Shelley's profile

Shelley's reviews

  5  
Shelley has 22 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
7 months ago
Third sale using Shelly for about two decades. Bottom line is trust.

Shelly sold a house for us in Alexandria over 7 figures about five years ago in addition to one in Haymarket near two decades ago. Present situation changed and we decided to return to VA to be close to family. Shelly guided us on purchasing our new home west of Port Royal and Skyline Drive. She was an absolute champ as our buying agent, with us still a thousand miles away on Southern Gulf Coast of Fl. Many negotiations and stumbling blocks but she methodically overcame each and every challenge. Her absolute honesty and willingness to invest the time is why she has represented us for a third time. And believe me this sale had its challenges. I would recommend Shelly to anyone, first time buyer to mega retirement mansion. There's a reason she was given all those awards.

about 1 year ago
Awesome. Shelley Is The Realtor You Want!

Shelley just made my life simple. As my realtor, I trusted her to make the decisions for me. She’s just the person you want at your side. Period.

about 1 year ago
Great Selling Experience, Under Contract in 3 Days

My husband and I had a great experience working with Shelley to sell our rental property. Shelley is always professional, knowledgeable and dedicated to making the process as smooth as possible. She handled the listing and negotiations with expertise and also helped us stage the home to make sure it looked it's best. We would highly recommend Shelley to anyone looking to buy or sell!

over 1 year ago
SOLD !!!!!! SOLD !!!!!!! SOLD !!!!!!!

Shelley is the best agent ever. She really does everything to ensure your home selling experience is definitely worth it. Her years of experience shine through as she assists you all the way thru the process and is extremely knowledgeable and great to work with.

almost 2 years ago
Excellent

We purchased and sold the same house with Shelley with positive results. She is extremely knowledgeable about the market. She listened to our needs and expectations and guided us with expertise through the process which in both cases we’re positive experiences. We were moving out of state to a much smaller residence and she was remarkable with helping us find new homes for our furniture. Made our move so much easier. She was always available to answer questions. I only have positive things to say about Shelley. She sold us house in two days! can often be challenging. We were moving out of state to a much smaller residence and Shelley helped us find new homes for our furniture. She was always available to answer our questions. Other things I live about Shelley—she’s so personal and sold our house in two days!

almost 2 years ago
Great Teammate

If you need a resourceful, honest, hard working, well connected advocate look now further than Shelley. I have used her in five real estate transactions, buying and selling throughout my military career, under some tough situations. Most recently she both found and purchased a property for our family while relocating from a Hawaii duty station. She stepped into a complex funding strategy with NAF Cash (who I do NOT recommend) and battled with less capable listing agents (Jim Gaskil who I would NEVER do any business with) allowing us to go door to door from Hawaii to Haymarket! If the future construct is buyers now have to pay their own agent fees, buy yourself some peace of mind and use Shelley Mastro!

almost 2 years ago
Above and beyond

Shelley is absolutely the best realtor my wife and I have ever dealt with. Her knowledge of the industry and her ability to get things accomplished is second to none. Not only is she knowledgeable but she has the best personality and was so easy to work with. My wife and I felt like we had known her all our lives. My only regret is that I wish we would of known about her for all of our previous home buying experiences !

about 4 years ago
Great Experience !

Shelly is very knowledgeable and stayed on top of all of the details to make sure the sale of the house went smoothly. She was very communicative and informative and made sure everything was ready before we went to closing. She did a great job communicating with the prospective buyer and helped us list our home at the optimum price to sell. She also helped us prepare our home to present a better showing. Working with Shelly was a great experience and would definitely utilize her services again in the future when buying or selling a home.

about 4 years ago
Great realtor!

Shelley did a great job selling my house. Several complications came up during the sale but Shelley was able to navigate things to a positive conclusion. I can’t recommend her enough!

about 4 years ago
Dedicated and fabulous!!

Shelley is extremely professional and has great knowledge of her industry! We loved working with Shelley and so will you! She is a GET IT DONE type of agent - the kind of agent you want working for you!

about 4 years ago
Awesome Experience

Shelley was fabulous. Throughout the process, Shelley was honest, forthright, and helpful. Highly recommend Shelley! She was amazing!!!

over 5 years ago
A 5 star experience

We are very happy with Shelley’s approach to selling our home. She is honest, professional and treats her client as if they were her family. I will definite recommend her to my family and friends. 5 Stars all the way...

1 - 12 of 22
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent