Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
44 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, responsive, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Fast moving, confident, expert agent
11 days ago
Fast moving, confident, expert agent

From the first meeting with David to making an offer on a house through him took 6 weeks. And we moved into our new home in another 4 weeks. We really value David's expert advice on pricing, negotiations, disclosures and inspections. All complicated documents came with David's commentary on what to pay attention to.

David Hargreaves
Seller review
Top-notch expertise for challenging properties in Sonoma County.
18 days ago
Top-notch expertise for challenging properties in Sonoma County.

Working with David and Jonathan to sell our house in Monte Rio was a fantastic experience. Our property was particularly challenging to sell because it was split across four parcels and zoned for vacation rentals, but they handled the complexity really well. David and Jonathan knew exactly how to market the unique aspects of the home and target the right pool of buyers. Thanks to their expertise and teamwork, we had serious interest lined up quickly and closed the deal much faster than we anticipated. If you're selling a property in the area- especially one with unique zoning or land setups- I highly recommend working with David and Jonathan. They are thorough, professional, and handle every aspect of the sale.

David HargreavesJonathan Bruington
Seller review
Exceptional Service from Start to Finish
20 days ago
Exceptional Service from Start to Finish

We had an exceptional experience working with Jeff to sell our home. From start to finish, he went above and beyond to make us feel that we were truly his priority and that he was always our advocate throughout the process. What stood out most to us was how genuinely Jeff cared about our needs and our experience. He was very knowledgeable, and if we had questions or thoughts that were outside the norm, he took the time to research them thoroughly so he could give us a comprehensive and informed answer. We always felt confident that he had our best interests in mind. Jeff was also extremely helpful in coordinating the many details that come with selling a home. He helped us select reliable vendors and went above and beyond by helping communicate with them and schedule the work that needed to be completed at the house. His thoroughness and attention to detail made what could have been a stressful process feel much more manageable. He also put a lot of effort into marketing our home, including hosting open houses in addition to the standard marketing efforts. We truly appreciated the time, energy, and care he invested in helping us achieve a successful sale. We are incredibly grateful for everything Jeff did for us. We would absolutely work with him again and would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, dedicated, and genuinely caring real estate agent.

Jeffrey CatomerDavid Hargreaves
Buyer review
Consummate professional with great insight and communication.
26 days ago
Consummate professional with great insight and communication.

David was referred to me by an old friend and I learned quickly why. Based on my interests, I was provided insight on several homes that may be coming onto the market. As we narrowed our search, David put us in a great position to get our primary home. Upon signing the offer letter, he and his team worked to ensure that the transaction went smoothly with constant communication with title, financing and the seller's agent. They managed the process with the selling agent to insure we got what we were promised and followed up after we moved in to make sure we were happy. I could not recommend David more strongly.

David HargreavesJonathan Bruington
Buyer review
Patient and extremely knowledgeable about the market
about 1 month ago
Patient and extremely knowledgeable about the market

Patient with our long search process, deep knowledge of the entire Sonoma county market - super-professional staff and process when it came to the mechanics of getting the transaction completed.

David HargreavesJonathan Bruington
Buyer review
The agent really worked hard to close the deal!!!
about 1 month ago
The agent really worked hard to close the deal!!!

I've bought and sold 13 properties in my lifetime. This was the smoothest transaction yet! David really went to bat for me to close the deal on a home my wife and I loved!!! David is very professional. He made sure all of the details were taken care of so there were no hang ups at the end. Definitely a 5 star agent!

David HargreavesJonathan Bruington
Seller review
Combination of excellent marketing, effective communication, setting proper expectations and more
3 months ago
Combination of excellent marketing, effective communication, setting proper expectations and more

Jonathan navigated very challenging selling conditions perfectly. He never panicked. Always kept a positive and realistic view of the situation. His analytical ability enabled us to understand the changing conditions. He gave us space to make decisions while helping us clearly see the implications of different decisions. Jonathan’s communication is outstanding. Always very clear and precise. We couldn’t have had a better agent.

Jonathan BruingtonDavid Hargreaves
Buyer review
Amazing team to Sell Your Healdsburg Home
3 months ago
Amazing team to Sell Your Healdsburg Home

We couldn't have asked for more. We reach out to David as a top Realtor in Healdsburg and then we did more research and found Jonathan and then we realized they worked together so we ended up with two of the best agents forthe price of one! Efficient process to get our house sold quickly for a great price. We could not have asked for more

Jonathan BruingtonDavid Hargreaves
Buyer review
A buyer agent going above and beyond.
3 months ago
A buyer agent going above and beyond.

Late 2025 we decided to relocate from NOVA to Sonoma county and enlisted the help of Jeff Catomer. With the priceless help of Jeff, we generated a short list and visited early March for a week. Jeff patiently guided us through about 2 dozen properties, resulting in a couple of offers. Unfortunately, we lost out in bidding wars. Jeff figured out very quickly what we were looking for and continued the house hunt remotely. In early April Jeff presented 1145 Portello Lane to us. He visited the property and did a virtual walk through via mobile phone and answered a gazillion of our questions. We decided to make an offer and Jeff's analysis was very helpful in determining the offer price. Our offer was accepted the following day, closed a couple of weeks later and moved in end of May 2026 after a 1 month rent-back period. Throughout the journey Jeff consistently went above and beyond. He never took any short cuts and always went the extra mile. We would describe him as pro-active and very responsive. To us, he isn't just a buyer agent. We experienced him as absolutely trustworthy fiduciary, and because of this quality, we had the trust to buy site unseen and we would do it again. Since Jeff grew up in Sonoma county, he brings unparalleled local knowledge to the table. This helped us to optimize our search and find exactly the property in a location that met our requirements. If you are looking for a realtor in Sonoma county, look no further. Just contact Jeff Catomer.

Jeffrey Catomer
Buyer review
Highly Recommended
3 months ago
Highly Recommended

We had a fantastic experience working with David on our recent home purchase in Healdsburg. His local market knowledge is unmatched, and he made sure our interests were protected every step of the way. He kept us informed, answered our questions swiftly, and made a complex process feel smooth and stress-free. We wouldn't hesitate to work with him again. He's professional, responsive, and highly recommended!

David Hargreaves
Buyer review
Jeff made this super easy for us
3 months ago
Jeff made this super easy for us

I would recommend Jeff to anyone who is looking to purchase a home. Jeff was always available to discuss our plan and he handled all of the logistics for us including helping us schedule inspections, repairs, etc. I would use Jeff again if we ever needed to sell or buy.

Jeffrey Catomer
Buyer review
Exceptional Partner in Finding Our Wine Country Dream Home
3 months ago
Exceptional Partner in Finding Our Wine Country Dream Home

We cannot recommend Jonathan highly enough! Throughout our search for a property in Wine Country, Jonathan was an invaluable partner. One of his greatest strengths is his deep local knowledge; he helped us understand the nuances of various microclimates and guided us toward the cities that were the perfect fit for our specific needs and lifestyle. Jonathan was incredibly available and flexible, always making time to take us to see houses and answer our many questions, even on short notice. He was super responsive and transparent throughout the entire process, which gave us so much peace of mind. Thanks to his expertise and dedication, we were able to buy our dream home. If you are looking for an agent who is knowledgeable, communicative, truly invested in your goals (And with a great sense of humor!) , Jonathan is the person for you! If I could give him 5,000 stars out of 5, I would.

Jonathan Bruington
1 - 12 of 44
© 2026 RateMyAgent