Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
63 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Absolute professional.
over 5 years ago
Absolute professional.

Judy has represented our family in the purchase and sale of two homes (four transactions) over the past 24 years. She has excellent knowledge of the Eastern Shore market. Her attention to details and advice have resulted in our receiving even greater returns on our investments. Judy and her team are a pleasure to work with.

Judy Niemeyer

Judy Niemeyer

  5   (35 reviews)
Seller review
Judy Niemeyer is more than a real estate professional
over 6 years ago
Judy Niemeyer is more than a real estate professional

Judy Niemeyer is more than a real estate professional. She provides the guidance and understanding to assist with the selections we make during each chapter of our life. That compassion helps nurture the energy we all need to make the best decisions for our future. Her energy helped us with many residence choices over the years. The assistance never ends. She is there for any questions long after the close. David Reiley Dominic Trione

Judy Niemeyer

Judy Niemeyer

  5   (35 reviews)
Buyer review
Judy always made time for me and addressed any concerns I had quickly
over 6 years ago
Judy always made time for me and addressed any concerns I had quickly

Judy always made time for me and addressed any concerns I had quickly. She negotiated on my behalf and had my best interests in mind. The inspector found things wrong with the house, and Judy resolved them with the builder.

Judy Niemeyer

Judy Niemeyer

  5   (35 reviews)
Buyer review
Judy, Was a true delight to work with
over 6 years ago
Judy, Was a true delight to work with

Judy, Was a true delight to work with. She was extremely knowledgeable and professional. We lived in Colorado when we met Judy, December of 2019. We kept in touch and she was always sending homes to us via email. She took time to go and look as well. We bought the first week of March and closed April 13th. We love our new home. We will recommend Judy Neimeyer to family, friends and strangers.

Judy Niemeyer

Judy Niemeyer

  5   (35 reviews)
Buyer review
We can't say enough positive things about Colin
over 6 years ago
We can't say enough positive things about Colin

We can't say enough positive things about Colin. We were out of state buyers during COVID-19 which would typically add some extra stress, but Colin made the whole process a breeze! He's extremely knowledgeable, attentive, and a skilled negotiator. Most importantly, he truly has your best interest in mind.We'd recommend him over and over again!

Colin McBrearty

Colin McBrearty

  5   (10 reviews)
Buyer review
I would highly recommend Colin to anyone buying/selling our home
over 6 years ago
I would highly recommend Colin to anyone buying/selling our home

I would highly recommend Colin to anyone buying/selling our home.He was extremely knowledgeable and was in constant communication with us. He was out of the country for a wedding, and still fielded our calls and texts, and gave us updates on both the selling and buying front throughout.He helped us with all the negotiating and made closing a breeze. We were able to get over asking on our house, and he helped get us a great deal on our new house. Another great thing about Colin, is he's from Fairhope, and knows the area very well. Would use him again for any future real estate needs.

Colin McBrearty

Colin McBrearty

  5   (10 reviews)
Buyer review
We feel so fortunate to have found Judy, which we did by chance and on a whim
about 7 years ago
We feel so fortunate to have found Judy, which we did by chance and on a whim

We feel so fortunate to have found Judy, which we did by chance and on a whim. The moment we met her, we felt as though we were in great hands and never looked back. Judy helped us through our quick but rather unconventional move to the area and made the process enjoyable and as stress-free as one could hope for. While I hope we don't need to use a realtor anytime too soon, Judy will always be our first choice.

Judy Niemeyer

Judy Niemeyer

  5   (35 reviews)
Buyer review
Judy made every step of the buying our new home easy
about 7 years ago
Judy made every step of the buying our new home easy

Judy made every step of the buying our new home easy. She is very knowledgeable about the Fairhope area. Judy knew which house we would fall in love with before we even saw it!! She is able to do this because she listens to your wish list and then matches you to the perfect home.

Judy Niemeyer

Judy Niemeyer

  5   (35 reviews)
Buyer review
Staci helped us find a wonderful second home in Point Clear
about 7 years ago
Staci helped us find a wonderful second home in Point Clear

Staci helped us find a wonderful second home in Point Clear. We absolutely love the area and now have a wonderful home as well. Staci is extremely knowledgeable with the details of the properties she represents. We cannot thank her enough for making our experience so GRAND.

Staci Niemeyer

Staci Niemeyer

  5   (13 reviews)
Seller review
Colin sold our house and helped us with the purchase of the next home
over 7 years ago
Colin sold our house and helped us with the purchase of the next home

Colin sold our house and helped us with the purchase of the next home. Colin knows the market well. He convinced us to list higher than we thought we were going to, then had us an offer in 5 days at asking price. He was also always willing to take our wishes to the seller of our new home and did an excellent job negotiating the deal.

Colin McBrearty

Colin McBrearty

  5   (10 reviews)
Buyer review
Colin was a delight to work with -- warm, competent, and extremely responsive
over 7 years ago
Colin was a delight to work with -- warm, competent, and extremely responsive

Colin was a delight to work with -- warm, competent, and extremely responsive. I never had a question that he couldn't answer. He has so many local contacts, it seems he must know everyone in Baldwin County. I cannot say enough good things about Colin McBrearty!

Colin McBrearty

Colin McBrearty

  5   (10 reviews)
37 - 48 of 63
Ashurst Niemeyer Real Estate
Contact Ashurst Niemeyer Real Estate
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent