Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
811 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
about 10 years ago
Wonderful realtor and very reliable

Gale is a wonderful realtor and very reliable. We have bought and sold four houses with her. She helped us sell our last home for list price and negotiated the purchase of our current Winter Park house. She was very professional during the buying and selling process. Gale was on top of everything, helping us step by step. We highly recommend her.

Gale Milgrim

Gale Milgrim

  5   (95 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Selling my home of 20 years as a single female was very overwhelming

Selling my home of 20 years as a single female was very overwhelming. Amy walked into my world and helped me make a plan. She brought in the best contractors to work on updating and meeting codes. She helped me make decisions and to prioritize tasks. She was always available and took an active role in the selling process. Amy is very professional and was sensitive to feelings I had regarding leaving my home. My home had no furniture and I was sleeping on mats while in Winter Park working on my home. The day I met Amy, she she brought me a blow up mattress. That was truly a gift from God. Amy made it all possible and helped me problem solve when an issue came up that needing action. If not for her, I would still be stuck and overwhelmed. Amy was amazing. I would highly recommend her to any one buying or selling their home. It was her ideas and guidance that helped me sell my home before it went on the market.

Amy Turner

Amy Turner

  5   (25 reviews)
over 10 years ago
We moved to central Florida in July, 2002 and purchased a home in Celebration through Gale Milgrim

We moved to central Florida in July, 2002 and purchased a home in Celebration through Gale Milgrim. From our initial conversation until the closing, Gale was friendly, knowledgeable, patient and professional. She met and exceeded our expectations throughout the transaction. Fast forward to July, 2015 when we were once again in the market for a new home. Gale had long ago left Celebration for Winter Park and, as luck would have it, we were moving to Winter Park. We reached out to Gale and were happy to reconnect with that same friendly, knowledgeable, patient professional we had met 13 years earlier (and somehow none of us had aged a day!) Again, Gale helped us through every stage of the buying process. She listened to our wish list, suggested appropriate properties and negotiated an excellent deal on the house of our choice. Gale went the extra mile to get us a contract that worked for our budget and she did it with grace, humor and style. Gale is a terrific Realtor...she has our thanks, our highest praise and our full recommendation!

Gale Milgrim

Gale Milgrim

  5   (95 reviews)
over 10 years ago
We are so fortunate to have found Gale when we moved to Orlando

We are so fortunate to have found Gale when we moved to Orlando. For over 18 years she has been our realtor and has helped us sell three homes and buy two. Each time, she has brought to the table her thorough real estate knowledge, her extremely hard work ethic and her enthusiasm to get the job done. She is always available to answer any questions, and give good advice. She is a true professional that knows the market in the Central Florida area extremely well. We have always been so happy to have her on our side because we know she will have our best interest in mind. If I could rate her 10 stars, I would do so. Thank you Gale for your wonderful and professional service over the years.

Gale Milgrim

Gale Milgrim

  5   (95 reviews)
over 10 years ago
I contacted Mrs. Dawn Tinder of Keller Williams...

I contacted Mrs. Dawn Tinder of Keller Williams Realty upon my daughter's recommendation. Mrs. Tinder proved to extremely competent with her professional knowledge of the area and the market trends. She kept me informed throughout the process of purchasing a home, and was very helpful patiently explaining paperwork that I didn't understand. I highly recommend Mrs. Dawn Tinder to anyone who needs an expert real estate professional.

Dawn Tinder

Dawn Tinder

  5   (4 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Dawn Tinder is who you want as your real estate...

Dawn Tinder is who you want as your real estate agent. She is a top notch, highly skilled professional agent that you can rely on and trust. Dawn is who you get, not an assistant. She makes you her priority. She truly wants you to find the right home. She has lived in Central Florida her entire life and she knows her territory well. She loves what she does and it shows through her dedication, flexibility and her non-stop smile and pleasant attitude day in and day out. Her passion for her career is obvious. You can't go wrong with Dawn Tinder -- you'll end up wanting her not only as your real estate agent, but also as your friend and business partner!

Dawn Tinder

Dawn Tinder

  5   (4 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Entrusting someone to handle the sale of your home is a huge personal commitment

Entrusting someone to handle the sale of your home is a huge personal commitment. When we chose Amy to sell our home we sat down with her to discuss why we're selling, what we wanted, and she LISTENED to every single detail. She got to know us, our house, our neighborhood, our story... Amy was honest, she educated us on how to prepare the house, she studied the comparable and current sales daily, she went to open houses, and walked around the Pines and talked to people. When it came time to list our house, Amy had a plan, a timeline, a strategy and all the tools to not only sell our home, but to find and assist a buyer. Amy sold our house in less than a week and we got a great market price! She has fresh ideas and is passionate about what she does!

Amy Turner

Amy Turner

  5   (25 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Andy used his vast experience in locating and qualifying the homes that we visited!

My husband and I recently used Andy as our agent as we looked for a new home in the Maitland Winter Park area. Andy used his vast experience in locating and qualifying the homes that we visited! He went to great lengths to find the best fit for the location, price and amenities that we requested. As we struggled with finding the perfect fit, Andy suggested we might consider finding a lot and build a new home. We then shifted our search and Andy found a great lot in a perfect location! He also connected us with some of this areas finest builders! We were extremely pleased with Andy and his expertise, as well his determination to bring our search to the perfect conclusion ! Sincerely, Jill Eiserman

Andy Lockhart

Andy Lockhart

  5   (28 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Andy was a pleasure to work with!

Andy was a pleasure to work with. He listened to what we wanted and did not try to sell us something different. He was professional throughout the process. He was very knowledgeable of the local market and was always very responsive. I would certainly recommend Andy to friends and family.

Andy Lockhart

Andy Lockhart

  5   (28 reviews)
about 11 years ago
Holly is outstanding! She did an excellent job of consulting us on pricing and upgrades needed to ma

Holly is outstanding! She did an excellent job of consulting us on pricing and upgrades needed to market the home, kept us up-to-date on progress, and made the process easy by working through most documents online. This was particularly helpful because we needed to sell the house from afar. There are a lot of real estate agents out there. Holly is one you want by your side.

Holly Wilton

Holly Wilton

  5   (20 reviews)
793 - 804 of 811
KELLER WILLIAMS WINTER PARK
Contact KELLER WILLIAMS WINTER PARK
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent