT negotiator. She saved us thousands on our forever home! She is diligently working to sell our previous home to get us out from under that financial burden. Offers were made within days of listing.

Elise Fay
Seller review
We had multiple offers in on Monday and ended up selling the house above asking price
over 8 years ago
We had multiple offers in on Monday and ended up selling the house above asking price

We had a great experience with Ilene. Our house sat on the market for about 6 months, even with a price drop, before we switched to Ilene. She pulled it off the market and updated all of the marketing materials, photos, minor staging, etc. She even had a handyman do some minor repairs on her own. Our house went back on the market and that same weekend had almost 10 times the traffic online and in actual showings that we had the whole previous month. We had multiple offers in on Monday and ended up selling the house above asking price. Ilene did a fantastic job in marketing the house, negotiating with the buyers and driving the entire process.

Ilene McKenna
Buyer review
We were struggling with the sale of our house
over 8 years ago
We were struggling with the sale of our house

We were struggling with the sale of our house. It was an empty house sitting on the market for months. My husband and I decided it was time to change realtors. Ilene came in, cleaned it up, staged it, relisted it and sold it in a week! Needless to say we think she is pretty awesome!

Ilene McKenna
Seller review
Our house was in the northwest area of the Phoenix metro area and we wanted someone local to help us
almost 9 years ago
Our house was in the northwest area of the Phoenix metro area and we wanted someone local to help us

Our house was in the northwest area of the Phoenix metro area and we wanted someone local to help us sell it. After interviewing several people, we selected Elise Fay because she not only seemed to know the area but she also had a lot of energy, experience and good ideas. We had just had the house appraised but she told us we could sell it for several thousand more. Even at that price, she promised it would sell within a month. We were skeptical but said OK. Elise sent over a specialist to help stage the house, recommended tradesmen to do minor repairs and painting, wrote a flattering but true description of the house, and had a professional photographer take pictures for the internet. She had put out a “coming soon” tickler so she already had a list of interested parties. It went live on Zillow and other web sites one afternoon and in less than 24 hours we had a full-price buyer. Even though the house sold in one day, we felt the price Elise set was spot-on. Elise held our hands all the way through closing, which went very smoothly.

Elise Fay
Buyer review
We were referred to Elise from a friend who had been working with her for awhile (because of their e
almost 9 years ago
We were referred to Elise from a friend who had been working with her for awhile (because of their e

We were referred to Elise from a friend who had been working with her for awhile (because of their extreme pickiness). We immediately felt that she understood our needs. She mentored us through all processes of getting our loved home of 21 years ready to sell. She also helped us with selling & purchasing. She assured us our home would sell fast, and 11 days later we had a signed contract. All steps along the way went off without a hitch because she kept us informed. I would recommend her to any of my family & friends.

Elise Fay
Seller review
Ilene McKenna was a wonderful help selling our house
about 9 years ago
Ilene McKenna was a wonderful help selling our house

Ilene McKenna was a wonderful help selling our house. She was very understanding? of my wants for selling and did everything she could. She went above and beyond for us and selling our house. She is highly appreciated and I highly recommend her!

Ilene McKenna
Buyer review
Let me start by stating that this is the first time I have ever done a review on the internet as it
about 9 years ago
Let me start by stating that this is the first time I have ever done a review on the internet as it

Let me start by stating that this is the first time I have ever done a review on the internet as it isn't my style. However, for Elise I have no hesitation to do one now. I met Elise by chance months before I even knew for sure I was moving to AZ. Although she knew I may not have gotten a job transfer to AZ (moving from DC), she still kept in regular contact with me. She was never persistent, but she was always kind, friendly, honest, down-to-earth, and real. When my job transfer was finally a reality, she worked closely with me throughout the process of narrowing down locations, researching the perfect area for me and my family, and greatly helping me find the right people to get me through the strenuous process. I only had less than 2 weeks to find a home. She took me and my family to over 30 houses (which was more of my indecisiveness than anything else). The entire time she was unbelievably helpful, well informed, and patient. She made us feel like we were absolutely her only clients from our first encounter until we moved into our perfect house. She did a phenomenal job in negotiating the right price, professionally fighting for us, and making sure other additional items that were needed got done. Even after the closing and us moving in, she continues to make sure everything is exactly as we expected. If you want a realtor that will tell you like it is but listens to what you want and need, you truly cannot go wrong with Elise. She's not just your realtor; she really is your partner and confidant throughout the entire process.

Elise Fay
517 - 528 of 570
Sibbach Team - eXp Realty
Contact Sibbach Team - eXp Realty
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent