Shelly's profile

Shelly's reviews

  4.9  
Shelly has 38 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, friendly, supportive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great Realtor
over 2 years ago
Great Realtor

Shelly Booth was recommended to me by my financial advisor. She was a great person to work with. She went beyond the scope of a real estate agent. She was a helpful advisor on how to get my house ready for listing and was there to handle all the details of selling my house. She kept in contact with me about everything from the open houses to the feedback about potential buyers. I would highly recommend Shelly Booth as a friendly, knowledgeable, reputable realtor.

Seller review
Excellent Realtor - attentive to our needs and terrific results
about 3 years ago
Excellent Realtor - attentive to our needs and terrific results

Shelly was a wonderful agent and was tremendous help to our family during our sale and our cross country move. She helped us through the who process - this included setting the right price for the house, marketing it (including photos, videos, etc.), negotiation to ensure we got a fair offer, and details on the closing. She even went outside of the normal area for a realtor and helped us find a reasonable cross country mover when we were struggling to find one in our target budget. She would listen and help us with any questions that we had. Both Shelly and the buyer's agent helped us through a issue with an appraiser who had missed some details and features in our home and they worked together to ensure that there were no issues as a result of that appraiser. Shelly always took time to listen to us and understand our needs and what we were looking for with our sale (i.e. ideal timing of the sale, price, our schedules, etc.) and would help us through any debates or questions that we had. Just as important as her counsel and assistance were the end results; Shelly helped us to sell in 3 days at near asking price. The price that we sold at was higher than what we expected to get before we reach out to Shelly; it was actually at the high end of our "ideal" range. Bottom line, we felt that Shelly cared about our family, making a stressful situation much less stressful, and helping us to get the best outcome and she delivered results that exceeded our expectations.

Seller review
Great experience!
about 3 years ago
Great experience!

Shelly was patient with my questions, gave great advice on getting our house prepared, and quickly sold our home at the right price. She was great with communication and I felt that she cared about the outcome of all involved, not just getting the job done. She was sweet and caring with a strong Christian character when dealing with all things concerning the sale of our house.

Seller review
childhood home
about 3 years ago
childhood home

Shelly was amazing in navigating me through the sale of mom's property. She was extremely helpful with the everchanging market. She was reliable, honest and professional throughout the entire process. I HIGHLY recommend Shelly and her company for the sale of your home!

Seller review
Above & beyond
over 3 years ago
Above & beyond

I live out of state and Shelly stepped up to help me evaluate the condition of rental property & what needed done to maximize the sale. Once listed, the house had 4 offers & sold within days.

Seller review
Above & beyond
over 3 years ago
Above & beyond

I live in FL and Shelly listed my home in Green. After listing, the furnace went out, we decided the house needed stainless appliances and the basement painted. Shelly handling all of that in my absence. She keep me up to date and was a pleasure to work with. I would recommend her without hesitation!

Seller review
Not the right realtor for us
over 3 years ago
Not the right realtor for us

Sadly, it wasn’t a great experience working with Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty and Shelly. It was a very stressful client/ realtor relationship. I wish we never signed that contract and found someone more local with more experience. They might work great for other people, but it just wasn’t a good match for us and once you sign the contract, Shelly will make sure to point it out every time you come to her with something you are unhappy with.

Seller review
Determined
almost 4 years ago
Determined

Shelly was determined to sell our house at the best possible price. She also was determined to find us another house based our specifications. She did and we are happy.

Buyer review
Great Job!
almost 4 years ago
Great Job!

Shelly was extremely responsive to all my queries and needs. She deserves an A+ for my experience purchasing a home that she listed and did a great job as a dual agent in the transaction.

Buyer review
Shelly cares about the happiness of her clients.
over 4 years ago
Shelly cares about the happiness of her clients.

My wife and I had begun looking for a home and chose an option to connect with a random realtor through Realtor.com. It was 10:30 at night and we could’ve gotten connected with anybody but we were incredibly lucky enough to be connected with Shelly! From our first meeting at a Panera to her handing over the keys for our new home, a process which took quite a bit of time due to the market, Shelly was on our side for anything we needed whenever we needed it. Anyone having trouble finding a home in this crazy market needs to connect with Shelly Booth. She is someone who will take the time and energy to get you in your home, not just a house. Because that’s who she is. She is someone who cares about the happiness of her clients not just the commission check.

Buyer review
My experience with Shelley Booth was very fulfilling, to say the least.
almost 5 years ago
My experience with Shelley Booth was very fulfilling, to say the least.

My experience with Shelley Booth was very fulfilling, to say the least. She worked very hard on finding the right home for my family and I. She friendly, very professional and knows her business. With her I achieved total satisfaction. I would highly recommend anyone wanting to purchase a home to contact Mrs Shelley Booth. She was a GOD SEND too us!!!

25 - 36 of 38
© 2026 RateMyAgent