25 South Street

Geneseo NY 14454

3164 sq. ft.

13000 sq. ft.

Duplex

Last sold for $260,000

Carla Rosati, last sold this property on 14 October 2026 after 447 days on market.

Overview

25 South Street, Geneseo, NY | 2-Family | 9 BR | 3 BA | ~3,200 SF Exceptional rent-stable investment in the heart of the Village of Geneseo. This nearly 3,200 SF 2-family Victorian delivers strong gross rents of $38,700/yr with low operating expenses - and a location that keeps quality tenants. The Investment Case: With both units currently occupied by responsible, neat-and-tidy tenants who handle their own utilities and have in-unit laundry - this property runs well. Separate entrances, dedicated porch areas, and ample off-street parking add to the tenant appeal that makes this asset so easy to manage and hold. The Location: Walking distance to SUNY Geneseo - one of the SUNY system's premier colleges - means consistent, reliable rental demand in a market that rarely softens. The Village itself offers a charming, walkable streetscape of shops, dining, and community amenities that attract quality long-term tenants well beyond the student population. For commuters, the I-390 corridor is minutes away, providing straightforward access to Rochester, URMC/Strong Memorial Hospital, and the region's major employment centers. Weekend recreation is equally accessible - Letchworth State Park, the "Grand Canyon of the East," and the shores of Conesus Lake are both just a short drive away. The Property: A classic two-story Victorian with strong curb appeal, the home features a welcoming covered front porch, mature trees, and generous off-street parking. The 4 BR / 2 BA lower unit and 5 BR / 1 BA upper unit offer the bedroom depth that today's rental market demands - ideal for student households, professionals, or even multi-generational living. Whether you're building your portfolio or adding a turnkey asset, 25 South Street is the kind of well-located, income-producing property that is simply a good choice. 1st showings MON 6/22 *NO delayed negotiations*

Features

9 bedrooms

3 bathrooms

1 carspace

1 garage space

3164 sq. ft. floor area

13000 sq. ft. lot size

Duplex

Estimated Value

We need at least 3 similar 9 bedroom duplexes sold in Geneseo over the last 12 months.

Property history for 25 South Street

2026

Sold

$260,000

14 Oct 2026 by Carla Rosati, of RE/MAX Realty Group

Happy sellers in Geneseo

We have insufficient information to provide an overview of customer satisfaction for Geneseo. Viewing the agent profiles, reviews and sales for Geneseo can provide insights for this location.