Susan Geitner

Susan Geitner

Broker Associate / REALTOR® at ADVANTAGE REALTY 1
BK: 03050844
  •   4.9   (20 reviews)

About Susan

Susan is experienced in full-time residential sales since 2003. She obtained her NAR e-PRO Designation in 2004, Broker's license in January of 2005, Certified Short Sale Professional in 2009 and Pricing Strategy Advisor certification in 2019. After some time commuting to the Orlando market, Susan has returned to the Heartland of Florida where she has lived since 1999.

Susan's reviews

  4.9  
Susan has 20 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 6.
Review Susan
about 4 years ago
Friendly, Knowledgeable and Great for Relocation

Great experience! My husband and I decided to move from Massachusetts to Lake Placid, FL in late December. Thanks to Susan Geitner, we were happily settled in our awesome new home by the first week of February. She handled everything for us remotely, giving us home tours via FaceTime and connecting us with local experts from home inspectors to a title attorney. We did a remote signing and she even did our final walk-through and collected the keys for us! She is warm, professional, and very proactive. If you’re looking for a home anywhere between Sebring and Kissimmee, Susan Geitner at Advantage Realty 1 is the right realtor to work with.

about 4 years ago
Professional,responsible,positive experience!

I recently had the opportunity of having Susan Geitner of Advantage Realty! advocate for me in the sale of my house. During this stressful time and emotional time, she remained professional and proactive , assisting me through process. She was quick to answer calls,or return calls in a timely manner.Susan even engaged in providing extra help in the tense final moments of vacating my home. For all of that I thank her much and give an all star rating❤️

over 4 years ago
Phenomenal experience with her adapting to my needs and schedule.

Went to susan to see a few properties i had found online, she took me inside allbof them with very short notice, making me a priority immediately. After viewing multiple properties she said she had an idea of whqt i truly wanted and brought me to the one i ended up loving and buying. Susan admittedly had never dealt with the VA loan before but by my experience you couldnt tell. She handled everything for me quickly and professionally and worked around my rotating schedule. Any real estate needs in highlands County, i would go to her first.

over 4 years ago
Susan Geitner

We have used Susan for selling two pieces of property she was very helpful and h we also used her to help us buy property in highlands county she is very professional with a lot of restate knowledge she made it easy for us

over 4 years ago
Excellent Customer Service

Ms. Susan Geitner was very professional and knowledgeable about selling the vacant land to me. The transaction was done on a timely manner. She followed through and I was very pleased with the service I received from her. I will recommend her to other prospective buyers.

Show all 20 reviews

Susan's properties

Susan has 45 properties for sale and sold 5 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 4, 2026
$15,900
1807 North Nantucket Road
Avon Park FL 33825
Land
Listing courtesy of ADVANTAGE REALTY 1
SoldMar 31, 2026
$440,000
1552 Sun Pure Road
Avon Park FL 33825
Land
Listing courtesy of ADVANTAGE REALTY 1
For Sale
$336,000
9107 Rengarts Place
Sebring FL 33870
Land
Listing courtesy of ADVANTAGE REALTY 1
For Sale
$675,900
537 State Road 70 West
Lake Placid FL 33852
Land
Listing courtesy of ADVANTAGE REALTY 1
Show all 50 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent