Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
68 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: attentive, responsive, friendly, reliable, clear communication, local expert, well-prepared.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
 Thank you for everything that you have done when it comes to selling the house.
over 1 year ago
Thank you for everything that you have done when it comes to selling the house.

Dear Mario Benavente, thank you for everything that you have done when it comes to selling the house. You have made the process simple, easy, quick, and understandable for me. I appreciate everything you have done and hope to someday work again together.

Mario Benavente

Mario Benavente

  5   (5 reviews)
Seller review
Quincy has been there for us every step of the way He did a super job
over 1 year ago
Quincy has been there for us every step of the way He did a super job

Quincy has been there for us every step of the way He did a super job. Everything turned out great. Quincy is definitely someone I would recommend. A great professional job. Not only did he get our house closed but also found one for us to purchase. Thanks again for all your hard work

Quincy Robinson

Quincy Robinson

  5   (12 reviews)
Seller review
Rusty went above and beyond! We worked with Rusty to sell our house, buy a new house as well as sell
over 1 year ago
Rusty went above and beyond! We worked with Rusty to sell our house, buy a new house as well as sell

Rusty went above and beyond! We worked with Rusty to sell our house, buy a new house as well as sell my mothers. It was a year long process. Rusty answered any questions quickly, gave us advice and pointed out the options for the offers on all three houses. My husband and I feel like we gained a friend and would recommend him to anyone. If we ever need advice or need a realtor again he we will be the first person we call!!

Rusty Downey

Rusty Downey

  5   (14 reviews)
Seller review
Rusty went above and beyond! We worked with him to find and buy our house, sell my mothers and sell
over 1 year ago
Rusty went above and beyond! We worked with him to find and buy our house, sell my mothers and sell

Rusty went above and beyond! We worked with him to find and buy our house, sell my mothers and sell our house we moved from. It was a year long process and both my husband and I feel we have gained a friend! He responded to any questions quickly, provided insight and advice on the process of selling and buying a house.

Rusty Downey

Rusty Downey

  5   (14 reviews)
Buyer review
Happy Repeat Client
almost 2 years ago
Happy Repeat Client

Paul helped us find our first home in Columbus in 2019. It was such a positive experience that we sought Paul’s help again in 2024. And again, we enjoyed a wonderfully successful experience. Paul maintains his professionalism while still being personable. We felt like we had reconnected with an old friend. Paul is always helpful and offers sound and honest advice. He’s the best!!

Paul Furber

Paul Furber

  5   (31 reviews)
Seller review
Knowledgable, Prompt and Responsive
almost 2 years ago
Knowledgable, Prompt and Responsive

We had the listing agent interview process through the relocation company. Paul came to our house for interview and took the measurements himself in each room. This set him part from other agents who came to see the house then suggested a listing price point that they believed will likely make the sell but was below our expectation. Since we listed our house at the end of fall, Paul worked within his network to set up the viewings with potential buyers. During the contracting process, Paul addressed our inquires promptly and helped connect with GC to ensure the repair work was performed in a timely manner. Overall, we had a great experience with Paul as our listing agent. Will definitely recommend him.

Paul Furber

Paul Furber

  5   (31 reviews)
Seller review
Guided in this complex market
almost 2 years ago
Guided in this complex market

Paul knows his market, gave his recommendations and helped throughout the different steps. Paul's availability, professionalism and flexibility was key in the final closing stage. He went the extra mile. Market was complex but in the end our house sale was successful!

Paul Furber

Paul Furber

  5   (31 reviews)
Seller review
Paul is the ultimate broker
about 2 years ago
Paul is the ultimate broker

Paul is the ultimate broker. Very impressive customer service, knowledge and professionalism. I would recommend Paul without hesitation - hope to work with him in the future.

Paul Furber

Paul Furber

  5   (31 reviews)
37 - 48 of 68
Carpenter Realtors - Columbus
Contact Carpenter Realtors - Columbus
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent