Sheena's profile

Sheena's reviews

  5  
Sheena has 61 reviewsacross 30 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sheena's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, proactive, dedicated, reliable, attentive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Exception service, trusted partner, outstanding support
about 1 month ago
Exception service, trusted partner, outstanding support

Working with Sheena Crompton of The Fletcher Team was an outstanding experience. I was selling my mother's home in Colorado while living on the east coast, so I needed someone I could completely trust to manage the property on my behalf. Sheena exceeded every expectation. She took the time to get to know me and my brother before we listed the house. She was the only agent we interviewed (we interviewed 4 agents) who showed any interest in us before talking about the house and her approach. She was thorough and came prepared with market comps and suggestions on how to best prepare the house for sale. From the beginning, she took ownership of every aspect of the sale process. She coordinated professional staging, provided excellent recommendations to maximize the home's appeal, and regularly checked on the property after I had moved away. Her communication was proactive, timely, and thorough, giving me confidence that everything was being handled properly despite the distance. After the buyers' inspection, Sheena leveraged her extensive network of trusted contractors and tradespeople to quickly complete the required repairs. She coordinated the work, ensured it was completed to a high standard, and kept the transaction moving forward smoothly. Sheena's professionalism, responsiveness, and dedication made what could have been a very stressful long-distance sale remarkably easy. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She is knowledgeable, resourceful, and genuinely committed to her clients' success.

Buyer review
We worked with Sheena and when Sheena wasn't available Keri helped and both were very helpful, frien
about 2 months ago
We worked with Sheena and when Sheena wasn't available Keri helped and both were very helpful, frien

We worked with Sheena and when Sheena wasn't available Keri helped and both were very helpful, friendly, patient, throughout the whole process they were very professional, we started out just occasionally browsing homes even though we weren't ready to buy, and we were never pressured, Sheena listened to our needs and always sent us homes for about almost a year until we were ready to buy, so we appreciate the team staying committed and providing the best customer experience we can ever ask for.

Buyer review
Sheena is full of knowledge, patience, and charisma
about 2 months ago
Sheena is full of knowledge, patience, and charisma

As first time home buyers we were full of questions and uncertainty on how to go about the home buying process. Sheena answered anything we threw her way, helped us identify things to look at when touring homes, and overall made our home buying process smooth. I can't even count the number of houses she showed us along the way, but she was patient with us the whole time. Her knowledge and negotiation skills helped us win the offer on our house and we couldn't be happier. A big thank you to Sheena for being so amazing!

Seller review
Phenomenal performance by a truly EXCEPTIONAL Real Estate Professional!
2 months ago
Phenomenal performance by a truly EXCEPTIONAL Real Estate Professional!

Phenomenal performance by a truly EXCEPTIONAL real estate professional! As a veteran homebuyer who has worked with many Realtors over the years, I can confidently say Sheena Crompton soundly outclassed them all. We will never work with another agent again—full stop. If you’re looking for a Realtor who truly knows the Colorado market, understands the nuances of negotiating transactions, and can seamlessly facilitate pre-sale home repairs or upgrades, look no further than Sheena. We just closed a high-stress home sale requiring over $50,000 in repairs. Sheena coordinated multiple trades—including plumbing, roofing, deck and fence work, interior/exterior paint, HVAC, staging, and lawn care—and still got the home listed and sold within a tight 30-day window. Her professionalism and work ethic are superior, and honestly, her commission is a bargain. She’s a "fire-and-forget" real estate cruise missile. Communicate your constraints, assign her the task, and let her get to work. You will not be disappointed—she is a MUST-HIRE!

Buyer review
Perfect Agent for First Time Homebuyers
3 months ago
Perfect Agent for First Time Homebuyers

Being first time homebuyers, we had a ton of questions throughout the process, and we truly couldn’t have asked for a better agent than Sheena to guide us through it all. She was incredibly responsive, knowledgeable, and always gave us honest, direct information that helped us feel confident in every decision we made. Sheena was consistently one step ahead of everything, which made the entire process feel so much less overwhelming. She was not only extremely hardworking and attentive to what we wanted, but also incredibly personable and genuinely invested in helping us find the right home. She went above and beyond to make sure we got exactly what we were looking for, and we couldn’t recommend her more highly. Thank you, Sheena, for making such a big and stressful process feel exciting, manageable, and truly special!

Buyer review
Excellent flexibility
3 months ago
Excellent flexibility

During the search for houses Ms. Sheena was amazing we were able to look at so many houses. She was able to adjust search conditions and help narrow down houses. Even when I had to pull out of a contract due to reasons she was very clear on the options and was always available to clear up any of information and questions I had.

Buyer review
Sheena was the best realtor we could have asked for
3 months ago
Sheena was the best realtor we could have asked for

Sheena was the best realtor we could have asked for. She was extremely knowledgeable and honest when we were looking at houses and patient with us until we found the right one. We appreciated her genuine attitude and the entire team of professionals she recommended/works alongside.

Buyer review
Just amazing!
4 months ago
Just amazing!

Sheena was amazing every step of the way in helping us with this purchase. She was so knowledgeable and efficient and we cound not have gotten our dream property without her.Thank you!

Seller review
Incredible Agent Who Prepared Us Perfectly for a Successful Sale!
4 months ago
Incredible Agent Who Prepared Us Perfectly for a Successful Sale!

Sheena Crompton was outstanding from start to finish as our listing agent for our property in Monument. She did a ton of work with us leading up to the listing — staging advice, professional photography and videography coordination, market analysis, and prep recommendations — that made our home show-ready and positioned it perfectly for the market. Thanks to her thorough preparation, we went to market extremely strong and attracted serious buyers right away. Sheena was top-notch, handling every detail with professionalism and expertise. She communicated clearly, responded quickly, and negotiated confidently on our behalf. Her deep knowledge of the Monument area and genuine care for her clients made the entire selling process smooth and successful. We couldn’t be happier with the outcome. If you’re selling in this area, Sheena is the agent you want on your side! Highly recommend — 5/5 stars!

1 - 12 of 61
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent