Susan's profile

Susan's reviews

  4.9  
Susan has 16 reviewsacross 9 different locations, showing 12.
7 months ago
Excellent Realtor Experience

With the purchase of my first home, Susan took the time to step me through all areas of the buying process. She went above and beyond to provide comparisons for me and to give me valuable insight into the buying process. It was a pleasure to work with her!

7 months ago
Wonderful experience!

Susan was super easy to work with and offered up ideas which helped sell my home for more than I had originally thought.

7 months ago
Great Experience

Susan was a professional and well knowledge about the property we were looking at.

over 1 year ago
Home Purchase in Somerset Kentucky

Susan is the person that found the home that we purchased. We drove to Sumerset and she arranged for my wife and I to tour all of the homes we wanted to see. She prearranged everything with the listing agents and we probably toured 6 or 7 homes that day. We settled on the last one we toured and Susan was very involved with the purchase and closing processes between the lender and the title company. One huge benefit that Susan provided was her ability to communicate with the listing realtor and her own network to provide us with recommendations for contractors to make the needed repairs to the house. We were able to start the renovations needed within 3 weeks of closing and the contractors that were recommended were very reliable. She also provided us with the names and phone numbers of all the utility companies to get everything transferred over to our accounts. In short, Susan not only provided excellent customer service up to the closing of the property, she also continued to provide much needed support, post closing, to make sure that we could move into our new home ASAP. If anyone is looking to purchase real estate in central kentucky my wife and I HIGHLY recommend the service provided by Susan Tegtmeier.

over 1 year ago
Fabulous experience!

Susan Tegtmeier was absolutely great, and we highly recommend her! She was thorough, communicative, very prompt, and full of useful information. If she hadn't suggested viewing the home we chose, we would have missed out on a fabulous opportunity. Thank you, Susan!

over 1 year ago
Susan was top notch in all aspects of real estate sales

Susan showed her market knowledge, communication skills and professionalism in handling a very difficult sale. We were selling my parents home and both are in their 90’s. She was very patient with them in explaining everything she was doing and making the sale as easy on them as possible. Susan went beyond our expectations of what a real estate agent could do for us. Susan was able to get a quick sale and got us a price above our expectations. Would highly recommend her anyone wanting a professional and knowledgeable real estate agent. She was great !

over 1 year ago
Experienced, Professional, and with a Personal Touch!

Susan is a must have when it comes to real-estate. She is Knowledgeable, and Professional and helped guide me through what could have been a painful beauractic process with ease. Most of all Susan Tegtmeier has a Heart of Gold and Truly wants the best for her Clients. I gained more than a Realtor, I found a new friend and Kindred Spirit with this amazing woman. Highly Recommend!!!

almost 2 years ago
Goes Above and Beyond!!!

We are SO incredibly grateful to have had Susan on our team during this process. Susan was not only extremely knowledgable and friendly, but very resourceful for all sorts of projects! She truly is an advocate for you and went above and beyond to ensure we received all the assistance we needed (she even took care of our 2 dogs when we needed someone during the showing/walkthroughs). We loved just how involved she wanted to be every step of the way and her passion really really shows. It was evident right away we made the best choice with Susan as she made us feel like her absolute top priority and a VIP. Susan will forever be more than an agent for us but a life long friend. Thank you again Susan (and Andy)!!! The Malloys

almost 2 years ago
Enthusiastic and Hardworking

We are so happy that we chose to work with Susan to sell our home. She was enthusiastic about selling our home and was always available if we had concerns throughout the process. She offered her help with quite literally every part of the selling experience, including watching our dogs during a showing. I recommend Susan to anyone looking to sell their home!

almost 2 years ago
Client Centered Superstar

Susan goes above and beyond to make sure you stay informed every step of the way. She's very thorough and asks the right questions to ensure the best possible experience. She was my selling agent and for several reasons it was an unusual and complicated property to sell and she worked with me every step of the way to understand where we were and what needed to happen. There were many steps that would have been time consuming for me to do, and she stepped in and took care of them to get us to the soonest possible closing date. Can't recommend her enough!

about 2 years ago
Great Communication and Very Helpful

I am a new buyer and had lots of questions. Susan has helped me every step of the way answering my questions and looking out for my best interest!

over 2 years ago
Outstanding service

Susan went out of her way to find a house that met our multiple needs. She really represented us well as we were out-of-state for much of the search process. Working with Susan was a very positive experience.

1 - 12 of 16
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent