Middle Island

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

Real Estate & Property for Sale in Middle Island

Showing 1996 - 2016 of 2946 properties

Sort by

Show more detail >

SoldOct 24, 2025

$705,000

8 Heather Court

Middle Island NY 11953

3

3

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of HomeSmart Dynamic Realty and Realty Connect USA LI

Show more detail >

SoldOct 24, 2025

$730,000

229 Southaven Avenue

Medford NY 11763

4

3

10

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Pine Barrens Realty LLC and Coldwell Banker Reliable R E

Nicholas Accardi

Show more detail >

For Sale

$888,888

Medford NY 11738

4

4

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Hartford Homes & Estates

Natalie Affenita

Show more detail >

For Sale

$910,000

35 Evergreen Ave

4

3

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Show more detail >

SoldOct 23, 2025

$615,000

Selden NY 11784

3

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate and Signature Premier Properties

Show more detail >

SoldOct 23, 2025

$725,000

4

3

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker American Homes

Show more detail >

SoldOct 23, 2025

$740,000

3

3

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty and Gateway to The Hamptons R E

SoldOct 23, 2025

$418,000

51 Blue Ridge Drive

Medford NY 11763

2

2

Condo

Listing courtesy of Century 21 KR Realty and Signature Premier Properties

Show more detail >

SoldOct 23, 2025

$420,000

120 Lookout Drive

Sound Beach NY 11789

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Aliano Real Estate and Re/Max Integrity Leaders

Marie Breslin

Show more detail >

SoldOct 23, 2025

$380,000

84 Walnut Street

2

1

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of O Kane Realty

Donna Memoli Varland

Show more detail >

SoldOct 23, 2025

$540,000

5 Charles Street

Selden NY 11784

4

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Show more detail >

SoldOct 23, 2025

$550,000

131 Curtis Drive

Sound Beach NY 11789

3

2

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Signature Premier Properties and Marylou Swan Realty Corp

Show more detail >

SoldOct 23, 2025

$626,000

4

2

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Exit Home Key Realty and Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Show more detail >

SoldOct 23, 2025

$545,000

37 Wyandotte Street

Selden NY 11784

3

1

8

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Signature Premier Properties and Davis Real Estate Group LLC

Leonard Saburro

Show more detail >

For Sale

$749,369

East Shoreham NY 11792

3

3

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Elite Residential Brokerage

Frank Gargano

Show more detail >

Pending

$659,000

96 Magnolia Drive

Rocky Point NY 11778

3

3

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Covenant Realty Group LLC

Nicholas Sekela

Show more detail >

For Sale

$479,000

18 Central Parkway

Gordon Heights NY 11763

4

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Oasis Realty Group LLC

Martin Hammer

Show more detail >

For Sale

$949,998

Lot B Merritts Path

Rocky Point NY 11778

3

2

2

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of H & G Realty New York

Show more detail >

SoldOct 22, 2025

$850,000

East Shoreham NY 11786

4

3

1

Single-Family

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Show more detail >

SoldOct 22, 2025

$280,000

135 Eastbourne Ct

2

1

Condo

Listing courtesy of Century 21 American Homes

Show more detail >

SoldOct 22, 2025

$390,000

1012 Skyline Drive

3

3

Condo

Listing courtesy of CHARLES RUTENBERG REALTY INC and Douglas Elliman Real Estate

1996 - 2016 of 2,946

Suburbs in Middle Island

View nearby Cities

Sales:: (619) 566-0008

Quick Links

© 2026 RateMyAgent

Terms & Conditions