Susie's profile

Susie's reviews

  5  
Susie has 119 reviewsacross 19 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Susie's qualities as told by our client reviews: stress-free process, patient, honest, supportive, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
great exerience
over 4 years ago
great exerience

Susie helped make the brutal experience of selling and moving go as well as possible. always there to help with questions.

Buyer review
The Barth's New Home
over 4 years ago
The Barth's New Home

Susie is hands down one of our favorite people on this planet! She is a dear friend of the family and a phenomenal real estate agent. Last year, my husband and I updated our old house in Arvada and we were on the hunt for a bigger house for our new family. We were also trying to plan our wedding during this process and Susie made it so easy for us to find the perfect home! She took the time to listen to our wants and needs and narrowed the search down to 10 houses. My husband drives a big truck and she made it a priority to ensure the houses we were looking at had a garage large enough to fit his truck. I'm not sure how Susie did it, but we were able to lock in our new house at asking price in 2021, not a penny over, which is almost impossible to do in the market! We are so thankful and blessed to know Susie and we love our new home!

Buyer review
Knowledgable and accessible
over 4 years ago
Knowledgable and accessible

Susie was great to work with. She was VERY prompt at answering emails and calls, knew the area, the local market , and closing details that other agents were not aware of. She gave solid accurate advice during the entire process.

Seller review
Queen of Anthem
over 4 years ago
Queen of Anthem

I was so fortunate to meet Susie. She really has a lock on the homes in Anthem and knows what is doing on. Very responsive, returned texts, emails, calls within minutes. Being able to sell my home that I owned for only 3 months at $130,000 profit says it all.

Seller review
Fantastic realtor
over 4 years ago
Fantastic realtor

We had a perfect experience working with Susie. She guided us with expert advice from the very first steps until closing day. She and her team kept us updated through the entire process. They made selling our house really effortless for us! Thank you

Seller review
The best of the best!
over 4 years ago
The best of the best!

Always responsive, knowledgeable, honest, caring, and always with the best interest of her client in mind. You can trust her on all levels to deliver a sale or a purchase of a home.

Buyer review
Buying in Anthem Ranch
almost 5 years ago
Buying in Anthem Ranch

From the first time I contacted Susie, I always felt that she was there to help; from showing us potential homes, to answering my never ending questions. She always kept me updated on potential houses. Since our closing, Susie has given me numerous references for different work we needed to have done. What a great help for someone new to the area. I would recommend her to anyone either buying or selling. She really knows Anthem Ranch!

Seller review
Susie Smyle sold our house.
almost 5 years ago
Susie Smyle sold our house.

Our expectations of our house sale were far above what was anticipated thanks to Susie. She is a true expert in the field of real estate. Susie explained everything about the process and left no question unanswered. She responded to all inquiries immediately. Susie surely went the extra mile in providing assistance in other related areas. Her shining personality coupled with her knowledge and professionalism truly make her one of best real estate agents. We highly recommend Susie to everyone. We are so fortunate to have chosen her for our house sale.

Buyer review
Home purchase in Anthem Ranch
almost 5 years ago
Home purchase in Anthem Ranch

We purchased our new home in Anthem Ranch in June at the height of a seller's market. Trying to negotiate an active market from 1,000 miles away proved difficult, fortunately for us we found Susie. Not only does she understand the product, she has incredible connections which allowed us to purchase our home without having to do battle with multiple potential buyers. Our transaction was incredibly smooth, my wife and I hold Susie in high esteem and would not hesitate to recommend her to any serious buyer.

Buyer review
Susie was both the selling agent of my old house and the agent on the new house
almost 5 years ago
Susie was both the selling agent of my old house and the agent on the new house

Initially I was hesitant to have Susie in both roles, I thought there would be a possible conflict of interest. However, several neighbors who knew Susie said, "She'll always have your best interests at heart" and she did. Plus, it turned out to be an advantage because she was great as a go-between in scheduling the closing, rent backs, move-in dates, etc. She is very well regarded in Anthem Ranch and is tremendously responsive-returning calls, texts and emails in minutes. her energy level is tremendous and I think it is because she genuinely loves what she does!

Seller review
Susie is Excellen
almost 5 years ago
Susie is Excellen

Susie knew the neighborhood and the crazy market. We priced a little on the higher side and still got way above asking price in 48 hours. She was very efficient in her listing and marketing materials. Her assistant, Van, was also a valuable tool in helping us setup closings, etc.

Seller review
Review of realtor Susie Smyle selling our home
almost 5 years ago
Review of realtor Susie Smyle selling our home

We previously knew of Susie's reputation as she is often involved in our community's (Anthem Ranch) activities and has represented both buyers and sellers in many past transactions. From her initial comparative properties presentation until the final closing, Susie was always professional and consistently "positive" even after the first two buying opportunities fell through. She maintained contact with us throughout. She is well networked in the field and she knows what's involved working with other realtors, appraisers, title staff, and she can recommend contracting and moving help should either be needed. She even helped us sell or donate belongings we no longer wanted. Finally, we sold our property for much more than we anticipated, in part, thanks to her knowledge of the changing market conditions in our area.

97 - 108 of 119
© 2026 RateMyAgent