Susan Toohey

Susan Toohey

Broker / Owner / Principal Broker at Toohey Realty LLC
  •   5   (32 reviews)

Susan's sales performance at a glance

See how Susan has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

11
Reviews
0
Properties for sale
9
Sold properties
$312k
Average sale price
$2.8m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • top20badge
  • trustedbadge
  • aotybadge
  • top20badge

    Recognized for being in the Top 20% for customer satisfaction.

  • trustedbadge

    Asks all customers for reviews whether positive or negative which may result in a more representative star rating.

  • aotybadge

    Recognized for going above & beyond for their clients.

Susan's customer service award

See the RateMyAgent award Susan has won

  • County Top 5Dakota County

About Susan

I'm proud to be your personal Realtor for Minnesota & Western Wisconsin. I'll help you beginning to close in your purchase or sale. After that I'm available for any future things you may ever need in the Real Estate industry. I've been in the business 10 years and have a solid referral and repeat customer base. After working with me you become family.

Social profiles

Susan's reviews

  5  
Susan has 32 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 6.
Review Susan
Buyer review
Caring and supportive even when it felt hopeless!
about 4 hours ago
Caring and supportive even when it felt hopeless!

Finding a new home is INSANELY hard! Especially in this economy and with high expectations of what we wanted as first time homeowners, we searched alot on our own but having a realtor who knows the area, knows the schools, and knows how to search for above and beyond locations is exactly what Susie did for us! She gave us her expert help when it came to selecting the right FIRST home for us and for our growing family! She helped us with our small children when it came time to tour without a sitter, and she even offered to help transport us when we were down to one vehicle! She absolutely cares about you, and your choice. She'll look at as many places as you'd like, and she'll make sure you don't jump into a house just because you're excited, she'll break down your decision and talk to you like a person - not a number or figure on paper. It was beyond the best experience we could have had for buying our first home together, this is after working with three other realtors over 2 years and having "little to no luck" finding what we wanted, could afford and in the area we wanted - Susie gave us all that!

Buyer review
Treated Us Like Family!
1 day ago
Treated Us Like Family!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ An Exceptional Realtor, An Even More Exceptional Person! Where do we even begin with Susan Toohey? From the very beginning of our house-hunting journey, Susan was so much more than our realtor. She treated us like family, and that is something we will never forget. Susan never gave us anything less than 100% of her time, dedication, and effort. Whether we had questions, needed reassurance, or faced unexpected challenges, she was always just a phone call or text away. Her professionalism was second to none, yet she carried herself with such genuine warmth and kindness that we never felt like just another client. What could have been a stressful experience became something truly fun, exciting, and memorable because of her. Every home we toured felt like another adventure, and Susan made sure we felt comfortable, informed, and confident every step of the way. Her knowledge is remarkable. She answered every question we threw her way, often going above and beyond to share things we hadn't even thought to ask. She's a natural problem solver whose patience, determination, and reassuring confidence made us feel safe and completely at ease in her care. But what truly sets Susan apart isn't just her expertise or incredible work ethic. It's who she is as a person. She's a genuinely beautiful soul who truly cares about the people she helps. We've worked with other realtors before, but never anyone quite like Susan. She is truly lightning in a bottle in the world of real estate — that rare combination of exceptional professionalism, unwavering dedication, genuine compassion, and a heart of gold. Finding a house is one thing, but finding someone who makes you feel supported, valued, and cared for throughout the journey of finding a home is something entirely different. We didn't just find an incredible realtor. We found an incredible human being. Thank you, Susan, for everything. You made this chapter of our lives one we will always remember! ❤️

Buyer review
A realtor and a friend all wrapped up in one!
28 days ago
A realtor and a friend all wrapped up in one!

Susie has been working with me since the fall of 2023 to find my very first home. She has been nothing but patient and kind throughout the process. She was always understanding of my hesitations and need for extra time in making the decision. Needless to say when my boyfriend came into the search he too appreciated Susie’s kindness and adaptability to our situation. Susie remains professional while also making you feel comfortable with telling her your likes/dislikes, worries/excitement and we truly have become friends through this process. She is always responsive and has clear communication, she helped us negotiate even small things when we got into the nitty gritty of the process, and she never made us feel pressured or rushed. I can’t say enough good things about Susie as a realtor for a first time home buyer (or any buyer) and as a person!

Seller review
Tirelessly Working to Sell Our House
2 months ago
Tirelessly Working to Sell Our House

Susie did a wonderful job helping us to get our house ready to sell! She was with us every step of the way, and often went above and beyond to help us. I would highly recommend working with Susie for all of your buying and selling needs!

Buyer review
So responsive and flexible
2 months ago
So responsive and flexible

I work a difficult schedule, and Susie was so flexible, and also never complained about a 3 am text when something came to mind while I was working. As a first time homebuyer, Susie made the experience as smooth as possible, and was extremely helpful in walking me through every step of the way, even after closing.

Seller review
Personable and knowledgeable!
2 months ago
Personable and knowledgeable!

Susie is a gem! She has become like family through the house selling process and we are grateful for her dedication to her craft. She worked very hard to get us a good deal that supported our needs as well as the buyer's. We intend to work with Susie on future homebuying and selling adventures!

Show all 32 reviews
map

Susan's properties

Susan has sold 9 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldNov 12, 2026
$151,900
102/500 North Etna Street
St. Paul MN 55106
1
1
1
Other
Listing courtesy of Toohey Realty LLC and Coldwell Banker Realty
SoldSep 21, 2026
$293,000
49 Belvidere Street East
St. Paul MN 55107
2
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Real Broker, LLC and Toohey Realty LLC
SoldSep 14, 2026
$289,000
845 Highview Loop Southeast
Pine City MN 55063
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REMAX Advantage Plus | Blaine and Toohey Realty LLC
SoldSep 4, 2026
$259,570
517 Sidney Street East
St. Paul MN 55107
3
1
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Toohey Realty LLC and Hamm Real Estate Company
Show all 9 properties

Susan's sold properties

Susan has sold 9 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
102/500 North Etna Street, St. Paul, MN, 55106
102/500 North Etna Street
St. Paul MN 55106
1
1
1
Other$151,900Nov 12, 2026
49 Belvidere Street East, St. Paul, MN, 55107
49 Belvidere Street East
St. Paul MN 55107
2
2
1
Single-Family$293,000Sep 21, 2026
845 Highview Loop Southeast, Pine City, MN, 55063
845 Highview Loop Southeast
Pine City MN 55063
3
2
2
Single-Family$289,000Sep 14, 2026
517 Sidney Street East, St. Paul, MN, 55107
517 Sidney Street East
St. Paul MN 55107
3
1
1
Single-Family$259,570Sep 4, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent