Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
42 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: pleasant, patient, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Fantastic experience
9 months ago
Fantastic experience

Working with Julie and Peggy was a fantastic experience! We met Julie by happenstance when we decided to check out one of her open houses. While our plan was buy was a future goal (at least a year!), we came across our forever home just a month later and her expertise helped us navigate every single step with patience and confidence. She was quick to get us a showing and since we had not fully prepared to buy so soon, she worked diligently to connect us with an available loan officer that same day (on a holiday nonetheless, when all banks were closed!) so we could have a pre-approval in hand and submit an offer. She stayed up late through the bidding war, into the evening of the home inspection, and coached us on what to prioritize as we put our home up for sale. We have bought and sold a few time before, but this was hands down the smoothest process of anyone we have worked with. We would put every confidence in her if we ever had to buy or sell again and have already recommended her to friends looking for a realtor.

Julie Worstell
Seller review
You need Peggy and her team!
9 months ago
You need Peggy and her team!

When other realtors just saw dollar signs, Peggy and Julie saw me as a person. The market is difficult and competition is high, but Peggy and Julie saved us from a bad situation and turned things around quickly and professionally. I can’t say enough that I am not an easy client, but the patience they had for me was extraordinary. No question was too dumb, nothing was unreasonable, they just got right to business and got the job done. If your realtor isn’t getting it done for you in these hard times, definitely give Peggy a call and see what she can do for you!

Peggy Johnston
Seller review
Peggy is the best.
10 months ago
Peggy is the best.

Peggy was phenomenal in every way. She was a dream to work with. She met all of our expectations and more. We are thrilled with the results!!! I’d highly recommend her to everyone!!!!

Peggy Johnston
Seller review
Best in the business!
11 months ago
Best in the business!

Peggy gave us great advice, had our backs when issues arose, knew the best people to call when repairs were needed, was always available and treated us like good friends. Others told us we had the best in the business and we agree.

Peggy Johnston
Seller review
The Best There Is
11 months ago
The Best There Is

If I could give Peggy’s team 10 stars I would. My family and I have had the pleasure of working with Peggy and her team several times and they never disappoint. They offer sound, honest and professional advice and guide clients through the process, whether buying or selling. If you’re looking for a true real estate pro, I highly recommend Peggy.

Peggy Johnston
Seller review
The Best There Is
11 months ago
The Best There Is

At the closing of the sale of my dad’s home, our title lawyer said “You know you have the best agent there is.” Both in that sale and in the recent sale of our home, that has been absolutely true. We couldn’t have asked for a more positive experience. Peggy’s knowledge of the market, guidance in the pricing and timing, response to questions, and resolving of unexpected issues made the process as smooth as it could have been. We cannot recommend Peggy and her team more highly.

Peggy Johnston
Seller review
Wonderful,  Peggy was so very knowledgeable and amenable to our desires.
11 months ago
Wonderful, Peggy was so very knowledgeable and amenable to our desires.

She was ever so gracious and her knowledge of the market and availability in our area. This helped us to be realistic about pricing. She did everything we asked and more! She was dealing with a very difficult buyer. Who kept breaking the rules, by showing up at times without his realtor Consent bringing with him contractors To examine the roof ! After the inspection was completed. I observed him on my Ring Camera and called Peggy, the final time after he had signed paperwork to purchase the house, I called Peggy and told her the next time I will call the police! He was such a rude man for everyone to deal with! Peggy handled it with grace and professionalism I couldn’t have asked for a person. She worked closely with my daughter in law Kelly when I was unable to.

Peggy Johnston
13 - 24 of 42
Cutler Real Estate | Johnston Team
Contact Cutler Real Estate | Johnston Team
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent