Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
571 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, detail-oriented, friendly, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
She is responsive, honest, professional and truly cares about her clients
about 5 years ago
She is responsive, honest, professional and truly cares about her clients

I was moving from another state. Ilene took the time to understand what I needed and wanted in a house and did everything possible to make sure I got it. She is responsive, honest, professional and truly cares about her clients. I would happily recommend her to anyone! She's the best.

Ilene McKenna
Seller review
It was an absolute pleasure to work with Elise on my home sale
about 5 years ago
It was an absolute pleasure to work with Elise on my home sale

It was an absolute pleasure to work with Elise on my home sale. Elise was extremely knowledgeable and professional. She went over and above. I would highly recommend Elise whether buying or selling.

Elise Fay
Seller review
Elise was an absolute pleasure.
about 5 years ago
Elise was an absolute pleasure.

It was an absolute pleasure to work with Elise on my home sale. Elise was extremely knowledgeable and professional. She went over and above. I would highly recommend Elise whether buying or selling.

Elise Fay
Buyer review
I wish there were more stars to give Ilene!
about 5 years ago
I wish there were more stars to give Ilene!

I wish there were more stars to give Ilene! This is the second time she's helped us with our Real Estate needs. This time it was selling one property and buying another. It was a tough deal due to this being a 1031 Exchange - selling one rental property and buying another. Due to the strict rules and current competitive market in the Phoenix area, the timing is critical. Ilene managed both sides and went above and beyond in handling countless details. I can't say enough good things about her, her work ethic and knowledge. Ilene is a true professional and the Realtor you should use if buying or selling in the Phoenix area. She is unbeatable!!

Ilene McKenna
Seller review
I wish there were more stars to give Ilene!
about 5 years ago
I wish there were more stars to give Ilene!

I wish there were more stars to give Ilene! This is the second time she's helped us with our Real Estate needs. This time it was selling one property and buying another. It was a tough deal due to this being a 1031 Exchange - selling one rental property and buying another. Due to the strict rules and current competitive market in the Phoenix area, the timing is critical. Ilene managed both sides and went above and beyond in handling countless details. I can't say enough good things about her, her work ethic and knowledge. Ilene is a true professional and the Realtor you should use if buying or selling in the Phoenix area. She is unbeatable!!

Ilene McKenna
Seller review
I can't say enough good things about her, her work ethic and knowledge.
about 5 years ago
I can't say enough good things about her, her work ethic and knowledge.

I wish there were more stars to give Ilene! This is the second time she's helped us with our Real Estate needs. This time it was selling one property and buying another. It was a tough deal due to this being a 1031 Exchange - selling one rental property and buying another. Due to the strict rules and current competitive market in the Phoenix area, the timing is critical. Ilene managed both sides and went above and beyond in handling countless details. I can't say enough good things about her, her work ethic and knowledge. Ilene is a true professional and the Realtor you should use if buying or selling in the Phoenix area. She is unbeatable!!

Ilene McKenna
Buyer review
Ilene is detailed and super responsive
about 5 years ago
Ilene is detailed and super responsive

Ilene is awesome! I have known her professionally For 5 years and she has helped me with all my real estate needs. Ilene is detailed and super responsive. I highly recommend her as a realtor.

Ilene McKenna
Seller review
we were able to sell at the top of the market efficiently and effortlessly
about 5 years ago
we were able to sell at the top of the market efficiently and effortlessly

We retained Ilene to sell our rental home in NE Scottsdale. She took care of managing the cleaning, improvements and staging of the home in preparation for sale. Additionally, based on her advice we were able to sell at the top of the market efficiently and effortlessly. Lastly and most importantly, Ilene was very professional and a true pleasure to work with.

Ilene McKenna
Buyer review
Elise is a fantastic realtor! Her experience and knowledge proved invaluable in the purchasing of ou
about 5 years ago
Elise is a fantastic realtor! Her experience and knowledge proved invaluable in the purchasing of ou

Elise is a fantastic realtor! Her experience and knowledge proved invaluable in the purchasing of our home. As first time homebuyers, Elise walked us through the process from start to finish. She was always available when we needed her and spent months with us searching for the perfect home. She has an impeccable eye for details and was quick to notice things in homes that we would have overlooked. We truly appreciated all her advice and wisdom in this major purchase. She's had our backs time and time again when negotiating contracts in this intense seller's market. We were in the best hands with Elise. While this seems to be a time when everyone knows a realtor, you should, without a doubt, GO WITH ELISE. You will not be disappointed!

Elise Fay
Buyer review
Elise is a fantastic realtor! Her experience and knowledge proved invaluable in the purchasing of ou
about 5 years ago
Elise is a fantastic realtor! Her experience and knowledge proved invaluable in the purchasing of ou

Elise is a fantastic realtor! Her experience and knowledge proved invaluable in the purchasing of our home. As first time homebuyers, Elise walked us through the process from start to finish. She was always available when we needed her and spent months with us searching for the perfect home. She has an impeccable eye for details and was quick to notice things in homes that we would have overlooked. We truly appreciated all her advice and wisdom in this major purchase. She's had our backs time and time again when negotiating contracts in this intense seller's market. We were in the best hands with Elise. While this seems to be a time when everyone knows a realtor, you should, without a doubt, GO WITH ELISE. You will not be disappointed!

Elise Fay
Seller review
Elise was fantastic!!  She went to bat for us in the purchase of our new condo, and provided valuabl
about 5 years ago
Elise was fantastic!! She went to bat for us in the purchase of our new condo, and provided valuabl

Elise was fantastic!! She went to bat for us in the purchase of our new condo, and provided valuable tips to help us make our existing home “sale ready.” We appreciated her “workhorse” effort to make our transition between homes as seamless as possible. We strongly recommend Elise and the Sibbach team! Thank you Elise!!!! Alice and Kent Kraft

Elise Fay
Seller review
Elise was fantastic!!  She went to bat for us in the purchase of our new condo, and provided valuabl
about 5 years ago
Elise was fantastic!! She went to bat for us in the purchase of our new condo, and provided valuabl

Elise was fantastic!! She went to bat for us in the purchase of our new condo, and provided valuable tips to help us make our existing home “sale ready.” We appreciated her “workhorse” effort to make our transition between homes as seamless as possible. We strongly recommend Elise and the Sibbach team! Thank you Elise!!!! Alice and Kent Kraft

Elise Fay
373 - 384 of 571
Sibbach Team - eXp Realty
Contact Sibbach Team - eXp Realty
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent