Tiffany and Jason Carey | The Trusted Team's profile

Tiffany and Jason Carey | The Trusted Team's reviews

  5  
Tiffany and Jason Carey | The Trusted Team has 186 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Tiffany and Jason Carey | The Trusted Team's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, reliable, empathetic, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Made first-time home buying experience much smoother
7 days ago
Made first-time home buying experience much smoother

We were first time home buyers and Tiffany was amazing through the entire process. Her wealth of knowledge was key. She focused on educating us in a way that helped us ultimately feel good about the decisions we made. Tiffany was very communicative. She was quick to respond, even if it was just acknowledging she got our message. Definitely would recommend working with Tiffany!!!

Seller review
Great Communication!
12 days ago
Great Communication!

Tiffany was very thorough in her communication and documentation, and she provided a realistic analysis of a less than ideal market. We couldn't be more pleased with the outcome.

Buyer review
Excellent experience!
26 days ago
Excellent experience!

Tiffany made selling and buying an easy and enjoyable experience! She stuck with me while I looked for the perfect place & helped me avoid some lemons. Now I have a wonderful new home that fits me and my family just right at a great price. :)

Buyer review
Best first time home buyer experience ever
about 1 month ago
Best first time home buyer experience ever

From the moment we got in contact with Jason to begin our house hunt, we felt like we found a realtor who didn't just want to quickly sell a house, but one who wanted to help us find a dream home. Jason taught us very quickly how to be thoughtful house hunters, focusing not just on the short term goal of getting a house but also looking into the future of possible changes and repairs each house would need. Having this education made my husband and I much more thoughtful and aware with each house we visited. I appreciated how prompt Jason's communication was with us. We were able to set up house visits easily. I also appreciate Jason's transparency and honesty with each house we looked at (ex: highlighting the good parts of the house as well as the obstacles that could make owning the house difficult). His honesty and candor made us put our whole trust in his expertise, and we are so grateful that we got to work with him. We would highly recommend Jason to anyone in the Rochester area that is in the market to buy or sell their house. We will most definitely be keeping in contact with him for our future housing needs.

Buyer review
I love these guys
2 months ago
I love these guys

I've moved dozens of time so have used, sometimes just endured, lots of realtors, so I have a good perspective here. Jason (and Tiffany behind) the scenes have been exemplary, extremely competent, personable, attendant to my concerns (accepting idiosyncracies in my wishes with only judicious expressions of caution), generous with their time. When I thought, for example, i couldn't get a mattress delivered soon, Jason offed to lend me an air mattress. When I got to the house there was a care package of the dozen or so things you need but forget the first day, a huge cookie saying 'Welcome Home Andy,' and an equally sized pizza. They know the town and who in it can help with things. Jason worked well with an unusually finicky inspector, not defensive, always focused on my needs. It's like having an old friend or a brother helping you make difficult decisions, making you feel welcome, critiquing choices and wishes tactfully and helpfully. And all this, from a practiced curmudgeonly octogenarian who's galactically hard to please in any area at all.

Buyer review
Not enough space to capture all the amazing things about working alongside the Carey team!
3 months ago
Not enough space to capture all the amazing things about working alongside the Carey team!

We cannot say enough good things about the Carey team. Over the years, we have sold three homes and purchased two others with their help, and every transaction has exceeded our expectations. Jason has been our primary contact, but we have also had the pleasure of working with Tiffany, Cherrie, and other members of the team. Everyone we have worked with has been professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely committed to helping us make good decisions. What sets the Carey team apart is their combination of honesty, integrity, and genuine care. They are incredibly easy to talk to, but they also tell you what you need to hear—not simply what you want to hear. They don’t exaggerate the value of your home or try to convince you that you have something you don’t. Their advice is thoughtful and focused on what is best for their clients. They are well connected throughout the community. Their relationships with realtors, bankers, property managers, contractors, and skilled tradespeople have been invaluable to us. It is clear they have put in the work to understand what it means to be a quality realtor and build a team capable of serving people well. We deeply appreciate that they love the Lord and genuinely care about the community they serve. Their generosity and willingness to support others are evident in how they do business. Because of our experience, we have referred the Carey team to numerous friends and acquaintances and will continue to do so. For our family, there is no question: when someone asks who we recommend for buying or selling a home, the Carey team is the only team we will recommend. After five successful transactions, we would choose them again without hesitation. There simply isn’t enough space to capture all the incredible things that make this team so special. We are extremely grateful for how they have served our family and wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone buying or selling a home.

Buyer review
Amazing First Time Home Buyer Experience
3 months ago
Amazing First Time Home Buyer Experience

Tiffany did a fantastic job taking us through the home buying process, especially as first time homebuyers! She made sure we understood each step in the process before moving onto the next and answered every question we had. I would recommend Tiffany to anyone and everyone looking to buy a home!

Seller review
We appreciated the help Tiffany gave us in order to prep our home for sale.
3 months ago
We appreciated the help Tiffany gave us in order to prep our home for sale.

W decided to move back in June to be closer with our family. Tiffany knew we were wanting to sell quickly and with her help we were able to sell the house within three weeks. We chose Tiffany because or neighbor used her and she came highly recommended by them. We really appreciated the Tiffanys advice along with the advice from the stager to help us identify what the buyers were looking for in order to prep our house. Tiffany and her team were outstanding!!! If you are looking to sell I highly recommend you contact REMAX and get in contact with Tiffany and her team you will not be disappointed!

Seller review
Experienced and extremely knowledgeable professional that we would recommend to anyone.
4 months ago
Experienced and extremely knowledgeable professional that we would recommend to anyone.

Tiffany has excellent market knowledge and negotiation skills. She made the process of buying and later listing our home seamless. She communicates thoroughly and always keeps us updated with next steps. Very professional and great to work with and had numerous helpful local recommendations for home improvement projects/service. We wish she would move to Texas to be our realtor again in the future!

Buyer review
A top notch Realtor!
4 months ago
A top notch Realtor!

My fiancé and I sincerely appreciate the time and effort Jason has dedicated to assisting us. He clearly recognizes that each client is a valuable investment and is genuinely committed to helping clients succeed and achieve their goals. Such dedication is increasingly rare these days. Our initial experience with Jason was when we sold our home. He went above and beyond to help us price the property correctly and effectively negotiate with other real estate agents. Later, when we decided to purchase a new home, we chose to work with Jason again. We shared our interest in potentially building a house, but were unsure if it was feasible given current market conditions. Jason was able to connect us with Bigelow, who was able to fulfill our needs. It has been a genuine pleasure working with Jason and his team. They made the transition into our new home as smooth and stress-free as possible, consistently providing guidance and support throughout the process. I highly recommend Jason and his team to anyone looking to buy, sell, or simply seeking a reliable realtor!

Seller review
Return Customers!
4 months ago
Return Customers!

Jason absolutely paved the way to a successful home sale last year for us. This year we went looking to build our custom home, and Jason connected us with every contact and resource we needed to make our build successful. Assistance with builder selection, operating within budgetary constraints, good fiscal stewardship of our financial target while still ensuring we got the quality you need in a lasting home. I would recommend Jason to every discerning home buyer, as a representative and helper to building, and definitely in helping you sell your home for a price you're comfortable with. I'm glad I get to write this second review, I'd write ten more (but I'm not going into the real estate trading business, sorry Jason!)

Seller review
Excellent and Professional Realtor
4 months ago
Excellent and Professional Realtor

Tiffany is an excellent realtor. When I needed to sell my home, she quickly guided me through the necessary repairs and paperwork. She also provided excellent advice on pricing the home for the market and handled negotiations very effectively. I truly appreciated her professionalism, expertise, and prompt support throughout the entire process.

1 - 12 of 186
Tiffany and Jason Carey | The Trusted Team
Contact Tiffany and Jason Carey | The Trusted Team
What information would you like?
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent