Toni Stacy

Toni Stacy

Licensed Real Estate Agent at Paradise Exclusive | Real Estate
  •   5   (4 reviews)

About Toni

Meet Toni Stacy, a highly-rated Licensed Real Estate Agent with a perfect review score of 5.0 from her clients. Serving the vibrant communities of Punta Gorda, Florida, as well as Harbour Heights and Port Charlotte, Toni is dedicated to helping clients buy and sell properties with ease and efficiency. With an average of just 31 days on the market, Toni ensures that her listings receive the attention they deserve and sell quickly. In the past year alone, she has expertly managed the sale of properties totaling over $1.25 million. While she specializes in single-family homes, Toni's expertise also extends to land, making her a versatile choice for a variety of real estate needs. A trusted name in the local real estate market, Toni Stacy leverages her in-depth knowledge of the area to provide insightful and personalized service. Whether you're a first-time home buyer, looking to expand your investment portfolio, or planning to sell, Toni is dedicated to guiding you through the real estate process with professionalism and care. Choosing Toni means partnering with an agent who is not only passionate about real estate but also genuinely invested in the community she serves. Experience the difference by working with Toni Stacy for all your real estate endeavors in Florida.

Toni's reviews

  5  
Toni has 4 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 4.
Review Toni
5 months ago
Thorough and prompt follow up.

Responsive and quick follow up with answers to buyer questions. Does additional queries to answer questions in depth. Example: Home we bought was listed as having sewer system by seller when in fact the system is a pressure effluent system (special system) that connects into city sewer system. Toni provided additional information regarding how this system operates. Toni is good communicator with other agents. Toni able to quickly assess a buyers needs & wishes and provided property information tailored to buyer desires. Toni very calm & patient in assisting buyer to locate property suitable to buyer. She was always accessible to view properties at buyer request. We were privileged & honored to have Toni represent us as a buying agent. This is our second time to have Toni represent us as a buyers agent. She represented and assisted us in purchasing a home in 2021 and also in 2026. We have always felt she is very ethical and honest with every part of the real estate transaction. Respectfully submitted, Jame’s and Sandra Allmyer

about 4 years ago
Knew what we were looking for and was very patient with us.

Very knowledgeable for the area we wanted. Pointed out things we didn’t notice, (ie busy roads, younger neighborhoods (we are retired so that mattered). Pulled reports on everything we were considering so we knew what we were getting into. Would highly recommend her to friends and family.

about 4 years ago
Outstanding experience with regards to the sale of our property in Deep Creek.

We happened to find Toni Stacy on the next-door app. In Deep Creek. Toni replied to our inquiry in a timely manner and gave us the confidence to allow her to list our property. We found her to be dedicated, professional, soft-spoken and displayed a very hands-on approach with regards to her marketing style. Toni kept us informed through every step of the process and responded to our questions and concerns promptly. The property was sold for above asking price and we closed smoothly in a timely manner. Thank you Toni Stacy for your outstanding service and going forward, we would highly recommend you. Ken & Marie B.

about 4 years ago
Florida bound......

I had a wonderful expierence working with Toni from the get go ! She was most supportive in my move from Pennsylvania to Punta Gorda. Toni helped me stay in my budget and target location.. She was also most helpful with recommendations on insurance companies, painters..... I look forward to her friendship as well once I actually relocate ! I highly recommend anyone relocating to reach out to Toni Stacy

Toni's properties

Toni has 5 properties for sale and sold 3 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$364,777
1921 East Isles Road
Port Charlotte FL 33953
3
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of PARADISE EXCLUSIVE INC
SoldFeb 27, 2026
$90,000
101 Wren Drive
Charlotte County FL 33946
Land
Listing courtesy of MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY and PARADISE EXCLUSIVE INC
SoldFeb 27, 2026
$710,000
99 Wren Drive
Charlotte County FL 33946
4
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY and PARADISE EXCLUSIVE INC
SoldDec 15, 2025
$52,900
2276 Mauritania Road
Harbour Heights FL 33983
Land
Listing courtesy of MARINA PARK REALTY LLC and ADNORAM REALTY
Show all 8 properties
Email
© 2026 RateMyAgent