Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
248 reviewsacross 42 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, dedicated, reliable, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
The day we closed on the sale of our house, I told Jessica, 'We are very grateful you are so good at
7 days ago
The day we closed on the sale of our house, I told Jessica, 'We are very grateful you are so good at

The day we closed on the sale of our house, I told Jessica, 'We are very grateful you are so good at your job!' We stand by this statement wholeheartedly! Jessica was especially creative with her marketing strategy and ensured that our home had several eyes on it, before it even went to market. This insured the right buyers saw our home early and we were under contract in four days--no small feat in this market! Jessica is also very communicative. throughout the process and has several great contacts in the industry to help get the job done. She is also exceptionally talented with the Erie real estate market. Throughout the process, we were treated like her friend and neighbor, not a client. Jess, you are in fact great at your job! You make selling homes in northern Colorado easy!

Jessica Luginbill
Buyer review
 Patient, responsive, knowledgeable, and a strong advocate every step of the way.
28 days ago
Patient, responsive, knowledgeable, and a strong advocate every step of the way.

We relocated to Colorado from out of state with little knowledge of the area. Jessica came highly recommended, and she was incredible throughout the entire process. She was patient, responsive, knowledgeable, and a strong advocate every step of the way. We couldn't be happier with our new home and highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling a home.

Jessica Luginbill
Seller review
Excellent: All The Things
about 1 month ago
Excellent: All The Things

Misti and her team are amazing!! A responsive, caring and fun team to work with. I am beyond grateful to have Misti in my corner when it comes to real estate and overall knowledge of the market and all things homes. I give her all the stars, all the referrals and all my repeat business (which hopefully is on pause for a bit). I could not recommend someone higher. Misti the THE BEST!

Misti Stewart
Seller review
A realtor who will work incredibly hard, think outside the box, pay attention to every detail
2 months ago
A realtor who will work incredibly hard, think outside the box, pay attention to every detail

Jessica Luginbill is, without a doubt, the best realtor you could ask for. Selling my home in an incredibly difficult market was an emotional roller coaster, and Jessica went so far above and beyond what I ever could have expected from a realtor. She worked tirelessly to get my home as much exposure as possible, including getting it into a broker tour so other agents could see the property firsthand. She helped to stage the house beautifully and thought of every detail, from signage and snacks to shoe covers for potential buyers. She made sure my home was presented in the absolute best possible way. When showing after showing came and went with no offers, even though the house was priced right and truly pristine, Jessica was the person who kept me grounded when I started to spiral. She was patient, reassuring, honest, and always in my corner. She never made me feel like I was being difficult or overly emotional; she simply reminded me to keep going and trust the process. Eventually, a contingent offer came in, and this is where Jessica really proved just how creative, resourceful, and dedicated she is. When my buyers weren’t able to sell their home before our contingency expiration, Jessica helped facilitate and navigate a very unique deal that ultimately allowed me to rent my buyers’ house. It was definitely not a straightforward transaction, but she found a way to make it work and helped navigate all of the moving pieces to get us to a successful outcome. I honestly don’t know how we would have pulled it off without her. If you are looking for a realtor who will work incredibly hard, think outside the box, pay attention to every detail, advocate for you, and truly care about getting you through the process, Jessica is your person. I cannot recommend her highly enough.

Jessica Luginbill
Seller review
We had an outstanding experience working with Jessica from Luginbill Homes start to finish
3 months ago
We had an outstanding experience working with Jessica from Luginbill Homes start to finish

We had an outstanding experience working with Jessica from Luginbill Homes start to finish. Jessica’s knowledge of the Erie market was truly impressive, and her expertise helped us feel confident throughout the entire selling process. Jessica’s marketing strategy makes her approach stand out. She always ensured every detail was handled professionally and effectively. What stood out most was how much Jessica genuinely cared about our family. She took the time to understand our needs, priorities, and long-term goals, making us feel more like family than just clients. If you're looking for a realtor in Erie or the Front Range who is dedicated, professional, and truly invested in your success, we cannot recommend Luginbill Homes highly enough. They exceeded every expectation and made the entire experience enjoyable. Five stars isn't enough!

Jessica Luginbill
Seller review
Jessica thoughtfully managed every detail with our best interests in mind.
3 months ago
Jessica thoughtfully managed every detail with our best interests in mind.

