Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
63 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
25 days ago
Nicole’s been a rockstar!

We got the chance to work with Nicole through a Compass referral and we are so glad that it worked out that way because Nicole’s been a rock star! She was a great steward for us during the whole process, and was patient and effective in our communication and strategy. She was always available to answer questions and provide guidance when we needed to make important decisions, which was tremendously helpful for us first-time sellers. I’d give 6 out of 5 stars if I could!

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (42 reviews)
about 1 month ago
Nicole found us our dream home!

Nicole found us our dream home! She was wonderful to work with, and made our search enjoyable and informed, especially in a competitive market. We are lucky to have been referred to her by another Compass agent, and she took care of us! We are forever grateful and highly recommend her if you are looking to buy anywhere in Westchester.

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (42 reviews)
about 2 months ago
Expert Guidance with Genuine Care

Working with Donna was an absolutely wonderful experience. She was incredibly patient with us as we took our time and played the long game before making an offer, never rushing us and always making sure we felt confident in our decisions. Donna truly went above and beyond—conducting thorough research, making multiple trips to the property and even to the town office to gather additional information, and ensuring we had a complete picture every step of the way. She also took the time to educate us about the process and what to look out for in the house, which made us feel informed and empowered as buyers. What meant the most was how much she advocated for us. Donna really went to bat for us and was deeply protective of our interests throughout. On top of all that, she is warm, friendly, and genuinely caring—a total delight to work with. We feel so lucky to have had Donna by our side and can’t recommend her highly enough.

Donna Nikic

Donna Nikic

  5   (13 reviews)
about 2 months ago
Donna was the absolute best!

Working with Donna was an incredible experience from start to finish. She guided me through a particularly challenging negotiation with confidence and expertise, always advocating for my best interests while keeping the process moving forward. What truly set her apart was not just her professionalism, but her kindness and genuine care. She took the time to understand my needs, kept me informed every step of the way, and made what could have been a stressful experience feel manageable and even exciting. I’m so grateful for her support and dedication—I honestly feel like she’s become part of my family. I couldn’t recommend her more highly to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Donna Nikic

Donna Nikic

  5   (13 reviews)
4 months ago
Very knowledgeable

Kathy is easy quick to respond

Katherine Sheehan

Katherine Sheehan

  5   (4 reviews)
5 months ago
Deep local market knowledge, strong negotiation skills, and a personalized, client-focused approach

As a first-time buyer, I had no clue what was involved in buying a house.One of my friends suggested that I contact Katherine, as they had a great experience using her services. katherine turned out to be the sweetest person I’ve ever met. Not only did she find the house of my dreams, but she also helped me find contractors to help with the minor remodeling. I think I made a friend for life!

Katherine Sheehan

Katherine Sheehan

  5   (4 reviews)
6 months ago
Could not have asked for a better Realtor!

Nicole is the absolute best. She was so patient with our three year house hunt. She demonstrated professionalism and guided us in the right direction to our dream home. She was absolutely clutch in negotiating and getting us through the finish line. Very prompt via email, text and call, always available for us and we never felt like an inconvenience to her. Could not have asked for a better Realitor!

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (42 reviews)
6 months ago
Words cannot describe how lucky my wife and I were to have Nicole as our realtor.

Words cannot describe how lucky my wife and I were to have Nicole as our realtor. She truly was there for both of us every step of the way to help us find our forever home. Her professionalism and care during this process was unmatched all while being one of the most genuine people I have ever met. She knew how to handle every situation. Any paperwork that was “impossible to find” Nicole found within in an hour. I feel bad for my friends when they say that they already have a realtor because they truly are missing to being able to with the best. It was a pleasure to work with Nicole and I will be recommending her to anyone that will be looking for a home.

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (42 reviews)
7 months ago
No pressure and very knowledgeable

Kathy did a great job listening to what I wanted and knows the ins and outs of the area very well. She also gave great recommendations for the other people I needed to help make my sale and purchase happen! I would recommend her to anyone looking. Thanks Kathy! Can't wait to show you what I've done at the house!

Katherine Sheehan

Katherine Sheehan

  5   (4 reviews)
7 months ago
Good agent and knows the area well!

Kathy is amazing! She knows the area well and really will take time to know you. Her style is exactly what I wanted-not pushy and not making me feel pressured. Her advice for my needs was so appreciated and I am very, very thankful for having to have worked with her for my sale AND my purchase! 😘

Katherine Sheehan

Katherine Sheehan

  5   (4 reviews)
9 months ago
A Truly Exceptional Partner in Our Home Sale

Working with our Real Estate Agent, Donna Nikic, was an absolute pleasure and the best decision we could have made when selling our home. As someone deeply connected to the community, she brought an unparalleled level of knowledge and insight to the process. From our very first meeting, it was clear she was a tremendous asset. Her professionalism was matched only by her genuine care for our family’s needs. Donna took the time to listen closely to our priorities, tailoring her approach so that our home’s story was beautifully presented. She worked with us to orchestrate every detail—from staging and photography to open houses and negotiations—with remarkable precision and warmth. Throughout the entire process, Donna’s communication was exemplary. She was straight forward and transparent throughout the process, always setting clear, realistic and appropriate expectations. We never felt like we were in the dark, we never felt like we were alone, and we always felt supported. She was readily available to answer our questions, provide updates, and offer reassurance whenever uncertainties arose. Her ability to anticipate challenges and address them proactively meant that the process unfolded smoothly from start to finish. We are so grateful for Donna. Selling a home can be a stressful experience, but her calm confidence and expertise made us feel supported and confident. She not only helped us achieve a fantastic result on the sale of our home, but she also left us with a sense of gratitude for her unwavering support and commitment. It’s rare to encounter someone so dedicated and passionate about their work, and we feel truly fortunate to have had her by our side during this pivotal chapter in our lives. We wholeheartedly recommend Donna to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, trustworthy, and dedicated real estate agent.

Donna Nikic

Donna Nikic

  5   (13 reviews)
9 months ago
Nicole was the best part about buying a home!

Nicole was the best part about buying a home. She's so personable and sweet, patient, extremely thorough, makes sure you understand every step of the way, and really just makes you feel like you've known one another forever - like she's helping her best friend pick out a home. She is ultimately the reason we ended up getting this home despite other offers. I could not recommend her enough - if you don't have a realtor and are in need of one - look no further. You'd be in great hands!

Nicole Biello

Nicole Biello

  5   (42 reviews)
1 - 12 of 63
© 2026 RateMyAgent