RateMyAgentGo to search
Back 204 Myrtle Ave
Off Market

204 Myrtle Ave

Port Jefferson NY 11777

4
2
2
2854 sq. ft.
10890 sq. ft.
Single-Family
Last sold for $925,000
Eric PeskinEric Peskin, last sold this property on 02 April 2026 after 1169 days on market.

Overview

Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a distinguished piece of Port Jefferson history. Originally built in 1890 for renowned sea captain Llewellyn Tuthill, this exceptional residence has been thoughtfully maintained and tastefully updated while honoring the craftsmanship and architectural character of its era. Set back and elevated above the roadway, the home commands attention with its stately presence and inviting wraparound porch. Inside, timeless period details abound, including soaring 10-foot ceilings, original custom woodwork, wide-plank flooring, antique push-button switches, decorative hardware, and beautifully restored cast-iron radiators. Stunning original pocket doors gracefully separate the living room from the entrance hallway, adding both architectural elegance and functional design rarely found today. Modern improvements blend seamlessly with the historic charm and include radiant heated flooring in the bathroom, a finished attic offering flexible bonus space, a newer roof, rebuilt chimneys, and a refinished fireplace. Ideally situated in the Historic Village of Port Jefferson, just moments from the harbor, village shops, dining, and amenities, and located within the highly regarded Port Jefferson School District—this is a truly special offering where history, character, and lifestyle come together.

Features

4 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
2 carspaces
2 garage spaces
2854 sq. ft. floor area
10890 sq. ft. lot size
Single-Family

Estimated Value

Based on this property and similar 4 bedroom single-family properties sold in Port Jefferson over the last 12 months, the estimated median property value of 204 Myrtle Ave is $842.5k.

Median value
$842.5k
Estimated value range
$510k - $2.5m
Median days on market
41
Estimated value trend
12%
increase over the last 12 months
Average days on market is based on recent, comparable sales in Port Jefferson. It is only an indication of the time a property is actively listed and should not be relied upon as an accurate representation of how soon a property will be sold.

Property history for 204 Myrtle Ave

2026
Sold
$925,000
02 Apr 2026 by Eric Peskin, of Signature Premier Properties
2021
Sold
$590,000
09 Jul 2021 by Jolie Powell, of Jolie Powell Realty Inc
2017
Sold
$554,000
22 Nov 2017 by Jolie Powell, of Jolie Powell Realty Inc

Happy sellers in Port Jefferson

~%

We have insufficient information to provide an overview of customer satisfaction for Port Jefferson. Viewing the agent profiles, reviews and sales for Port Jefferson can provide insights for this location.

Local market activity for 4 bedroom single-family properties in Port Jefferson

In the last 12 months, 35 four-bedroom single-family properties similar to 204 Myrtle Ave, have been sold.

This represents a 9% decrease in four-bedroom single-family properties sales when compared to the previous 12 months.

Nearby agents

Compare and contact these top performing agents who’ve delivered exception customer service for their clients in Port Jefferson

placeholder
Maria Palmar

Maria Palmar is a recommended agent for Port Jefferson.  They have 2 local sales and collected 2 local reviews across the last 12 months.

  •   5   (14 reviews)
  •  2 Reviews in Port Jefferson
  •  2 Sales in Port Jefferson
View profile
placeholder
Melissa Martins

Melissa Martins is a recommended agent for Port Jefferson.  They have 1 local sale and collected 1 local review across the last 12 months.

  •   5   (2 reviews)
  •  1 Review in Port Jefferson
  •  1 Sale in Port Jefferson
View profile
placeholder
Julie Poidomani

Julie Poidomani is an award winning recommended agent for Port Jefferson.  They have 1 local sale and collected 1 local review across the last 12 months.

  •   5   (38 reviews)
  •  1 Review in Port Jefferson
  •  1 Sale in Port Jefferson
View profile
placeholder
Kristen Toffales

Kristen Toffales is a recommended agent for Port Jefferson.  They have 3 local sales across the last 12 months.

  •  3 Sales in Port Jefferson
View profile
or
Skip the list and find your ideal agent to sell your propertyFind My Agent
RateMyAgent
Sales:
(619) 566-0008
Quick Links
© 2026 RateMyAgent
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsLicensingSitemap