
Donna Membrino
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Jay Contessa
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 158 Old Redding Rd, Fairfield County
Jay goes above and beyond to help his buyers and sellers. He has represented us for both types of transactions as well as temporary housing and we have been extremely satisfied with his level of knowledge, service, and professionalism. We highly recommend Jay for anyone looking to buy, sell, or rent. Real estate transactions involve so many moving parts and Jay keeps track of everything seamlessly and makes sure his clients are always informed as to progress that is being made and what the next steps are. He is an exceptional problem solver and works extremely hard to negotiate so both sides of the purchase or sale come to acceptable terms. His professional network and ties to the community have resulted in many excellent recommendations, be it for service providers, contractors, or other professionals related to the real estate transaction. We cannot say enough good things about working with Jay Contessa and have had complete confidence in him representing us for our real estate undertakings.

Mary Worstell
Broker
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 1625 Overhill Street, Yorktown Heights
Working with Mary on the sale of our late father's estate in Yorktown was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. From our very first meeting, Mary stood out for her clear, open, and easy communication style. She kept us updated at every turn, answered all our questions promptly, and made sure we always felt completely confident in the decisions being made. The thought of selling our childhood home became overwhelming, but Mary’s calm professionalism, local market knowledge, and proactive approach made the entire process surprisingly stress-free. She held our hand through every step right up until closing. If you are looking for an agent who genuinely listens and works tirelessly to deliver top-tier results for her clients, I cannot recommend Mary highly enough!
Buyer of 6 Silvestri Place, Marlboro
From the very start of our house hunting experience, my husband and I were blown away by Mary's expertise, honesty, professionalism, and patience. She has not only looked out for our best interests throughout the entire home buying process, but has been an incredible communicator, negotiator, and trustworthy person. We are incredibly grateful for the amount of time and energy Mary took in making sure that we found the perfect home for our growing family. Mary always made herself available for spur of the moment decisions to check out homes and continuous conversations about our concerns and questions. We are thankful to have had such a wonderful realtor (and now friend) to help us secure our first home!!
County Winner
Putnam County2026City Winner
Carmel Hamlet2026Cynthia Szentkuti
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here