Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
64 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
9 months ago
Nicole was the best part about buying a home!

Nicole was the best part about buying a home. She's so personable and sweet, patient, extremely thorough, makes sure you understand every step of the way, and really just makes you feel like you've known one another forever - like she's helping her best friend pick out a home. She is ultimately the reason we ended up getting this home despite other offers. I could not recommend her enough - if you don't have a realtor and are in need of one - look no further. You'd be in great hands!

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (43 reviews)
9 months ago
From start to finish Nicole was just the best.

From start to finish Nicole was just the best. Knowledgeable, communicative, and simply present and on top of every step of the process. We even ended up buying the house of our dreams with a bid lower than other competing offers thanks to her negotiating on our behalf. I wouldn’t use anyone else in the future.

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (43 reviews)
10 months ago
Nicole is the absolute best—seriously.

Nicole is the absolute best—seriously. From day one, she was warm, patient, and completely on top of everything. She helped us find our very first home and made the process feel easy, always taking the time to make sure we felt informed and supported. Every question was answered, and we never felt left in the dark. We’re so grateful to have worked with her. Couldn’t recommend her more!

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (43 reviews)
10 months ago
Donna is the absolute best!

When it came time to sell my home, and buy a new one, I didn't know where to start. I reached out to Donna with a recommendation from a friend and I'm so glad I did. She walked me through the whole process from looking at houses (for almost a year!!!), to helping me purge as I prepped to move, to staging the house for sale, and, of course, showing it. She was able to get me 20% above asking for my sale. For both the sale and the purchase, she worked very well with the other side and we were able to close on both quickly. I couldn't have done this without her.

Donna Nikic

Donna Nikic

  5   (13 reviews)
11 months ago
Donna was my MVP!

Highly recommend Donna for your house hunt! She helped me get my dream home in a very tough buyer's market, in a very high-demand area. I'm confident few other Realtors have the savvy to make your purchase go so smoothly— her experience was invaluable throughout the whole process. Would surely use again when the time comes!

Donna Nikic

Donna Nikic

  5   (13 reviews)
11 months ago
Nicole Biello is an incredible realtor who held our hand through a very complicated and difficult ye

Nicole Biello is an incredible realtor who held our hand through a very complicated and difficult year of preparing our father's house for sale. She knows the Westchester market inside and out, and she has a great network of professionals to help with all of the tasks involved in preparing for a sale. Thanks to her work, we got well over asking and a quick closing. We highly recommend Nicole!

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (43 reviews)
about 1 year ago
Nicole absolutely exceeded our expectations! As first-time homebuyers looking...

Nicole absolutely exceeded our expectations! As first-time homebuyers looking, we were looking for someone who knew Westchester (as a place to live, not just as a market) and who was willing to help us understand the byzantine homebuying process. Nicole delivered! She was timely in her replies, patient with her explanations, and diligent throughout the whole process. We never once felt pressured or rushed. We could not be happier with our experience and are delighted to recommend her.

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (43 reviews)
about 1 year ago
We had a great experience working with Nicole while searching for our first home...

We had a great experience working with Nicole while searching for our first home. The market was super competitive, and we felt a bit overwhelmed at first. Thankfully Nicole was not only knowledgeable but also incredibly patient with us. She took the time to understand what we were looking for and guided us through the entire process, making it feel much less daunting. Whenever we had questions or concerns, she was always just a text or call away, ready to help. Nicole helped us see new listings as soon as they came up, and gave us great advice on how to make our offers more competitive. Thanks to her expertise and dedication, we found a home that we truly love and got it under asked price! We couldn’t be more grateful for all of her help. If you’re searching for an Agent… look no further, Nicole is the one!

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (43 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Working with Nicole was an absolute pleasure

Working with Nicole was an absolute pleasure. She was not pushy and VERY supportive. Her suggestions were helpful and she was always willing to go the extra mile. I am glad that I stuck it out with her. We found a really nice home at a great price!

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (43 reviews)
over 1 year ago
The Best in Westchester County

If you are considering engaging Donna Nikic, look no further. I needed to hire an agent in New York to manage the sale of my parents’ home and investment properties. My family recently completed a very challenging transaction with Donna for their long-time home in Croton. The house had been neglected as my parents aged and it needed extensive TLC and complete staging. Donna provided an excellent analysis of the different approaches to ready the house for market keeping an eye on the bottom line. No one wants to spend big money to prepare a home for sale, and Donna understood that perfectly. Donna took charge of everything, handling dozens of maintenance tasks. She staged the 4,400 sq. ft. home from top to bottom as part of her commission. She worked tirelessly to prepare the offering in record time. Her experience and contacts in residential construction were invaluable. An added challenge was working with my 85+ year old parents who were moving out of state. Donna treated my parents like they were her own, demonstrating a level of patience that is hard to articulate—it came from her inner core. We interviewed a few other real estate agents before making a decision and Donna stood out. She had her eye on a target number that was $500,000 higher than her competitors vying for the listing. She knows the Westchester County market and secures top dollar for your home. The right offer was accepted within two weeks. As a result, we hired her for additional properties that anyone would typically pass off to a junior partner. These properties were dirty, neglected, and occupied by long-term tenants who had no intention of moving. Donna rolled up her sleeves and jumped into the challenge. The two properties went above asking with cash offers secured in a weekend. Her experience in coordinating permit issues with local governments, carpenters, plumbers, electricians, and other service providers is rarely found. I can’t imagine better outcomes.

Donna Nikic

Donna Nikic

  5   (13 reviews)
13 - 24 of 64
© 2026 RateMyAgent