Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
31 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, clear communication, well-prepared, responsive, dedicated, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Excellent support in a challenging market.
1 day ago
Excellent support in a challenging market.

Karen was so patient with us during the process of buying in a seller’s market. We had not purchased a home in a long time and were not familiar with the way offers and purchases were working. Karen explained the process and worked in several failed offers before we got “the one.”

Karen Scott

Karen Scott

  5   (7 reviews)
Buyer review
Michelle Creamer is professional and personable, and I highly recommend her for all your realty.
4 days ago
Michelle Creamer is professional and personable, and I highly recommend her for all your realty.

Our experience with Michelle Creamer as our realtor was outstanding. She answered our questions thoroughly; she presented multiple options and answered our questions in a timely manner. She is A+ at returning calls. Further, she communicates professionally and personably. She is also vey competent in her field. She knows houses, construction, remodeling, and handy work. We have been in our house in Cotswold for about a month and are happy. She also made closing a painless experience. I would wholeheartedly recommend her for anyone looking for a home in the Birmingham metro area. I would use her again. She is a five star realtor from the beginning of the process until closing.

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Michelle is a consummate professional with deep experience in the Liberty Park market.
6 days ago
Michelle is a consummate professional with deep experience in the Liberty Park market.

Michelle guided us through the sale of our home and the purchase of another. This was a downsize move, and were very relieved we did not have to worry about having an erratic agent on top of the other stresses accompanying such a move! She is an excellent communicator, and a delight to be around. We would never consider engaging another agent should we ever move again…she’s that good. We also would not hesitate to recommend her to anyone else considering moving to another home. Thank you Michelle, we are so grateful you were our agent!

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
I live 4 plus hours away from the Birmingham area.  Michele guided me through thr purchase
about 2 months ago
I live 4 plus hours away from the Birmingham area. Michele guided me through thr purchase

Michelle Creamer truly went above and beyond for me throughout my home search. She personally visited every property I was interested in—and many others she felt I should consider—because I lived more than four hours away and work full-time. I simply didn’t have the luxury of jumping in the car and driving across town every time a property came on the market. When I finally found the home I wanted, Michelle went to the negotiating table armed with knowledge, experience, and determination. She negotiated a deal that exceeded anything I could have hoped for. Michelle is exceptionally well-versed in real estate and is an outstanding negotiator. Most importantly, she always has her client’s best interests at heart. She will tell you honestly when it’s time to walk away and when it’s worth stepping up and making the deal happen. This weekend, Michelle and her team helped me complete the purchase of a home I had never even set foot in. And when I finally walked through the door, I was completely enchanted. Was it my perfect home? No—and I never expected it to be. But I got exactly what I wanted, and I am incredibly happy with my new home. I truly could not have done this without Michelle and her team. Their dedication, expertise, honesty, and willingness to go the extra mile made all the difference. I am incredibly grateful for everything they did to make this experience possible.

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Seller review
Wonderful Realtor!
4 months ago
Wonderful Realtor!

We have worked with Karen to buy and sell! When we were buyers, she was patient with us, knowledgeable, and worked hard to get us what we wanted. When we were sellers, she presented our home in the best way and we were able to get a fair offer rather quickly. She is an amazing realtor but more importantly, an amazing person!!

Karen Scott

Karen Scott

  5   (7 reviews)
Buyer review
Go-getter that fights for your best interest!
4 months ago
Go-getter that fights for your best interest!

Working with my realtor was an outstanding experience from start to finish. She was respectfully aggressive when it came to advocating for my best interests, making sure every opportunity was pursued while remaining professional and considerate throughout the process. She was always responsive, answered my questions quickly, and kept me informed every step of the way. Her politeness, patience, and attention to detail made what could have been a stressful experience feel much more manageable. One of her greatest strengths is her strong connection to the community. Her local knowledge and network were invaluable and gave me confidence that I was making informed decisions. I highly recommend her to anyone looking for a dedicated, knowledgeable, and trustworthy realtor.

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Bulldog negotiator with extensive knowledge of the current market and how to leverage it
4 months ago
Bulldog negotiator with extensive knowledge of the current market and how to leverage it

Michelle came highly recommended with the exact phrasing 'she's a bulldog' and she lived up to that billing. She was extremely knowledgeable of the areas, comps, and advocating for us as buyers during the negotiation. She has an extensive network of trusted contacts we could pull from for the various services we needed both prior to closing as well as post closing. When the time comes we will have her sell what we just purchased. We're grateful for all of her help and recommend her to all!

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Michelle was very knowledgeable and easy to work with.
5 months ago
Michelle was very knowledgeable and easy to work with.

Michelle responded quickly to our questions and stayed in touch with us every step of the way on the purchase of our home. To me, it was very important to have an agent who listened to what type home we wanted. She went above and beyond to help us find the right one. We couldn't be happier with our home and the choice of our agent, Michelle Creamer.

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Seller review
Liberty Park expert!
5 months ago
Liberty Park expert!

Michelle is "in the know" in Liberty Park! I contacted her to market my home and she was able to bring me great buyers with an outstanding offer. All without going to market - which is what I preferred! Simple, direct and straight-forward. Michelle is a long time resident and engaged in our community which makes her the expert! She's our unofficial mayor! ;)

Michelle Creamer

Michelle Creamer

  5   (21 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent!
5 months ago
Excellent!

Karen was so helpful to us in her knowledge of the market and quality of homes in the Vestavia Hills market. She guided us professionally through showing to closing. I highly recommend Karen.

Karen Scott

Karen Scott

  5   (7 reviews)
1 - 12 of 31
ARC Realty | Liberty Park
Contact ARC Realty | Liberty Park
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent