Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
31 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, clear communication, well-prepared, responsive, dedicated, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
The Realtor You Want on Your Side!
6 months ago
The Realtor You Want on Your Side!

Buying my first home at 36 years old is one of the biggest blessings and accomplishments of my life, and I am so thankful Amy was part of that journey. She stood by me through a long assumption process, answered every question, and never made me feel like I was bothering her. She genuinely cared about helping me find the right home and guiding me all the way to the closing table. When I finally got the keys, it felt like a dream come true. Thank you, Amy, for helping me start this beautiful new chapter and for helping make my dream of homeownership a reality! I will always be grateful. 🏡❤️ I highly recommend Amy to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She truly goes above and beyond for her clients.

Amy Stump

Amy Stump

  5   (3 reviews)
Seller review
Michelle is top notch and makes the selling process easy and seamless
6 months ago
Michelle is top notch and makes the selling process easy and seamless

This is the second home Michelle has sold for us and I cannot say enough good things about her. Both times she was thorough, a great communicator, hard working and never left us guessing about any details throughout the process. Her knowledge in real estate is unmatched! She cares about her clients and their needs are her number one priority. So thankful for all her hard work and efforts to get our house sold and closed quickly.

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Seller review
Her experience shows!
6 months ago
Her experience shows!

To start, Michelle was extremely patient and knowledgeable during the whole process. For every question that we had, she had an answer that you could tell was from years of industry experience. We had 50+ showings and 7 offers by the time the open house came around just three days later. We got significantly more money than we expected from our home sale. She also helped out financially on the house staging! I will never use another realtor again. 11/10!

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Seller review
Karen Scott is amazing
6 months ago
Karen Scott is amazing

Working with Karen Scott to both sell our previous house and buy our new one was an incredible experience. From start to finish, Karen went above and beyond. She was incredibly patient, listened to our needs, and put in the time and effort to help us locate our absolute dream home. If you want a realtor who is dedicated, attentive, and truly cares about her clients, look no further than Karen. We cannot recommend her highly enough and will definitely be using her for all of our real estate needs moving forward!

Karen Scott

Karen Scott

  5   (7 reviews)
Buyer review
Very professional and knowledgeable about the housing market!
6 months ago
Very professional and knowledgeable about the housing market!

She listened to what I was looking for in a house. Amy took me to beautiful areas of Pelham, Helena and beyond that she knew were safe and the houses were in the price range I was looking for. She was able to answer any questions I had or would find out the information within minutes. Very smart and professional!

Amy Stump

Amy Stump

  5   (3 reviews)
Buyer review
10/10 service!
6 months ago
10/10 service!

Karen was great throughout the whole process. Gave expert opinions on everything while touring. Was always available to to tour or answer any questions I may have. Extremely easy to work with. Couldn’t give a higher recommendation!

Karen Scott

Karen Scott

  5   (7 reviews)
Buyer review
Michelle is absolutely the best
10 months ago
Michelle is absolutely the best

Michelle is absolutely the best. A true professional. Her knowledge of the market in Liberty Park is just incredible. She gives great advice and we just overall had a wonderful experience working with her. She also has a name and number of an excellent person for any service you need.

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
She is not only a top professional but also a very nice person.
12 months ago
She is not only a top professional but also a very nice person.

I haven’t done a real estate transaction for 25 years and am quite unfamiliar with how it all happens today. Fortunately I found Michelle Creamer with ARC Realty. She is a wealth of information and willingly shares it. She walked me through the process of buying a new home and selling my old one. My anxiety is gone and replaced by calmness and confidence. Thank goodness for Michelle. She is not only a top professional but also a very nice person.

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Seller review
If you are selling or buying a home in the Birmingham area you need to hire Michelle
over 1 year ago
If you are selling or buying a home in the Birmingham area you need to hire Michelle

If you are selling or buying a home in the Birmingham area you need to hire Michelle. She knows her market and can confidently guide you through the entire process without leaving a penny on the table in profit. She is matter of fact and to the point and never overwhelmed us with useless information and she certainly didn’t wast anyone’s time which was greatly appreciated with our busy family. We LOVE Michelle and cannot say enough good things about her. Having sold several homes over the years, we have never had the level of experience she brings and we will be loyal clients for life.

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Seller review
Michelle was so wonderful to work with!
over 1 year ago
Michelle was so wonderful to work with!

Michelle was so wonderful to work with! She made selling and building our home such a seamless experience. We cannot recommend her enough!

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Michelle is a wonderful friend and realtor
over 1 year ago
Michelle is a wonderful friend and realtor

Michelle is a wonderful friend and realtor. She pays attention to every detail and makes you feel extremely special!

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
I was very pleased with how Michelle marketed my home - using a range of products and strategies \
over 1 year ago
I was very pleased with how Michelle marketed my home - using a range of products and strategies \

I was very pleased with how Michelle marketed my home - using a range of products and strategies that resulted in multiple offers quickly and a final contract over list price! She also worked diligently to help me find my new home and proved her in depth knowledge of my community time and time again.

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
13 - 24 of 31
ARC Realty | Liberty Park
Contact ARC Realty | Liberty Park
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent