
Valerie Morris
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here


Katelyn McCarthy
Licensed Real Estate Agent
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 63 Lyndon Road, Fayetteville
Katelyn is a wonderful Realtor overall, I wouldn't hesitate going forward, but if you still have doubt, read along! 1. INTEGRITY - Katelyn prioritized my wife's and my interests above anything else and worked non-stop to accommodate our needs over money or the hopes of a sale. 2. EXPERIENCE - Katelyn was very obviously the most experienced agent in our entire sale, often taking the time to help the buying side as well with guidance. 3. COMMUNICATION SKILLS - Never feel short or delayed communication, never left feeling like we were yearning for a response. Extremely attentive and thorough! 4. MARKET KNOWLEDGE - Knew our market up and down, was spot on every step of the way. 5. NEGOTIATION SKILLS - Got us the best offer possible. Even with some buyer shenanigans attempted right near the finish line Katleyn stayed on our side and strong. 6. AVAILABILITY - Katelyn went above an beyond. Was always available whenever we had random questions along the way and with multiple feet of snow arriving right before the viewings / open house was all over it to help out and make sure the house was accessible. Thank you Katelyn for all of your help, if we find our way back in the area you will surely have forever clients!
Seller of 1754 North George Street, Rome
Whether you’re buying or selling, Katelyn provides a premium level of service. I’ve worked with her twice now and can speak to her trustworthiness, knowledge, and skill in her craft. She stays on top of everything, communicates clearly, and makes sure things actually get done.
Nicki Donlin
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 203 Elmbrook Dr, Manlius
Nicki was excellent to work with because of her readiness, “roll up your sleeves” attitude, and communication skills. I hired Nicki to handle the sale of my moms house and from the beginning stages of listing to the closing, her communication was seamless and professional. I always felt like I was in the loop and knew the next steps of the selling process. It was a joy to work with Nicki and I would highly recommend her.


Tom Tarry
Principal Broker | Owner
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 7410 Rice Road, Cayuga County
Things with Tom started out very well. We had a contract within 8 days. After some fixes we were on track. In the end, things didn't run so smoothly. Due to a lack of communication, the "final walk through" never had a firm time of taking place between both sides. No exact time was conveyed to be out of the house which caused the buyers lawyer/realtor being involved and making demands straight through me! I expected Tom to be the buffer between us but that was no communication on both sides. Additionally, the realtor for the buyers said to my face that she was the lawyer and I was to be out ASAP! I had never met the woman previously. Finally, due to scheduling and weather issues, the new roofing job has not been completed as of yet. The other lawyer is withholding $10,000 from the sale even though I have paid the contract for the job in full. Is that even legal? My experience of owning a home in NY was great until the end. I won't be back. v/r Robert Bannister
State Top 10
New York2026County Winner
Onondaga County2026County Top 5
Oneida County2026