Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
35 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Couldn’t have gone more smoothly!

We had a great experience working with Cheryl and Eliza. They have a great understanding of the marketplace and were very helpful in our dealing with the various matters that we needed to address. They helped get our condo staged and sold in 4 days!

Cheryl Santelli

Cheryl Santelli

  5   (14 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Cheryl gets the property SOLD

Considering an agent to sell your Siesta Key property quickly and without hassle you definitely want Cheryl Santelli she will get the property sold and keep you informed with the process to close the deal. We are so happy we chose Cheryl

Cheryl Santelli

Cheryl Santelli

  5   (14 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Great experience

Eliza very easy to work with on the purchase of a beach condo for my mother in law. She was very knowledgeable about the area, the home owner’s association and the property. She communicated well with my husband and me. She even set up a an A/C replacement in the unit at my mother in law’s request. Eliza was very professional. We had a great experience with Eliza.

Eliza Miller

Eliza Miller

  5   (21 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Seamless ...

From beginning to end Cheryl & her team were always on top of things & it required minimal effort on our part (the sellers).

Cheryl Santelli

Cheryl Santelli

  5   (14 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Eliza Miller

I feel like I’ve made a friend with Eliza. My situation was a bit of a roller coaster but in the end she was someone I could really turn to for support, friendship and intervention on my behalf!

Eliza Miller

Eliza Miller

  5   (21 reviews)
over 3 years ago
EZ to work with!

From start to finish, Eliza is always there to assist. Very knowledgeable realtor and full of ideas. She will make you happy you hired her.

Eliza Miller

Eliza Miller

  5   (21 reviews)
almost 4 years ago
Amazing Agent!

Eliza was wonderful to work with throughout the process of purchasing our condo. She was super knowledgeable, extremely professional, and very responsive to all of our many questions! It was such a pleasure working with her and we look forward to keeping in touch when we vacation at our new property as we have definitely found a true friend!

Eliza Miller

Eliza Miller

  5   (21 reviews)
almost 4 years ago
Awesome buying experience!!

Eliza is very professional and patient! She was also always ready to help us check out properties we were interested in. We loved working with her! And would definitely recommend you give her a try!

Eliza Miller

Eliza Miller

  5   (21 reviews)
about 4 years ago
Exceptional

In the past year, I have been involved with four real estate transactions as both buyer and seller. From this recent experience, I can say with full confidence that Eliza Miller made all the difference. She helped sell a property for my family. The transaction was challenging as it was located out of state for me, so communication was of utmost importance. Eliza is extremely skilled when it comes to distilling down the facts and communicating with appropriate urgency the ins and out of selling a property. Not only that, but Eliza went above and beyond what I expected as an agent, especially because I could not be on site much of the time. I also found Eliza to be very knowledgeable when it came to pricing the home, in fact, she was spot on her prediction for the final sales price. She offered excellent information and guided us through the process. There were quite a few ups and downs from the Buyers perspective, but Elize took it all in stride and kept things right on track. I would absolutely recommend her and would hire her again without hesitation.

Eliza Miller

Eliza Miller

  5   (21 reviews)
about 4 years ago
Everything was so smooth!

I enjoyed working with you!

Cheryl Santelli

Cheryl Santelli

  5   (14 reviews)
about 4 years ago
Excellent Service with a Personal Touch!

Eliza did an excellent job helping us navigate the sales process while selling our Siesta Key condo at Peppertree Bay. She is detailed oriented, professional, and communicates clearly and promptly. Although we had some disappointing moments including broken contracts, Eliza was always helpful, gave us excellent advice, and guided us moving forward to a positive outcome. Eliza knows the area, has excellent knowledge of market values especially Peppertree Bay and understands the advantages of the Peppertree community to potential buyers. We are very happy that our condo has sold and highly recommend Eliza Miller to any future clients looking to sell property in the Sarasota area.

Eliza Miller

Eliza Miller

  5   (21 reviews)
about 4 years ago
The agent that doesn't take a break...

Cheryl from the beginning showed my that she wanted to make the deal happen. She was full of knowledgeable information on the subject property. I never felt that something was happening without my knowledge. She is an open book. Very trustworthy person and extremely helpful during and after the transaction. I was surprised to see how much time and effort she puts in. 10 points for her!!

Cheryl Santelli

Cheryl Santelli

  5   (14 reviews)
13 - 24 of 35
PEPPERTREE BAY REALTY  INC
Contact PEPPERTREE BAY REALTY INC
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent