From 75 reviews overall

Justine Dennis McPhee
Keller Williams Elite - Lancaster

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 17602
23 Bradford Street Millersville
Thanks to Justine, I am officially a first-time homeowner! She was phenomenal through every step of the process, with incredible attention to detail and constant support. She was patient, kind, trustworthy, and always willing to teach me along the way so I truly understood everything involved. I have known Justine for over 10 years, and this was actually our second home search together — her patience never wavered. She always made me feel supported and informed. At closing, she even provided an organized binder with all of my documents, which perfectly reflects how thoughtful and prepared she is. Justine has a great network and has connected me with great industry contacts and resources whenever I needed them. She truly has a resource or contact for everything. I could not have asked for a better experience and would highly recommend her to anyone, especially first-time homebuyers.
131 Milton Cir Lancaster County
Justine was fantastic to work with. As first time home buyers, she walked us through each step of the process. She has a fine eye for detail and during showings, she was able to point out potential problems or identify where changes could be made without much stress. Communication was excellent, and Justine was responsive to our questions. Most importantly, Justine listened to us and was able to help us identify exactly were our priorities lay. We are thrilled our friends recommended Justine to us, and we will enthusiastically recommend our friends to Justine as well.
104 E Harrisburg Ave Rheems
Goes above and beyond!! Justine and her team are the BEST! She is professional, kind, always kept us updated, and truly went above and beyond to get our home sold during a very difficult time for us. I will forever be grateful for all the help Justine and her team has given, and highly recommend you choose her as your realtor!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Lancaster County2026From 1 review overall

Sherill Johnson
BHHS Homesale Realty-Lancaster
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 17602
515 Hand Ave Lancaster
I worked with Sherill Johnson to purchase a home in Lancaster, PA and had a great experience. Sherill was easy to communicate with, quick to respond, and very flexible with scheduling showings. She is patient and friendly, and never made us feel rushed or pressured. I also felt confident that she was looking out for our interests and advocating for us at every step. I would gladly work with Sherill again and recommend her to anyone buying in the area.
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 17602
524 Sherbrook Drive Eagleview
We planned to interview a few realtors before listing our home, and Dave was the first person we met with. We didn’t know much about him, but we were so impressed with his knowledge and expertise that we signed with him on the spot. Dave showed our house 2 days later and we had a fabulous offer the following day. He was with us every step of the way, supporting us through personal health problems, and even assisting us during the move. We would highly recommend Dave to anyone looking for a realtor.
1209 New Hampshire Lane Downingtown
As you may know, the market was competitive from 2022 to 2025 and finding the right agent is essential to get the perfect house for us. As we looked at each house, Dave was able to provide advice on the pros and cons of the property including what it might cost to repair. He has a great network and was able to get experts in their respective fields to provide further advice when it was needed. When it came to this property, he was able to coordinate with the seller agent to get us through to getting our offer being accepted, so thank you so much! Closing was the smoothest thing we had experienced as first time home buyers and it is all thanks to Dave and his team. Will definitely be reaching out in the future for my housing needs.
From 5 reviews overall

Gerry Gwinn
Iron Valley Real Estate of Lancaster
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 17602
215 Steepbank Road Lancaster
Gerry Gwinn was an excellent realtor for us on the sale of our townhouse. Gerry had earned our trust in the past few years when she helped us purchase this house 2 1/2 years ago and providing updates on properties that might please us on our next move. We would recommend Gerry to anyone wishing to sell. Her advice and help with staging gave our townhouse a fresh, modern look. She has a good eye for design which paid off in a quick offer on our home even during the busy holiday season. Gerry was responsive to our questions and needs and conscientious in her work with us.