Susan's profile

Susan's reviews

  5  
Susan has 19 reviewsacross 2 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Susan's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, clear communication, friendly, proactive, hard-working, local expert, attentive.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Our realtor, Susie Wykoff, was  friendly, professional and thorough
about 5 years ago
Our realtor, Susie Wykoff, was friendly, professional and thorough

Our realtor, Susie Wykoff, was friendly, professional and thorough. She knew what I needed and did a phenomenal job of making the sale happen to my best advantage and dealing with the personal family dynamic occurring at the same time with patience and kindness. If I ever need a realtor in the future I will certainly look for her assistance!

Buyer review
My wife and I want to thank you for your hard work, persistence, and advice
over 5 years ago
My wife and I want to thank you for your hard work, persistence, and advice

My wife and I want to thank you for your hard work, persistence, and advice. You probably have the most positive attitude of any person I've ever met.You guided us to a lovely home after showing us at least 20 houses, making at least 5 offers on different houses, and 3 inspections.We closed today!! We thank you so much for all that you did for us!

Seller review
Wonderful couldn't ask for better.
over 5 years ago
Wonderful couldn't ask for better.

Wonderful experience. Both agents went above and beyond . Beautiful ladies inside and out.

Seller review
Good Morning from Taft St
over 5 years ago
Good Morning from Taft St

Good Morning from Taft St. Let's review. 4 years ago I bought this lovely cottage in Chesterton so I could live near my adorable new grandson. I wasn't ready to sell my dream home south of the river in Lawrence County so I rented it to two of my favorite people. My tenant has gotten a great job in Louisville and will be able to give his young family a better life. Since I live HERE, and my life is HERE, I decided to sell that place in Southern Indiana. It sold in 5 days and now I only own one house and have my feet firmly planted here, 5 miles from Lake Michigan and my grand babies. Thank you to so many people for making this transition happen, but top of the list is my Lawrence County realtor, Susan Reuter Wykoff of Williams Carpenter Realtors, Bedford, IN. She helped me find and buy it, and now she helped me sell it. Godspeed and best of luck and thanks to Patrick and Andy Gould, for loving that house as much as I did and keeping it safe and beautiful. I'm so excited about your new life and opportunities. One of the best things about this summer project was that I got to stay with my dear gardening friend Gail Woodruff while I worked on and arranged things on the house. I loved our garden tours, our long talks and all the delicious meals you fixed for me. Best. Thank you Rick Butterfield for stepping in and fixing all the little stuff. More than once. Did you know ant colonies can fry a GFI? Try Borax. Thank you to my neighbors Buddy Hendricks and Bryan and Shari Garrett Perkins for helping with our projects. I certainly miss being close neighbors with you. Oh yeah, and thanks last but certainly most to my family, Allyson Baughman , Brandt Baughman and my sweetie pie son Ben Jackson for months of listening, weed pulling and mulching. We did it. Ok that's it, now I need to go paint stuff. See these pix? This is the only house I own and I live here. Ha ha ha.

Seller review
Susan has sold me 2 homes in the past 10 years
almost 11 years ago
Susan has sold me 2 homes in the past 10 years

Susan has sold me 2 homes in the past 10 years. She is always prompt, answers any questions that you have. She currently has a home for sale for me and keeps me informed on what is going on with it. I appreciate all the help she has given me

13 - 19 of 19
© 2026 RateMyAgent