Jessica with Luginbill homes has always been responsive and incredibly knowledgeable about buying and selling homes in Erie and the Front Range and genuinely invested in helping our family achieve the best possible outcome. From the marketing plan and staging to the open houses, Jessica thoughtfully managed every detail with our best interests in mind. More than anything, Jessica and the team at Luginbill Homes made us feel valued and supported every step of the selling price

Jessica Luginbill
Seller review
When it comes time to choose a realtor, please, take my advice and partner with Jessica Luginbill.
3 months ago
When it comes time to choose a realtor, please, take my advice and partner with Jessica Luginbill.

Jessica does more than go the extra mile for you, she runs a marathon! A well-equipped and caring tactician with resources to back it up, Jessica made sure the bumps in the road didn’t derail me from reaching my goal. A wonderful partner with real adaptability and understanding of my unique situation helped me navigate through contractors, crazy timing, and multiple closings when it all felt way too much to handle. Jessica was referred to me by a friend, just as I’m referring her to you. That’s how this works, so what are you waiting for?

Jessica Luginbill
Seller review
Jessica was absolutely wonderful to work with
4 months ago
Jessica was absolutely wonderful to work with

Jessica was absolutely wonderful to work with. She invested so much time and energy into getting our home market-ready, and her pricing strategy was spot on. Jessica is dedicated, professional, and truly goes above and beyond for her clients. Thank you, Jessica, for making this such a success!

Jessica Luginbill
Seller review
Jessica and her team, kept us informed and on track through throughout Listing and Selling
4 months ago
Jessica and her team, kept us informed and on track through throughout Listing and Selling

Jessica was a great realtor to work with! She, and her team, kept us informed and on track through the entire sales process. She responded to any questions in a timely manner and was our go to expert for any issues we had. The house looked amazing after staging and that showed in the photos. Price point was perfect. Between price point and having the house look its best, it was a quick sale! We would definitely recommend Jessica if you need to sell your home!

Jessica Luginbill
Seller review
We couldn’t have asked for a better team to work with!
4 months ago
We couldn’t have asked for a better team to work with!

We decided to sell our house in Erie. The next step was finding a realtor. We had seen many ads, Facebook posts and emails from realtors in the area. We decided to start with Jessica Luginbill since she was the seller’s realtor when we bought the house 7 years ago. She came to our house to do a presentation and we were blown away with her knowledge of the market, ideas and plans to market and stage the house, and the prep work she would handle before putting the house on the market. She said she would have the house professionally staged, thoroughly cleaned, windows washed inside and out, and a professional photographer would prepare photos for a web page and marketing materials. We knew we didn’t have to look any further. We were splitting our time between Colorado and Arizona, so we moved back to Colorado to clear out the house. We spent 6 weeks packing a pod, giving stuff away, donating stuff and throwing stuff away. We finished our part on May 19 and moved back to Arizona, while Jessica and her team took over the staging, cleaning and marketing. The online photos and marketing materials were incredible. The house was listed on May 27, showings started May 28 and we received our first offer May 29. After negotiations, we accepted the offer and were under contract. Since we were out of state, we worked closely with Jessica on the inspection resolutions. She was on top of every inspection item and made sure things were handled, as she communicated with the buyers. The buyers wanted to close by June 18, making it a tight window to get the details handled. My wife and I were stressed about the schedule and inspection repairs, but Jessica made sure everything was done when it was supposed to be and that everybody stepped up to meet the timeline. We closed as planned. We couldn’t have asked for a better team to work with. We recommend Jessica and her team whole heartedly!

Jessica Luginbill
Seller review
Takin Dr - The Miller’s
7 months ago
Takin Dr - The Miller’s

When we told Misti we wanted to sell our home she provided all the tools to make the right decisions for the market. She had extensive knowledge of the neighborhood, where to price, and helped us stage the home to appeal to buyers while still living there. She celebrated every showing with us and had communication with those realtors on what the buyers were looking for. This helped us make any adjustments. When we got our offer she explained everything that was happening. What it meant for us and how to respond. Misti was our biggest advocate! With her we were able to sell our house at the right price!

Misti Stewart
1 - 12 of 248
Luginbill Homes at Compass Colorado
Contact Luginbill Homes at Compass Colorado
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent