Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 08753
1512 Burr Oak Road Toms River
I was very hesitant to list my house with just any random realtor but John came very highly recommended by another friend that used him and boy was I happy that I listened to her!!! From start to finish John made sure that every step and transaction went so smooth! If any problems or issues that came up he was right on top of it coming up with a solution! He was so knowledgeable about the area and the community, he was available day and night to answer any questions that I had and would always respond right away! If you in the market to sell your home John is 100% your guy!!!! Thank you for making this hard decision such an easy choice!!
From 40 reviews overall
Matthew Sirchio

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 08753
98 Seabreeze Ave North Middletown
I had a very positive experience working with Matt Sirchio. He was proactive, responsive, and consistently well-prepared throughout the process. Matt communicated clearly, answered questions promptly, and made sure everything stayed on track. I especially valued his honesty and straightforward advice. He was focused on my best interests and set clear expectations at every step. I would confidently recommend Matt Sirchio to anyone looking for a reliable and trustworthy real estate agent.
4 Runyon Road Monmouth County
Matt was very knowledgeable, professional and quick to provide updates on our buying process. He has a great network of business and personal relationships, especially in the Middletown area that helped us make a decision on the right neighborhood and home for our family. I would highly recommend using Matt for any of your real estate needs whether buying or selling.
27 Southview Terrace South Monmouth County
As first-time homebuyers, we were naturally nervous about navigating today’s market, but Matt made the entire process incredibly easy. He was patient, took the time to explain every document, and toured dozens of homes with us without ever making us feel pressured to make a decision. The real magic happened when we finally found 'the one.' Just as we were preparing an offer, the house went off the market. We tried looking at other properties, but nothing compared. Matt went above and beyond by hand-delivering a personal letter to the owners to express our genuine interest. Thanks to his persistence and outside-the-box thinking, he managed to get us the house! Throughout the closing, Matt ensured everything went smoothly and we felt completely supported and advocated for from start to finish. He also helped connect us with all the right local contacts from inspectors, home insurance, lending, roofing, alarm systems and more to make sure we got top notch service for all areas of the process. If you want an agent who will truly go the extra mile for you, we cannot recommend Matt highly enough!
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Monmouth County2026From 0 reviews overall

Jennifer Seitz
Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 08753
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here
From 0 reviews overall
Jeanette Schlapfer
Crossroads Realty - Berkeley
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 08753
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here