127 Myrtle Avenue

West Cape May NJ 08204

5606 sq. ft.

Single-Family

Last sold for $3,700,000

Edward Mahaney Jr, last sold this property on 12 January 2026 after -252 days on market.

Overview

This remarkable property, once a cherished inn, is now a stunning full-home vacation rental hosting guests year-round. Originally built by Dr. Albert G. Stevens as his personal residence and medical office, the home has now been thoughtfully updated to meet today's standards while preserving its rich historical character. Boasting 12 bedrooms and 11.5 bathrooms, the layout includes 3 bedrooms on the first floor, 8 on the second floor, and a spacious suite on the third floor accessible by its own private outdoor staircase and a common interior staircase. Around every corner, you will find something to admire--from the multiple fireplaces (both gas and electric) to the charming, enclosed side porch, and the intricate architectural details that reflect true Queen Anne design. Step into the expansive backyard to find a luxurious inground heated pool with a jacuzzi tub and sun shelf--perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The outdoor deck and patio area provides an ideal setting for gatherings with family and friends. Situated on a 0.41-acre lot, the property includes rare off-street parking for 10+ vehicles, and a yard spacious enough for a barbecue or even a game of croquet. Enjoy peaceful views of Wilbraham Park from the covered front porch or unwind on the shady rear porch overlooking the sparkling pool. Ideally located just two and a half blocks from the Washington Street Mall and five short blocks from the ocean beaches, this estate offers easy access to everything Cape May has to offer--including a scenic bike ride to Sunset Beach which is home to the most breathtaking sunsets on the East Coast. Don't miss your chance to own one of Cape May's most iconic and beloved homes--The Albert Stevens Inn at 127 Myrtle Avenue. This is truly a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

Features

12 bedrooms

11 bathrooms

5606 sq. ft. floor area

Single-Family

Estimated Value

We need at least 3 similar 12 bedroom single-family properties sold in West Cape May over the last 12 months.

Property history for 127 Myrtle Avenue

2026

Sold

$3,700,000

12 Jan 2026 by Edward Mahaney Jr, of Coastline Realty, LLC

Happy sellers in West Cape May

97%

97% of sellers in West Cape May reported that their sale price either exceeded or met their price expectations.

West Cape May stands out for consistently delivering exceptional satisfaction and strong market results for homeowners.

This is based on voluntary sentiment collected from 6 reviews in West Cape May over the last 12 months.

Local market activity for 12 bedroom single-family properties in West Cape May

Sold

For Sale

Interested in selling?

People are reaching out to these agents in West Cape May for a market analysis.

CAROL MENZ

at Coastline Realty, LLC

(144 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Brian Giancola

at REMAX Surfside | Cape May

(7 reviews)

Get a market analysis

Frank Punzi

(1 review)

Get a market analysis

Dagmer Chew

at HOMESTEAD REAL ESTATE COMPANY INC.

Get a market analysis

Nearby agents

Compare and contact these top performing agents who’ve delivered exception customer service for their clients in West Cape May

CAROL MENZ

Sellers who recommend CAROL MENZ have praised them for being local expert, responsive, clear communication, reliable, supportive, great negotiation, and dedicated