Cutler Real Estate | LifePoint Real Estate Group

168 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081, United States
  •   5   (10 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Cutler Real Estate | LifePoint Real Estate Group has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

4
Reviews

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 15 agents at Cutler Real Estate | LifePoint Real Estate Group.

Amy Clark
Amy Clark

REALTOR®

  5   (3 reviews)
About Amy
Where You Want to Be I am Amy Clark, the Team Leader of LifePoint Real Estate Group at Cutler Real Estate. With over 20 years' experience in the industry, I know how important it is to have an agent you can trust with your money, your family, or your real estate investments. Our award-winning team is comprised of some of the best agents in Central Ohio, ranking in the top 1% in sales volume. We understand the importance of quick responses and personal attention, which is why we make it a priority to be AVAILABLE when you need us most. Whether you have a question about a property or need assistance navigating the buying or selling process, we are here to guide you every step of the way. Clear COMMUNICATION is key in real estate and we pride ourselves on being transparent while also respecting your privacy. We strive to connect with clients to understand individual needs and tailor our approach accordingly so that you feel comfortable and confident throughout the entire process. We work diligently to ensure transactions are completed with EFFICIENCY saving you time and money while minimizing stress. We bring a wealth of industry knowledge and negotiation expertise to the table to achieve the best possible outcome. We believe in asking the right questions and we genuinely CARE about you going above and beyond to ensure your needs are met. We are direct in our communication, always striving to be calm, cool, and caring while maintaining honesty and integrity in all interactions. Whether you are buying, selling, or investing, we approach each transaction with a business FOCUS, ensuring that your interests are protected every step of the way while always keeping the relationship at the forefront of every interaction. You can trust that you are in good hands with the LifePoint Real Estate Group at Cutler Real Estate!
View Profile
Kelly Shuff
Kelly Shuff

REALTOR®

  5   (2 reviews)
About Kelly
CARING - RESPECT - GRATITUDE Kelly Shuff is a Senior Real Estate Consultant on the team serving buyers and sellers in Central Ohio. Since 2002 LifePoint Real Estate Group at Cutler Real Estate has grown to be ranked in the top 20 agents in the Columbus Board of REALTORS® with annual sales over $40 million. LifePoint Real Estate Group has always focused on providing clients with the best technology and marketing available while maintaining a boutique level of customer service. "This team is incredible to work with! Professional, friendly, knowledgeable... I could go on and on. Their level of attentiveness to detail is unmatched, right down to where they place the For-Sale sign in your yard. Everyone plays their part and does it so well, put together the entire group is a well-oiled machine. Over the years our agent has become our friend and we can't imagine going through this with anyone but her, she makes it so smooth and easy. If you haven't used Clark Realty Group yet you don't know what you're missing, they really are the best in the business." LifePoint Real Estate Group of agents are hand-selected, highly-respected real estate consultants who fully embrace a customer-first approach to real estate by bringing relationship-building to the forefront of every client interaction. Everyone has a story and we are all at different points of life with unique wants and needs. Understanding these truths and meeting people right where they are is at the heart of our company. We are your one-stop real estate resource for all your residential and commercial buying and selling needs.
View Profile
Mallory Watson
Mallory Watson

REALTOR®

  5   (2 reviews)
About Mallory
CARING - RESPECT - GRATITUDE Mallory Watson is Co-Team-Lead and Senior Real Estate Consultant on the team. Since 2002 LifePoint Real Estate Group at Cutler Real Estate has grown to be ranked in the top 20 agents in the Columbus Board of REALTORS® with annual sales over $42 million. LifePoint Real Estate Group has always focused on providing clients with the best technology and marketing available while maintaining a boutique level of customer service. "This team is incredible to work with! Professional, friendly, knowledgeable...I could go on and on. Their level of attentiveness to detail is unmatched, right down to where they place the For-Sale sign in your yard. Everyone plays their part and does it so well, put together the entire group is a well-oiled machine. Over the years our agent has become our friend and we can't imagine going through this with anyone but her, she makes it so smooth and easy. If you haven't used Clark Realty Group yet you don't know what you're missing, they really are the best in the business." LifePoint Real Estate Group of agents are hand-selected, highly-respected real estate consultants who fully embrace a customer-first approach to real estate by bringing relationship-building to the forefront of every client interaction. Everyone has a story and we are all at different points of life with unique wants and needs. Understanding these truths and meeting people right where they are is at the heart of our company. We are your one-stop real estate resource for all your residential and commercial buying and selling needs.
View Profile
Aiden Nelson
Aiden Nelson

REALTOR®

  5   (1 review)
About Aiden
Choosing the right REALTOR® is about more than just finding the perfect property—it’s about building a lasting relationship with someone who listens, understands, and truly cares. My name is Aiden, and I was born and raised in Columbus, Ohio. I believe in fostering relationships that go beyond the transaction. With a background in customer service, I’ve developed a deep understanding of what it means to truly serve others. My experience in communication and navigating complex situations with patience and understanding enables me to offer more than just expert guidance in real estate. I strive to provide an experience that makes every step of the process smoother and more personal for you. I view every client relationship as a partnership—one that doesn’t end when you sign the papers. My goal is to ensure that you not only achieve your real estate objectives but also feel supported, informed, and valued throughout the entire journey—and beyond. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, you can count on me to be there every step of the way and to maintain that relationship long after the deal is done. Choosing to work with me means you’re gaining a dedicated partner who genuinely cares about your success and well-being. I look forward to helping you reach your goals and building a relationship that will last far into the future.
View Profile
Jill Taylor
Jill Taylor

REALTOR®

  5   (1 review)
About Jill
Jill Taylor is a Listing and Buying Specialist with LifePoint Real Estate Group at Cutler Real Estate. She is a seasoned, top producing, real estate professional who has been licensed since 2012 in both Ohio and California. With over a decade of experience in the industry, Jill has cultivated a reputation for her calm demeanor and meticulous attention to detail. Her clients consistently praise her commitment and the genuine care she extends, often forming lasting friendships. Her approach is client-centric, ensuring everyone receives personalized and thorough service throughout their real estate journey. This dedication has not only earned her a loyal clientele but also the respect and admiration of her peers in the real estate community. Whether you are buying or selling, Jill Taylor offers unparalleled expertise and a steady hand to guide you through every step of the process. Trust in her proven record of accomplishment and let her make your real estate experience seamless and rewarding.
View Profile
Kristi Hicks
Kristi Hicks

REALTOR®

  5   (1 review)
About Kristi
CARING - RESPECT - GRATITUDE Kristi Simpson is a Senior Real Estate consultant on the team serving buyers and sellers in Central Ohio. Since 2002 LifePoint Real Estate Group at Cutler Real Estate has grown to be ranked in the top 20 agents in the Columbus Board of REALTORS® with annual sales over $42 million. LifePoint Real Estate Group has always focused on providing clients with the best technology and marketing available while maintaining a boutique level of customer service. "This team is incredible to work with! Professional, friendly, knowledgeable...I could go on and on. Their level of attentiveness to detail is unmatched, right down to where they place the For-Sale sign in your yard. Everyone plays their part and does it so well, put together the entire group is a well-oiled machine. Over the years our agent has become our friend and we can't imagine going through this with anyone but her, she makes it so smooth and easy. If you haven't used Clark Realty Group yet you don't know what you're missing, they really are the best in the business.” LifePoint Real Estate Group of agents are hand-selected, highly-respected real estate consultants who fully embrace a customer-first approach to real estate by bringing relationship-building to the forefront of every client interaction. Everyone has a story and we are all at different points of life with unique wants and needs. Understanding these truths and meeting people right where they are is at the heart of our company. We are your one-stop real estate resource for all your residential and commercial buying and selling needs.
View Profile

About us

Cutler Real Estate is a family-owned, boutique brokerage that aligns closely with LifePoint Real Estate Group’s core values and beliefs. Together, we combine the strength of a national marketing platform with the personalized touch of a boutique real estate team. LifePoint Real Estate Group agents offer unparalleled resources, technology, and market reach while staying true to our commitment to local expertise and exceptional service. Your Columbus & Central Ohio Real Estate Experts Our team of agents is agile, responsive, and adaptable—free from the limitations of rigid franchise structures. This flexibility allows us to navigate market trends, financial shifts, and client needs with precision and care. Whether you’re buying or selling residential or commercial real estate, LifePoint Real Estate Group is your one-stop resource for expert guidance, strategic marketing, and a seamless transaction experience. LifePoint Real Estate Group’s mission is to “Meet each person at their unique point of life to guide them from where they are, to where they want to be”. It’s about relationships, trust, and delivering outstanding results.

Our reviews

  5  
7 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 6.
Seller review
Professional and Knowledgeable
11 months ago
Professional and Knowledgeable

There knowledge of the area and real-estate helped guide us through today's market.

Amy Clark

Amy Clark

  5   (3 reviews)
Seller review
Thank You!
11 months ago
Thank You!

Kelly was very knowledgeable, professional and accessible throughout the entire process. From help with planning to go to market, going to market, and then working through the closing stages - she was an amazing asset. We will look for her again whenever we need to sell, and will recommend her to anyone that asks for real estate assistance. Thank You!

Kelly Shuff

Kelly Shuff

  5   (2 reviews)
Seller review
Best Agent Ever
11 months ago
Best Agent Ever

This is the second home I have sold with Amy and Mallory. I also bought a home thru them. Mallory has a way of making you feel at ease with the whole process. Buying/ selling a home is stressful, Amy and Mallory took great care of me. They worked with me on what value my home should be and they got me over asking price. Overall I would recommend them and will use them again when I'm ready to buy.

Amy Clark

Amy Clark

  5   (3 reviews)
Seller review
Smooth and Easy
11 months ago
Smooth and Easy

Thank you, Amy and Mallory, for a smooth and easy sale of my condo! It was one of the smoothest real estate transactions I have had!

Amy Clark

Amy Clark

  5   (3 reviews)
Buyer review
Aiden was on time, every time, for each and every appointment!
over 1 year ago
Aiden was on time, every time, for each and every appointment!

Aiden was on time, every time, for each and every appointment, and equally as prompt in her response to emails, texts, and phone calls. Additionally, she was personable with a great sense of humor, which was a nice bonus when house hunting ~ not all realtors are this way. In the end, we were able to find a great house at $30k under our budget in the highly competitive Columbus OH market.

Aiden Nelson

Aiden Nelson

  5   (1 review)
Show all 7 reviews
map

Our properties

Cutler Real Estate | LifePoint Real Estate Group hasn't had any property sale activity in the last 12 months

© 2026 RateMyAgent