Stacy Stahl

Stacy was incredible from the start. We wanted someone who represented a fellow islander to represent us not a major corporation. Stacy made us feel comfortable and confident in our goals. We sold due to losing our parents and this added a very difficult dimension to the process which Stacy handled so well. She was always empathetic and supportive first, an agent second. Although the proper sale was the priority it was clear she was focused on our wellbeing as much as achieving the sale goal we had set. The market demanded a bit longer process than expected but Stacy handled it professionally and wonderfully. We felt supportive, heard and understood. I wholeheartedly recommend Stacy.

Stacy is a second generation real estate professional who understands Key West. In my experience it is critical to use an agent who truly understands the island as it is a unique market. She has provided us expert assistance buying and selling properties in Key West. I highly recommend using Stacy and her expertise in buying and/or selling.

Stacy is well known as being excellent throughout the real estate community in Key West and she has terrific relationships with everyone. When anyone asked who our agent was, we always heard “oh, you’re in great hands” as the first response. That’s reassuring when you’re looking at a very expensive investment. And Stacy not only knows her stuff, owns her business and gives tons of guidance, she also takes time to teach others how to do real estate well. I’ve been to this rodeo quite a bit and was educated and picky. My husband is just as meticulous in the process. Stacy saved us a ton of time figuring out what we wanted and finding properties that were contenders. And we have leaned AE is bad, but X marks the spot for my Safety Pup tendencies. Stacy has become a great friend and looking forward to spending more time with her (and she will definitely be handling any real estate transactions for us regardless)!

We had the pleasure of working with Stacy, and she was absolutely amazing. As out-of -state sellers, we were worried about managing everything from afar, but Stacy made the entire process seamless and stress-free. From start to finish, she was incredibly professional, responsive, and attentive to all of our needs. Her expertise and dedication made the transaction feel easy even though we were not there in person. We highly recommend Stacy to anyone looking for a reliable and dedicated realtor!

My wife and I have had the pleasure of working with Stacy for 2 purchases. Stacy has years of experience and an abundance of knowledge about the Key West market. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for residential or commercial properties. Stacy checks all the boxes.

I've worked with many Realtors over the years and Stacy is one of the best! She was on top of things at all times. A very good communicator, very responsive... a real professional. When issues popped up, as they always do in transactions, she was on it with resolution. The whole transaction went smoothly from contract negotiations to closing. I highly recommend her.