Toni's profile

Toni's reviews

  5  
Toni has 8 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 8.
Map view
Toni's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, friendly, clear communication, reliable.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Exceptional!
almost 4 years ago
Exceptional!

Toni’s buyer centric and strategic approach helped us to define our priorities and price range. Over seven months, Toni tirelessly sent us (hundreds) of well curated listings, took us on virtual tours, and joined us for multiple private in-person showings. Her follow-through and commitment to our satisfaction is unprecedented. She is well-experienced, intelligent, and trustworthy!

Buyer review
Professional ,energetic and friendly Realtor
over 4 years ago
Professional ,energetic and friendly Realtor

Toni has been outstanding not just helping us purchase the home seamlessly fair price but also honesty navigated every steps. She also represented the seller very well to from showing properties to close of the deal. Highly recommend to buyers or sellers.

Seller review
My experience was very seamless with Toni
over 4 years ago
My experience was very seamless with Toni

Toni , was an absolute joy to work with during a stressful time in my families lives. She was always available to answer questions and had a very extensive knowledge of all the ins and outs of the market in Florida. She went above and beyond helping us to complete the sale of my fathers house.

Seller review
Friendly and very professional
over 4 years ago
Friendly and very professional

Fast efficient service both before 1st offer and after accepting right on thru closing. Repeated necessary emails got us thru the sale almost effortlessly. She really shine as an agent. If we had more property, she would be handling it.

Buyer review
Boston to Bradenton
over 4 years ago
Boston to Bradenton

Me and my wife decided to search for a home in the Sarasota/Bradenton area and chose Toni Carrico as our agent. We live in Massachusetts and were concerned about the market and being able to look at homes remotely. We first met Toni in person while we were on vacation in Sarasota and she showed us 3 or 4 properties while we were on vacation and quickly became familiar with what our need/wants were and things that were deal breakers with us. She sent us updated lists that met our criteria while we were back in Massachusetts and when we found a property we wanted to see, Toni would set up a virtual showing literally the next day because homes were receiving multiple offers on the first day on the market in most cases. She must have showed us 10-15 properties and based on her knowledge of our likes/dislikes she would tell us wether she thought we would like the area/neighborhood/property and she was always spot on!!! Toni put together 3 offers before we finally had an offer accepted. Toni took care of everything and went above and beyond in our eyes which made the whole process much less stressful for us. I highly recommend Toni and wouldn't use anyone else should we decide to purchase or sell another property in the Sarasota/Bradenton area!!!

Seller review
Toni Carrico is top-notch!
about 5 years ago
Toni Carrico is top-notch!

I have the deepest respect for Toni Carrico. She went above and beyond what is normally expected of a realtor. I had to leave Florida and completely depend on her to deal with landscapers, contractors, and more. She took care of all minute details thoroughly and professionally. She always kept me up to date. I highly recommend her to anyone who needs to list their property in the Sarasota area.

Buyer review
Toni is an outstanding person and broker
over 5 years ago
Toni is an outstanding person and broker

Toni is an outstanding person and broker. Toni's gift is certainly serving her clients. Communication and negotiating skill are over the top. We started out as Toni being the broker and now I would consider her a very dear friend. Not only during the purchase but after the sale she is there to help. I certainly could not find a better person to recommend to anyone looking at selling or buying.

Seller review
Toni did a wonderful job helping us sell our mobile home
over 5 years ago
Toni did a wonderful job helping us sell our mobile home

Toni did a wonderful job helping us sell our mobile home. Very professional. She worked helping us as well as the buyer to successfully finalize the sale satisfactorily for both parties. If you are selling a mobile home in Sarasota, do yourself a favor, hire Toni.

1 - 8 of 8
© 2026 RateMyAgent